3 ms·
I haven't "brought someone's personal details as ammunition". I have called someone by his name when had introduced himself by his name beforehand in his HN's "
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
I haven't "brought someone's personal details as ammunition". I have called someone by his name when had introduced himself by his name beforehand in his HN's "about". How can this be personal attack? Some would say I'm just being polite.
If he does not like it then perhaps he should not publish his name on HN or should write things that he is not ashamed of.
If you introduce yourself by "Hi I'm John" then you cannot complain that people call you John.
This is ridiculous.
- dang 7y agoI'm finding it a little hard to read your intent here. But that is secondary anyhow, because in the game of internet comments, what you did comes across as menacing and a move in the online callout/shaming direction. That's not allowed on HN, so please don't do it again.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoAre you saying that it is not allowed on HN to address someone by their name after they have introduced themselves? It's me who's not clear about your intent here... How can I call out/personally attack/shame someone that way? If their name was not available on HN I would agree with you, but, again, in this case the person voluntarily introduced themselves on HN first. I also note that the person in question still has their name in their HN's "about" so clearly they have no problem with it. Btw, my intent is that I don't like hypocrisy and posturing. It's hypocrisy to claim to feel offended and intimidated by me addressing that person by their name, which their freely published in their HN's "about", and you seem to be playing along. I'll move on now...
- dang 7y ago> Are you saying that it is not allowed on HN to address someone by their name after they have introduced themselves? We can't make a simple rule about this. Imagine someone posting "Oh my god, Joe Schmoe! We worked together at Acme Inc!" or whatever. That's harmless. But yeah, if you're in an argument with someone - don't go there. In that case it most likely signals personal aggression. I appreciate that you don't like hypocrisy and posturing. I don't either. But there can easily be distortion in our interpretation of such things online. We have so few data points on each other that whatever picture we receive is mostly how our own imagination has connected the dots; and we tend to fill in the blank spaces with material from our own darker side. The net result is that we end up feeling surrounded by our own demons on the internet - I've written about this in the past: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20demons&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu.... That clearly doesn't take us to good places, so we need to guard against it.