4 ms·
Viruses have little ability to influence their spread; they depend entirely on human behaviours. It is physically possible to all-but eliminate the coronavirus
by roenxi 7y ago
Viruses have little ability to influence their spread; they depend entirely on human behaviours. It is physically possible to all-but eliminate the coronavirus worldwide in ~3 weeks if everyone magically knew when they were spreading the virus.
Reproductive numbers are important, but I'm not sure governments have really stepped up to the plate to explain how the virus spreads and what people need to do to stop spreading the thing. "Social Distance", "wash your hands" and sometimes "wear a mask" really lacks lacks explanatory power.
Given the vast costs the world has put up with so far to slow the coronavirus down, there is actually room in the conversation to have teams of people travel around and conduct some sort of training session on how not to spread this thing and have people actually act out simulations. There need to be finer grained tools than mass lockdowns and alternatives to tracking everyone with apps.
I've seen a lot of basic confusion on HN about whether masks even help. This is pretty clear evidence of uncertainty in the broad community about how to deal with respiratory viruses. I don't believe that is due to a lack of research; engineers have had the practical tools to research droplets in airflows work for more than a century now.
Even the fact that "SARS with a risk of asymptotic spread" didn't have world leaders slamming borders closed in Jan/Feb hints at a possible general misunderstanding of how virus spread works. There were other considerations at the time, but in retrospect more general education on the subject would have been well worth the time invested.
- oezi 7y agoAbsolutely correct. We need better understanding of how the virus spreads, but this is not an engineering problem but an epidemiology question. Record every infection contact and determine highest risk activities so these can be reduced.
- roenxi 7y agoEither or. I suspect the aeronautical engineers would be better people to ask than epidemiologists if it turns out the virus is mainly transported through the air. Turbulence and control thereof would be the most important factors. But these are exactly the sorts of things that shouldn't still be open for discussion after 4 months and global lockdowns. Even among the general public.