6 ms·
Amazon in France pays sales tax, just like everybody. Sales tax in France is 20% (19,6% to be precise). Is that a problem for Amazon in France? It doesn't seem
by bambax 16y ago
Amazon in France pays sales tax, just like everybody. Sales tax in France is 20% (19,6% to be precise). Is that a problem for Amazon in France? It doesn't seem so.
I can't find a justification why online retailers should be exempt from sales tax; the reason invoked by Amazon US is that sales tax are a local tax, at the state level, and they happen to be located in a different state (they're always in a different state).
This reasoning is preposterous; the sales happens where the customer is, and that's where the tax is due. That's what will happen eventually; they are just buying time -- and not very elegantly.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoThey're not always in a different state. If you live in California, you pay sales tax on online purchases pretty much always.
- storborg 16y agoThat's because California has tax-hungry laws concerning what defines a "nexus" (a business's presence in the state). It's difficult for many companies to avoid creating a California presence, so they're stuck collecting California sales tax as if they were based there.
- Vivtek 16y agoDoesn't every state have similar laws? Indiana does - yet I don't normally pay sales tax online, because most of the companies aren't based in Indiana, whereas online companies really do tend to be in California.
- storborg 16y agoLots of states, but not every state. California is also of particular importance because it's so big: nobody would care as much if Delaware had laws like this. However, in California, even if you only have a physical presence in some remote part of northern CA, suddenly that affects your ability to sell to 37 million other people.
- 3am 16y agoI have firsthand experience in online retail and if California is 'tax hungry' for that reason, then every other state in the country is, also. If you have payroll in a state, you collect sales taxes for physical items shipping there.
- allwein 16y agoLikewise, back when CDNow.com was it's own company it was located right outside of Philadelphia. Living in Pittsburgh, having to pay sales tax when buying from CDNow was always a consideration when deciding to buy music from them or someone else.
- thematt 16y agoIt's not that the purchase is exempt from tax, it's that Amazon isn't responsible for collecting it. The onus falls on the consumer to pay the sales tax directly to the state. Nobody does though, which is why they want Amazon to collect it. If you're looking for justification, refer to the Supreme Court ruling that established it, which said that requiring these companies to comply with the varied sales tax rules and regulations of 45 states and some 7,500 different local taxing jurisdictions would burden interstate commerce.
- bambax 16y agoWhy don't they fight in court then? Cutting their affiliates lose looks really low; they should stand for them instead.
- dexen 16y agoPerhaps because fighting in court is costly and long, while asking your affiliates to petition their representatives to change law may be cheaper and quicker? And suggesting to the representatives jobs will be lost (still a big no-no in today's post-crisis mentality)? Never mind the tax paid to the state actually goes into improvement of local infrastructure, services etc.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThey probably will. They already have in other states. http://techcrunch.com/2009/01/13/new-york-court-dismisses-amazons-objections-to-paying-state-taxes/ http://techcrunch.com/2009/01/13/new-york-court-dismisses-am... I'm not a lawyer, but I believe they cannot file a lawsuit until they are actually harmed (i.e., after the law takes effect).
- chopsueyar 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locus_standi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locus_standi
- btilly 16y agoI can't find a justification why online retailers should be exempt from sales tax; This justification is to be found in the US Constitution where authority over interstate commerce is granted to Congress. This leaves states with no legal authority over interstate commerce. This reasoning is preposterous; the sales happens where the customer is, and that's where the tax is due. That's what will happen eventually; they are just buying time -- and not very elegantly. In theory, yes. In practice, no. Experience says that people don't voluntarily report or pay taxes on those sales to the state government. Furthermore state governments have proven unable to track down those sales without the cooperation of merchants. So if Amazon doesn't cooperate, those taxes don't get collected.
- wheels 16y agoAmazon's competitors in France also pay tax. That's the difference. The issue here is that the law is such that out of state vendors don't have to pay tax; Illinois is just trying to jigger a way to make Amazon have to pay anyway, because Amazon sells lots of stuff and they'd like the tax revenue. But that effectively gives their competitors a 10% pricing advantage, not to mention making accounting much more expensive.
