2 ms·
Yes, I wrote a web spider that allows anyone who runs it to collect and index public, published data. If one were to run it, it does not violate anyone’s priva
by sneak 7y ago
Yes, I wrote a web spider that allows anyone who runs it to collect and index public, published data.
If one were to run it, it does not violate anyone’s privacy because it only indexes information from the public, unauthenticated web.
It’s a bit of a stretch to claim that I myself am collecting anyone’s data. I write software. As a point of fact, I have actually never spidered or indexed the Fediverse (yet).
The software I wrote sends requests to webservers, which are in no way obligated to reply to those requests with any information. This is how the web works, and the tool I wrote is no different than any other web spider/indexer from an ethical perspective.
ActivityPub users seem have interesting concepts of what it means to have “published”.
- kstrauser 7y agoSo, you want perfect privacy for yourself, but also it’s ethical and good to harvest and archive everyone else’s information because they haven’t explicitly blocked you personally from it. That’s why I have a bit of a hard time taking your complaints about Def Con seriously.
- sneak 7y agoI believe you may be confused. I do not wish any privacy whatsoever for the information I publish unauthenticated on the public web. Quite the contrary, I wish for the things I publish to be read and understood as widely as possible. That's how the web works: if your webserver (or web host, or mastodon instance, or whatever) receives a request for a webpage, and then it says "yes, sure, here's the webpage", and sends it to the requesting user, there's no ethical or moral framework which at that point says that the webserver has been wronged by the requesting user having that content. It literally sent it to them voluntarily. If you (or your server, or your host) hands out data to all comers, it is not reasonable to then say that those other people should not have access to that data. You (or your server, or your host) provided it to them.