3 ms·
Could you point me to your source for that quote? I'm not coloring his response when I call it a divisive political opinion piece. It's explicitly framed as "t
by wpietri 7y ago
Could you point me to your source for that quote?
I'm not coloring his response when I call it a divisive political opinion piece. It's explicitly framed as "the politics of the majority of people at Google is a big problem". And whether or not their initial request technically was broad enough to include his response isn't the issue.
Either Damore was reasonably smart, and he knew that this would at best be enormously divisive. Or maybe he was just incredibly clueless. (Personally I think it was the former.) When bosses (or anybody) ask for something, technically complying with the literal meaning of their words is not enough. One has to consider goals and context, and respond accordingly.
- piflon 7y agoHe was clueless, insofar as he made the mistake of trusting a giant corporation to be a good steward of a political space.
- wpietri 7y agoIt wasn't a political space. It was a corporate space that Damore used for an explicitly political end.
- kortilla 7y agoIt was a political space. The topic was literally about gender hiring policies.
- wpietri 7y agoTo the extent that every space is political, sure. But it's not like Google had declared themselves steward of a space devoted to political discussions. They're a business. Employees at work should keep in mind they're at work.
- zozbot234 7y agoThey expressly asked him to share his opinion about an extremely divisive, almost third-rail topic. You're just saying that his statement ended up being divisive as well, but that's tautological. It's simply not possible to be "politically neutral" about such a topic and say anything worthwhile.
- wpietri 7y agoCould you please point me to your source for the exact wording of their request?