6 ms·
> The whole point of evolution is that only genes that promote survival and replication can make it through There are plenty of inheritable genetic physical di
by watwut 7y ago
> The whole point of evolution is that only genes that promote survival and replication can make it through
There are plenty of inheritable genetic physical diseases. The evolution is not machine to make us perfect not God. You can't treat it this way.
- mrmonkeyman 7y agoIt's a trade off as the poster said. Those genes that cause 99% to run slightly faster will cause a bad hip in 1%. Is it worth it? Apparantly it is.
- tomhoward 7y ago> There are plenty of inheritable genetic physical diseases So I can respond to something solid, can you name some?
- username90 7y agoThere are plenty, Huntington's disease is an example.
- tomhoward 7y agoHuntington's disease is one of a small number of conditions that is caused by a single-gene defect (along with haemophilia, and a few others). It's very rare. What is known about mental "illnesses" are that they sometimes manifest when certain combinations of genes are present, but not always, and when you look at the details of cases you can pretty much always find an outer-world factor that triggers the state (e..g, abuse, trauma, neglect etc). So we're talking about very different things.
- lostdog 7y agoHere's dozens of them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genetic_disorders https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genetic_disorders If you want a few well-known examples: Cystic fibrosis, Muscular Dystrophy, Canavan Disease, and Hemophilia. There's lots of obvious bad stuff floating around in our genomes. It's not surprising that the roots of mental illness, heart disease, diabetes, and others are hereditary too.
- tomhoward 7y agoOf the conditions you mentioned, cystic fibrosis and haemophilia are due to specific, single-gene mutations, and both are quite rare. There's a huge difference between conditions that are caused by a single-gene defect vs conditions that sometimes arise when a combination of genes are present/expressed in combination with other (e.g. environmental) factors. > There's lots of obvious bad stuff floating around in our genomes Too handwavy. Please be specific :)
- igravious 7y agoNot handwavy. They were specific. The article makes this exact point: “In the genes ------------ One pillar of this future approach is a better understanding of the genetics of mental illness. In the past decade, studies of psychopathological genetics have become large enough to draw robust conclusions. The studies reveal that no individual gene contributes much to the risk of a psychopathology; instead, hundreds of genes each have a small effect. A 2009 study found that thousands of gene variants were risk factors for schizophrenia. Many were also associated with bipolar disorder, suggesting that some genes contribute to both disorders. This is not to say that the same genes are involved in all brain disorders: far from it. A team led by geneticist Benjamin Neale at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston and psychiatrist Aiden Corvin at Trinity College Dublin found in 2018 that neurological disorders such as epilepsy and multiple sclerosis are genetically distinct from psychiatric disorders such as schizophrenia and depression (see ‘Mental map’).”
- tomhoward 7y agoMy point is that it's not "obvious bad stuff", and the continued presumption that it is is probably the reason why so little progress has been made in the field. Even that passage of the article you quote doesn't characterise the genes as "bad stuff"; just known genes that seem to correlate with the (contextually undesirable) conditions manifesting.
- igravious 7y ago
- martingoodson 7y agoAsthma, type II diabetes, obesity, Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, MS, etc
- tomhoward 7y agoJust as is the case for mental "disorders", none of these conditions are attributable to a known gene or gene combination, or have a 1:1 match between carrying a certain gene combination and having the disease (meaning there must be an environmental trigger in addition to the genetic predisposition). For almost all of them (possibly all of them in some cases), there is evidence of links with auto-immunity and the presence of active pathogens (including viruses, bacteria, funguses, etc), suggesting that the illness is related to the body's efforts to fight off or cope with pathogens, or to some effect of the pathogen's activity. Those who invoke conditions like Huntington's Disease and haemophilia are on more solid ground, as these are directly attributable to single-gene mutations. But these conditions are also very very rare, unlike mental "disorders".
