9 ms·
A Lesson from the Spanish Flu: Don’t End Restrictions Too Soon
- paypalcust83 7y agoAnd don't call it the "Spanish Flu," it's the "Kansas Flu."
- alvatar 7y agoI find it interesting that it’s ok to call it Spanish Flu (while it wasn’t even originated there), but is politically incorrect to call this one the Wuhan virus or the Chinese flu. Political correctness has always a political intention I guess.
- Gigablah 7y agoWhy is it "interesting" to you? Is it not an entirely natural progression, that people would start realizing the stigma arising from associating diseases to geographical locations, and start changing the status quo?
- alvatar 7y agoI agree with the stigma associated to locations. I believe this stigma also affects past events, even if less so. So I think the argument for renaming the 1918 pandemic holds as strongly as not naming any new one based on the geographical location.
- shazzzm 7y agoI think intent matters here. Spanish Flu is from so long ago it already has a universal name, whereas I think referring to COVID-19 as the Chinese virus is usually only done by people who'd like to blame China.
- rosywoozlechan 7y agoHow much blame does China deserve for the pandemic? No blame at all?
- cjslep 7y agoIn what way does assigning any blame help? Magically US citizens will be able to successfully sue China for lost wages? Magically there will be less deaths?
- rosywoozlechan 7y agoAccountability matters. When things go wrong it's important to assign blame to understand why things went wrong and how to prevent them in the future. So in this particular case, a way blaming might help would be to recognize those organizations and governments that were incapable of preventing the spread of the disease and to recognize in the future a quicker need to mitigate and not to assume China will take care of it, assuming China deserves blame. It may also help by recuperating the economic loss by holding those responsible for it and requiring payments. These are common things that happen in all walks of life and the international context is no different. People and countries shouldn't get to walk away from massive fuck ups if it is possible to hold them to account. At least we can try.
- Izkata 7y ago> When things go wrong it's important to assign blame to understand why things went wrong and how to prevent them in the future. Exactly. Things have recently been declassified that makes me very surprised pandemics like this hadn't already happened a few times in just the past few years. For example: https://news.yahoo.com/suspected-sars-virus-and-flu-found-in-luggage-fbi-report-describes-chinas-biosecurity-risk-144526820.html?guccounter=1 https://news.yahoo.com/suspected-sars-virus-and-flu-found-in...
- cjslep 7y ago
- arboc 7y agoIt's kind of a complicated issue. I do think that we should refer to the 1918 flu as just that. However, since that's so far back in the past, you won't find a lot of people pointing their fingers at Spain and accusing Spaniards of being inhuman scum. On the other hand, you have a LOT of people saying "Chinese flu" who then jump to the conclusion that the Chinese people themselves are to blame and inherently 'bad', aggravating racism against the Chinese. The Chinese government deserve a lot of criticism for so many things, including their persecution (and most likely execution in some cases) of Chinese citizens who reported on the pandemic. But hate crimes happening right now against Chinese, and people who happen to look remotely Chinese, are very real. I see little benefit in referring to the 2019 Coronavirus/COVID-19 as a "Chinese flu", while I see huge downsides. In sum, while I think "Spanish" flu is more factually incorrect, I see talk about a "Chinese" flu as more acutely harmful. So - 1918 flu, COVID-19, IMO.
- Gigablah 7y agoIt's ironic that you talk about stigmatization, yet indulge in baseless speculation about execution of pandemic reporters.
- arboc 7y agoI think "stigmatization" isn't quite the word for spreading disinformation/speculations about the actions of a government, but you're right. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-china-journalist/chinese-citizen-journalist-resurfaces-after-going-missing-in-wuhan-idUSKCN22515X https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-china-... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chen_Qiushi#February_2020_disappearance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chen_Qiushi#February_2020_disa... "Citizens reporting on the epidemic have been made to disappear" would be a more factual description. And as can be seen from the first article linked above, "disappearance" doesn't necessarily lead to a fatal end. There is some not-direct-but-still-relevant support for being inclined to think that death is not entirely out of the question for those reporters, e. g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Gong_practitioners_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Go... But again, I think you were right to call me out on speculating. We just don't know, and if there's one thing we don't need more of right now, it's speculation from non-experts like me. Thank you.
- cjslep 7y agoThis is a false equivalence and you even hint at that very fact yourself ("Spanish Flu" => Spanish first broke worldwide censorship vs "Wuhan Flu" => Place of origination). There was no worldwide censorship of Covid-19. So what must be "interesting" is the lack of any real argument being made in your post, instead leaving a convenient gap where an argument should be so everyone can get into a trollsy debate about projecting their own political feelings upon this awful contentless comment.