- shareme 16y agoNo, read the damn paper..Illinois is bankrupt they are asking for sales taxes to get them out of debt..
- dpatru 16y agoIllinois should cut its spending.
- logicalmind 16y agoEven if that spending is money they are contractually obligated to pay based on contracts they made years ago?
- ultrasaurus 16y agoTaxpayers aren't prisoners, so there is some maximum rate you can get out of people before they start leaving. I doubt it's the case, but there is a non-zero chance that paying all their obligations are actually impossible. It's interesting enforcing contracts when my local government can sign a contract that we'll pay pensions for the next 40 years in exchange for a service now (say education), but I can move away after consuming it (or simply never become productive and pay taxes).
- logicalmind 16y agoYes, the taxpayers can leave. But on the other side are the people providing the service with whom the government has made these contracts. Some people took these positions based on the deferred compensation. If that goes away, there will need to be upfront compensation. If neither of those happen you won't find many qualified people willing to take those jobs. Both sides will get screwed.
- repiret 16y agoI disagree. Consider the following sequence of examples: 1. I have a store in Oregon, a US state with no sales tax. You live in France, and while on vacation here, you buy a trinket, and carry it home in your luggage. Clearly, I don't have to pay French sales tax. You might owe some import duty when you bring it home. 2. Suppose instead that the trinket is big and heavy, so rather than putting it in your luggage, you have me mail it to you. Its still pretty clear I shouldn't have to pay French sales tax. 3. When you get home, you like the trinket so much, you want a second one. You know that your cousin will be visiting the area, so you give her money, she gives it to me, and I mail you the second trinket. You probably still agree I don't have to pay French sales tax. 4. Suppose your cousin, and nobody you knew, was going to be near my store. So instead you hire an agent to deliver me the money instead. Now perhaps its starting to get a bit murky, but I don't see that the agent is morally different from your cousin, and the use of an agent should not avail me to French sales tax liability. If that agent is named "the postoffice", then what we have is a typical mail-order business. And I think you can make a good case that online business should be treated a lot like mail-order business. * * * Now if we repeat those examples with my store in California and you in New York, there are two differences. First, California has sales tax, so in the first example, California sales tax would unquestionably be owed. Second, at some point along the way to the last example, we became engaged in inter-state commerce. The United States constitution forbids states from regulating inter-state commerce. This has been construed to mean that mail-order business is interstate commerce, and as such, neither the state of the seller nor the state of the buyer have a right to impose sales tax. Online business has, correctly I believe, been treated the same as mail-order. Most states have a "use tax", which requires a tax be paid on new goods brought into the state for use in the state. The problem is out of state sellers can't legally be required to collect it, or even report enough details for the state to reasonably enforce it. Legal issues aside, allowing inter-state commerce to be used as a sales tax evasion scheme doesn't seem like good public policy. But the obvious fix - collecting sales tax for the locale of the buyer - is not logistically simple: states, counties and cities can all impose their own sales tax, so across the country there are thousands of different government authorities to which sales tax must be remitted and thousands of different tax rates which are constantly changing. Requiring every online seller to keep track of that - and exposing them to audit liability from all these different authorities, would not be beneficial to public policy either.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe issue is that Illinois has no right to issue laws governing the actions of people not located in Illinois. Illinois is free to demand that people who are located in Illinois pay sales taxes on their out of state purchases. If it has probable cause for believing one of it's citizens is evading taxes, it can even file a subpoena with Amazon for sales records.
- chopsueyar 16y agoDoes Amazon France pay for their employees' health insurance? What percentage of their paycheck has social security and medicare taken out?
- baddox 16y agoBy that logic, it's certainly fair for your family to pay sales tax if you live in, say, Illinois. But isn't it also reasonable to leave one state for another because of sales tax?