3 ms·
> the corpus frequency of "Prince" 王家 What? 王家 doesn't mean "prince". Or at least, there is no such dictionary entry in the ABC dictionary or in the 汉语大词典. I w
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> the corpus frequency of "Prince" 王家
What? 王家 doesn't mean "prince". Or at least, there is no such dictionary entry in the ABC dictionary or in the 汉语大词典. I would expect 王家 to mean "prince's household", in the same way that 皇家 means "imperial household".
汉语大词典 has two glosses for 王家:
1. 犹王室,王朝,朝廷。 [Equivalent to "royal family"/"royal court".]
2. 王侯之家。 [An aristocratic household.]
There's no problem with the concept of the phrase 王家庭 meaning "prince's courtyard", since a home can easily contain a courtyard. But the phrase should arguably be segmented 王-家-庭. (Or not -- there's very little to distinguish the idea 'one word, "the prince's household"' from 'two words, "prince"/"household"'.) Regardless of that choice, the courtyard is being associated with a household, not a person.
- numpad0 7y agoSo to illustrate the situation the input would be like “Royal, House, Hold” and whether it’s supposed to be “Royal-Household” or “Mr. Royal’ household” or “Royal House, hold ... ” is up to context right
- thaumasiotes 7y agoCorrect, though just to be clear, "hold" doesn't correspond to anything in the Chinese. (I only mention this because on a character-by-character basis, "royal" and "house" are fairly decent glosses of 王 and 家.) "King" is also a decently well-known English surname, so we can draw a pretty close analogy to the distinction between 王家, the royal household, and 王家, the 王 family. Compare the English sentences 1. That's the king's house. [The king lives there] 2. That's the Kings' house. [The Kings live there]
- jcampbell1 7y agoMy Chinese ability rounds down to non-existant, and I apologize for constructing a questionable example. Wang as a family name, and Wang as king or (royal-) was the first thing that came to mind. Since you know Chinese well, do you know of a good example of a 1-2, vs 2-1 split where both are reasonable but one is much more likely to be semantically correct? I have been told there are quite long sentences that humorously can be segmented two ways and have completely different meanings, but I can't find any. My favorite in English is expertsexchange.com had to change the domain to experts-exchange.com :)
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> I apologize for constructing a questionable example No need; as an example of segmentation, the one you've presented is fine. The biggest problem, mostly irrelevant, is that "prince's courtyard" is pretty archaic. I was objecting to the translation-in-passing of 王家 as "prince". It's defensible to segment the "prince's courtyard" sense 1-1-1, but it's also defensible to segment it 2-1. I don't have an example of the type of you're looking for to hand, but I will see about finding one.