- martingoodson 7y agoYou asked for 'inheritable genetic physical diseases'. I gave you a list. Now it seems you actually want a list of 'mendelian' genetic disease, i.e. those which are caused by a single genetic variant. Mendelian diseases are not the only sort of genetic disorder. This is a misunderstanding of genetics. Source: I was a university researcher in psychiatric genetics
- tomhoward 7y agoI'm making the distinction between illnesses that are directly caused by an identifiable genetic defect (e.g., Huntington's), and conditions that can arise when a certain combination of genes/genetic expressions are present but even then only arise some of the time. As a professional in the field you'll know the terminology better than me and that's great, but you must understand the distinction I'm trying to make. In the former case, we can clearly see a 1:1 causal link from genetic defect to the manifestation of the disease (whether it's a single gene or more is not central to the point). In the latter case, the genetic predisposition is there, but there must also be some other form of conditional trigger. One of your examples with which I'm quite familiar is asthma, which I've experienced at times in my life (though neither of my parents did). I started experiencing it at about age 9 (as an allergic reaction to dust, dust mite and possibly other chronic infections I had at that age). Then it stopped in my mid teens. Then it started again when I smoked tobacco in my 20s, then stopped as soon as I stopped smoking. Then it started again in my mid 30s when I was experiencing severe stress and anxiety, then it stopped when I undertook a combination of approaches to reduce the stress/anxiety in my life, and a dietary program and other remedies to reduce chronic infections. That was 6 years ago and I've not needed asthma medication ever since. The point is, there's nothing genetically deterministic about my asthma, given that it's come and gone through out my life and has been clearly influenced by environmental factors. Further, it's plausible that the asthma has been a beneficial symptom, to protect my body from allergens and pathogens, and signal that I needed to change my lifestyle. Certainly, it was a big part of what signalled to me that I need to stop smoking, and later to clean up my diet and make other improvements to my emotional and physical health. As I've proposed in several other comments, it's just as plausible that the conditions we regard as mental "illnesses" are likely not genetic flaws or other malfunctions at all, but rather beneficial adaptations that have been selected for by evolution (e.g., it's obvious how the presence of "ADHD" in a small percentage of the population would have been beneficial in prehistoric human tribes). Given this, our real challenge is to do a better job of interpreting and responding to these conditions, as several practitioners going back decades have already figured out how to do.
- golover721 7y ago> The whole point of evolution is that only genes that promote survival and replication can make it through While this has been true in our past, we as a species have completely diverged from this. We do everything in our power to save every life no matter what the disorder or weakness. So it is no longer survival of the fittest in the traditional sense. Whereas in the past someone with schizophrenia or major depression would not likely live a “normal” life and have children, now obviously it is very likely.
- tomhoward 7y agoThese genes didn't just appear in the last couple of hundred or even few thousand years. And the fact that they're widespread means they're selected for, not just not selected out.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoGenetic evidence suggest that the human population was bottlenecked to 3,000–10,000 individuals about 70,000 years ago. Not all that much time has passed since then, evolutionarily speaking, and whatever genetic predispositions were present in that tiny population are probably mostly still kicking around the gene pool. A disorder that doesn't cause problems before sexual maturity or that wouldn't pose an issue for a hunter-gatherer in the environment of evolutionary adaptation isn't really maladaptive, and there's no reason to suspect some number of such traits wouldn't be widespread. It can also mean that the normal state of the brain exists near a small number of other stable modes, and that a wide variety of small nudges would have similar effects. The article mentions that a study of schizophrenia found that it was characterized in part by extremely rare mutations, suggesting that the brain is at an unstable local maximum, vulnerable to degrading into schizophrenia if unbalanced in any direction. Schizophrenia may in a sense be a much hardier fallback mode of brain operation.
- tomhoward 7y agoMany of these "disorders" manifest before reproductive age; depression, anxiety, ADHD, bipolar, even schizophrenia occasionally. Think about the condition we currently call the "disorder" ADHD. We can easily imagine how the behavioural tendencies ascribed to it would have been beneficial in hunter-gatherer times; i.e., it would be beneficial to the tribe for a certain number of people to be restless and explorative, rather than being conformist and content doing repetitive tasks. Same goes for bipolar; think about how many of our leading writers, inventors, musicians are diagnosed bipolar, and how useful it would always have been to have had a few people with that kind of creativity and propensity for bursts of novel productivity in the tribe. And I can easily think of ways depression and anxiety are adaptive and supportive of survival, rather than not (for depression it's the ability to contemplate/reform a troubled life, and anxiety it's the avoidance of danger). Even schizophrenia in certain circumstances. And of course when we invoke Occam's razor, it makes far more sense that these genes are there because they're beneficial, rather than being there due to a historical accident.