- alvatar 7y agoCorrect, my comment was devoid of opinion or arguments, it was just that, a comment. I also don’t see how your last paragraph contributes any better to a healthy debate though. Regarding the false equivalence though, I didn’t imply that, since I don’t think you need to go so deep into the interpretation of words. If any point was to be made in my comment is just the plain wording “Spanish/Chinese flu” associates the location and its people to the stigma. This, repeated over time, contributes to the social imaginary. Not every one knows the historical facts so well, and many people hearing the words “Spanish flu”, missing the context, will still make the negative associations. And let’s not forget that for a considerable part of the population in USA (not in Europe though), Spanish means “speaks Spanish”.
- chippy 7y agoI think I had heard that the Chinese amongst their normal population (not officially) called it the "Wuhan Flu" originally.
- Izkata 7y ago"Wuhan pneumonia", I think it was.
- xyzzyz 7y agoWe’re already locked for twice as long as we were for Spanish Flu.
- coopsmgoops 7y agoCounterpoint: The world is way more than twice as connected as it was then at a macro level.
- js8 7y agoNot only that, COVID19 also spreads slower. The incubation period is longer.
- EGreg 7y ago* Barro's calculation doesn't take into account the economic losses from an extended shutdown. But in an email, he says any decline in gross domestic product has to be weighed against the economic value of saving lives* Not so simple. Consider that the shutdowns themselves can lead to even worse consequences: https://mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSKBN21Y2X7 https://mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSKBN21Y2X7 And I just posted an article about millions becoming infected by tuberculosis, an even more serious issue. Here is the thing... The politicians and media in the west have utterly failed us, telling us not to wear masks. The WHO still continues to do this and YouTube censors anyone who disagrees. It’s not just bad for free speech — it’s irresponsible! In Austria, masks led to a 90% drop in cases, as they did across Asia. The lockdowns are a last resort, after public policy has failed to contain the outbreaks Masks are supposed to protect others from you. They keep the germs in, doesn’t let them escape when you cough or talk. An N95 mask with the valve is actually worse than doubling up surgical masks, because the germs can go through the valve under pressure. What good is social distancing and quarantines when residents use elevators? Masks on the other hand greatly reduce R0 and aerosols. Cuomo just found out the “shocking” statistic that most hospitalizations are from people who stayed home. Elevators play a huge role. Masks and gloves are a way to return back to work, restore social life in common areas too. Please watch this video: https://youtu.be/oScxm_xy1i4 https://youtu.be/oScxm_xy1i4
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- js8 7y ago> Consider that the shutdowns themselves can lead to even worse consequences Are you saying that when people cannot travel by airplanes, go to a theater or a restaurant, then this is inevitably causing children to die? What kind of sick society is that, which cannot make a different economic arrangement? I understand (obviously) there are jobs that are required for functioning of the modern society, but to claim that it cannot be organized (especially given we have Internet) so that people could avoid mass gatherings is insane.
- vertex-four 7y ago
- OatsAndHoney 7y agoThe title is just doublespeak. The article ends with the line: "At 12 weeks, he says, the benefits from a shutdown exceed the costs." The economy is a human invention, there is nothing natural about it. You can't go on the safari and find a wild S&P500. These consistent demands in the media for a blood sacrifice is outrageous and dehumanizing to the people that have to suffer the consequences.
- dkdk8283 7y agoWe will see a second wave of devastation in 6 months when foreclosures hit. We are fucked even if there isn’t a second infection uptick. The handling of this situation is a perfect demonstration of how the current political system fails us. Half the people want lockdowns to continue and cite research papers supporting the argument. The other half wants it to end so they can pay their bills. People are going to die. It can’t be helped.
- ekidd 7y ago> Half the people want lockdowns to continue and cite research papers supporting the argument. I don't think anybody who's thought about it for more than a few minutes wants the stay-at-home orders to continue indefinitely. I certainly don't, and it's not what my state has proposed. There are several states that are aiming for something like the South Korean solution: stay-at-home until the level of cases drops low enough that we can test mild symptoms, track contacts, and safely treat everyone who falls ill. This is literally the official proposal in my state, and we're relaxing the stay-at-home order now that the conditions are met. I won't pretend that this proposal will be easy to execute. IIRC, Seoul just re-closed all its bars after an infected partier visited four bars that hadn't been following the social distancing rules. As someone in my 40s, my risk of death is fairly low. But a substantial portion of hospitalized cases are younger people, and something like 30% of severe hospitalized cases are showing some loss of lung capacity, loss of kidney function, or micro-clotting with risk of stroke. I earn a living with my brain; stokes scare me. So you can reopen the economy all you want, but I'm not setting foot in a restaurant, movie theater, airplane or barbershop until I'm vaccinated (or recovered). Whenever possible, I'll be buying from merchants who offer curbside pickup or delivery. And I've been trying to support local merchants as much possible, including takeout from several local restaurants.
