4 ms·
Should LA urbanize? I find the lack of density to be a benefit, not a problem. The problem is rather the lack of public transport + lack of self-driving, green
by keiferski 7y ago
Should LA urbanize? I find the lack of density to be a benefit, not a problem. The problem is rather the lack of public transport + lack of self-driving, green vehicles + lack of widespread remote work. Making LA as dense as Seoul or NYC would kill the unique vibe it has IMO.
There are many cities in the world which manage to have effective public transport and not be ultra-dense. Warsaw, in Poland, is a good example and probably one more useful in a comparison to LA, as both cities are mostly flat, sprawl for miles/kms and have large road systems that can’t easily be removed and replaced. Berlin is another good example, although it’s more dense than Warsaw.
- bestnameever 7y agoI agree. Change L.A and many of the reasons why people who live in L.A love L.A go away. Although others will find to love it for other reasons.
- xvedejas 7y agoLA's high housing price is one of the top social issues that people who live there face, due to low supply. I think a little bit more urban character in exchange for lower rents is a fair price to pay. I lived in the LA area for five years and found that the more urban areas were the more lively and interesting, but there were a lot of dead sprawling areas too. LA stands to gain a lot from having more of the former and less of the latter. I suppose I agree that becoming Seoul is not necessary; but the lack of density isn't ideal.
- keiferski 7y agoI agree that building more housing is good, however: better public transit, self-driving cars, and remote work are a far more viable path for LA than turning it into a super-dense city.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoYou can’t really have good public transport in LA because the distances are so huge.
- bogomipz 7y agoYes you can and LA actually already had quite an extensive public transport called the Pacific Electric network. The last of it was dismantled around 1961-63. They were replaced with diesel buses. These are some maps. The ehra.org site has some good timeline and some cost figures as well. https://www.transitmap.net/pacific-electric-1925/ https://www.transitmap.net/pacific-electric-1925/ http://www.erha.org/pesystem.htm http://www.erha.org/pesystem.htm And here is a link to LA Times article some details about what actually happened: https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-california-retrospective-red-car-20160103-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-california-re...
- throwawaysea 7y agoI agree. Today’s “urbanists” are so very opinionated and unable to process or accept that not everyone wants to live in their version of the world. Cities with lesser density have many quality of life benefits and cultural differences that denser cities cannot replicate. The correct question is indeed “should LA urbanize” and my answer is “no”. I suspect most Angelenos would agree. Here in Seattle, most long time Seattleites also don’t want it to urbanize further and turn into another SF. The urbanists, however, are quite vocal and will likely continue to push for their monoculture, a one size fits all recipe on how everyone everywhere should live. I really wish they would accept that different people and different locales have different ways of doing things, and that this is a good thing.
- ajmurmann 7y agoAnother SF? Most problems SF has are because it's refusing to urbanize.
- throwawaysea 7y agoI feel this is a narrow perspective because it focuses on a subset of problems and doesn’t recognize all the other problems of benefits that are in the balance. Low density living is great for many of us - the open spaces and air gives the city a certain aesthetic, and it does create a certain culture and sense of community that has been disappearing as the city has changed in the last several years. I would like to see us retain those things.
- keiferski 7y agoThis person meant from the perspective of the original SF inhabitants. 50-60 years ago, before the tech industry moved in, SF was sort of a weird, sleepy counter-cultural city where hippies and Beats hung out. Sort of like: a crowd of people moves into your house, making it uncomfortably overcrowded. You refuse to build an extension to the house in order to give everyone more space, as it would destroy the architectural reasons that made you wanted to live there in the first place. Who’s at fault? Tough question. It’s unclear if urbanization trends made this inevitable or if there are/were better ways to deal with gentrification.
- summerlight 7y ago> The problem is rather the lack of public transport + lack of self-driving, green vehicles + lack of widespread remote work. It's basically about the infrastructure cost and higher density actually helps a lot to reduce this cost and make the system more sustainable. Yes, theoretically you can have good infra without high density, but it will cost much more. There's a good reason why the most dense cities in the world (Beijing, Shanghai, Seoul and Tokyo) have the most advanced public transportation system. Even in the US, cities with an acceptable mass transit tend to have decent levels of density.