6 ms·
I mean good for them diversifying but it’s such a weird thing that of all the stuff to complain about on YT they go out of their way to mention having to tag vi
by Spivak 7y ago
I mean good for them diversifying but it’s such a weird thing that of all the stuff to complain about on YT they go out of their way to mention having to tag videos as appropriate for children and/or for children.
Like surely that’s such a tiny thing. It seems like the author is trying to muster up some nondescript hate for YT when they were going to move for ideological reasons anyway.
- ludamad 7y agoRight, it's essentially ragging on a complete product. No one would say, come to peertube, where you have no idea what is meant for your child!
- superkuh 7y agoThat actually sounds like good advertising to me. Allowing children to join ruins everything. Not because of the children but because parents cannot think rationally about their "safety" (as if you can be hurt over the 'net). They're neurologically hardwired to be biased and prioritize perceived safety over all other issues. This leads to crazy commercial policies re: children that effect everyone (and even worse laws).
- azangru 7y agoI wish there were a checkbox in account settings somewhere by ticking which you would essentially say, "I do not record videos for kids, just stop asking me already".
- detaro 7y agoThe "appropriate for kids" thing has caused a lot of concern for youtubers due to how relatively heavy-handed it is.
- CM30 7y agoYeah, this. Tagging a video as for kids doesn't just stop certain types of ads running on it, it also disables many core YouTube features there too. For instance, you can't use the miniplayer, add it to a playlist, etc. This puts creators of videos that might potentially appeal to kids in a bad situation, since either they tag it as such and watch their video get buried, or avoid doing so and hope YouTube or the FTC doesn't disagree with them.
- tehwebguy 7y agoYouTubers are beholden to YouTube, YouTube is beholden to advertisers. When advertisers realized that a stupid percentage of their ad spend was going to four-year-olds watching six hours of unlicensed Disney characters in kinky scenarios it was the perfect storm for change. Keeping perceived ad value up to advertisers is why creators even have the opp to monetize at the rate they do, so it’s really give and take.
- soulofmischief 7y agoIt has more to do with these recent YT changes causing big issues with monetization and community-building. Less revenue, but also comments are now disabled for example. If you make content which could in any way be aimed for kids, or has kids appearing in the video (with some nuances) then you don't get comments which are huge for building a community. And if you get it wrong, the video or channel could be demonitized altogether based on YT's interpretation. Essentially YT opted out of actually creating moderation tools and a team and instead just increased their ad revenue cut while placing further burden on independent creators who don't have millions in budgets to cushion this effect. https://www.theverge.com/2019/11/13/20963459/youtube-google-coppa-ftc-fine-settlement-youtubers-new-rules https://www.theverge.com/2019/11/13/20963459/youtube-google-...
- Barrin92 7y agoThe only reason you even have ad revenue is because the platform is in a state that allows the general public to use it. Yes, these things are hassles but on youtube you have access to an audience of billions, youtube eats the entire infrastructure costs and manages virtually everything for you. What do you get on peer tube, 500 views and laggy 480p videos, and no advertisement revenue at all?
- soulofmischief 7y agoI agree with you, and I have in mind a pretty decent solution worth exploring if I can generate the capital to throw at it. It involves separating the ad experience from the videos being consumed. You can still work out targeted deals, but the gist is that the advertiser generally has no control over which videos are seen before and after their ads and have no incentive to find out.
- Anon1096 7y agoThat's how it used to be, then people on social media such as Twitter started reporting things like "why is this Bounty ad next to a controversial figure like Pewdiepie". That's when companies paying for ads started to care and pulled funding.
- DanBC 7y agoThere's a weird mix of regulation and Youtube action that mean no-one (parents, youtubers, regulators) are happy with the current result. We want to protect children from predatory data harvesting, so we have laws like COPPA (in the US). YouTube's answer to COPPA was to just forbid children under 13 having their own account and launching Youtube Kids. Children under 13 want to watch youtube, and the content they want isn't always on YTKids, so they watch using a parent's account. They do this because they also want the like and subscribe buttons. But because YT doesn't know if it's a child or adult watching they serve ads for horror films or gambling or alcohol. But they also try to guess if it's a child watching the video and they'll serve ads for toys. Regulators were unhappy. Youtube tried to say to the regulators "we comply with coppa and we definitely do not target children for ads", but they were going to the potential advertisers and saying "we have the largest child audience and we know how you can reach them". Faced with further regulation Youtube bunted this onto the creators, and (weirdly, IMO) the regulators agreed and said that the creators (not Youtube) were responsible for ads placed against their content. Now you have content that is clearly, unambiguously, aimed at children where the Youtuber has to say the word "fuck" three times a video so they can tick the "not for kids" box to get decent ad revenue. There's a bunch of content that was fine for kids that now has to include tediously edgy shit just to avoid that "aimed at kids" classification. Youtube has no idea who is watching videos so the ad serving is awful. The regulators don't talk to each other but are clearly unhappy that unsuitable ads are pushed at kids. And parents are left not knowing if this content aimed at children actually is aimed at children or if it's going to include jokes about anal rape[1]. [1] On the off-chance that anyone from YouTube is reading this this is a real fucking example, but there's no way to tell you.
- Izkata 7y ago> And parents are left not knowing if this content aimed at children actually is aimed at children or if it's going to include jokes about anal rape[1]. > [1] On the off-chance that anyone from YouTube is reading this this is a real fucking example, but there's no way to tell you. Well, in the 90s they sometimes put adult jokes/puns in cartoons so adults would get something out of it and watch alongside their kids. Your example reminded me of this from Animaniacs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xmAC9Qu908 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xmAC9Qu908