- supernova87a 7y agoUsing value of statistical life figures of the federal government, and lives potentially saved by the shutdown, we are still saving much more in life $ value than the cost of the shutdown on economic output. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/835571843 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/835571843 And, I might add, the situation isn't fully yet understood, so it's not like anyone making these calculations is doing so with the real known risk factored in.
- logicchains 7y agoOften public policy will use "quality-adjusted life years" saved as a more precise metric in decision-making, which allows for valuing e.g. an intervention that saves people 10 years of life on average more than one that saves 2 years of life on average. Using this metric, it's not clear that we're saving more in life $ value than the cost of the shutdown: https://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/economic-cost-of-flattening-the-curve/ https://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/economic-cost-o... .
- Scarblac 7y agoJust comparing the numbers is one thing, but there is an inherent unfairness: the risk of death is much higher in certain groups (mostly the elderly). And the economic damage is also distributed very unequally: some sectors are wiped out, some are barely hurt or even profit. So the cost is in one group and the benefit is in another. It can't be easily helped but it's extremely unfair.
- luckylion 7y ago"Life value" considers a life over the years, not life itself. The value isn't constant since the earning potential is a large part of that value. It should be obvious that it sinks with age, that is if you're 80, the projected earnings that you will achieve during the rest of your life is very different from the projected earnings of the same person at 20 years. If you wanted to take out an insurance that would pay you some sum for the rest of your life if you had an accident, that will also change dramatically if you're 20 vs if you're 80. Saying that the value is constant is a PR thing, not scientific, and it's not what "we" (as in governments, insurances, hospitals etc pp) do. We look at age. We'll prefer to give a new heart to a 20 year old vs a 89 year old.
- cm2187 7y agoI find it extraordinary that the goalpost has completely moved without even a debate about it. We were told to enter this lockdown to flatten the curve to under the capacity of the healthcare system so it is not overwhelmed. Now we are being told we can’t leave the lockdown as someone more could die, ie the objective is not to remain under the capacity of the healthcare system but to go to zero deaths at all costs. If the healthcare system has spare capacity, which seems to be the case pretty much everywhere, this lockdown is no longer justified.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rosywoozlechan 7y agoI also find it extraordinary that unelected health officials have been allowed to dictate the freedoms of millions of people. These bureaucrats are experts in health and not economics, politics, and law and we're all beholden to them. They're qualified in a specific and narrow field but their decisions are impacting so much more. There's more to our lives and well being than an r0 number. What we are experiencing right now is a considerable loss of freedom, this is what government intervention looks like, but into the most cherished aspects of our personal lives. How much of this control are governments going to try and hang on to after this is all over?
- didibus 7y agoAs far as I know, they are not allowed to dictate the freedoms of millions. They simply report and provide guidance from their angle of expertise, and it is up to elected officials to aggregate the advice of all their consulted experts and their own judgement and hopefully with a bit of listening to their populace as well, to make the decisions.
- lbeltrame 7y agoYou are correct. However, some elected officials have (for incompetence, or just wanting to deflect responsibility) completely abdicated from their functions, and they act (or say they act) like whatever the experts tell them. "We'll reopen when the scientists say so" was a common mantra the past two months in my country. That's an admission of giving up responsibility, IMO. On top of that, experts not always agree, which makes things even more confusing. Some say (again, my country) that masks and social distancing are "worthless" (in favor of indefinitely long lockdowns), others say that they might work, others say that they definitely work.
- tinus_hn 7y agoThe first problem with this article is that they calculate peoples worth based on expected earnings but as if they’ve still got their whole carrier ahead of them. But in reality Covid-19 just is not very dangerous for people under 50. And of course that whole reality thing where there is an end to giving people free money while nothing is being produced and the stores are not going to remain stocked if the factories are closed.
- foogazi 7y agoBut there are things being produced and factories are open
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/wggSS https://archive.md/wggSS