9 ms·
Vitamin D looks powerful, underutilized for Covid-19
- gremlinsinc 7y agoNot by me. I'm D-deficient, had gastric sleeve surgery, surprisingly it's the only deficiency I have regularly. I often forget my D... but been taking it religiously and asked my doctor if it's okay to add an extra 5000 iu per week, and he said it was fine and a good idea because of how low I normally run. I've got a new formulation coming soon though that has vitamin k mixed in w/ 5000 ius, and a separate calcium/magnesium pill to make sure my bones stay strong. Will get re-tested next month and see if I beat the deficiency. I'm sure there's plenty of things but seemed like taking D probably is biggest (other than distancing) due to my already extremely low normal levels.
- open-source-ux 7y agoIs it safe to take a high dose of vitamin D in supplement form? I ask only because the National Health Service (NHS) in the UK warns not to take more than 100 micrograms of vitamin D. 5000 iu (International units) is approximately 125 micrograms of vitamin D. Here is what the NHS website says: "What happens if I take too much vitamin D? Taking too many vitamin D supplements over a long period of time can cause too much calcium to build up in the body (hypercalcaemia). This can weaken the bones and damage the kidneys and the heart. If you choose to take vitamin D supplements, 10 micrograms a day will be enough for most people. Do not take more than 100 micrograms of vitamin D a day as it could be harmful. This applies to adults, including pregnant and breastfeeding women and the elderly, and children aged 11 to 17 years." https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/vitamins-and-minerals/vitamin-d/ https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/vitamins-and-minerals/vitamin-...
- vegannet 7y agoI am not a doctor but fwiw I was told by an NHS doctor that the most recent scientific understanding of vitamin D is that the recommended dose (based on old science) is far too low and 5000 per day is a good amount for someone in the UK (due to the amount of sunlight we get on average here).
- youareostriches 7y agoUnits, please. He said micrograms and it sounds like you’re talking about IU.
- sudoaza 7y agoRemember hearing a podcast (the drive peter attia with someone else) and they were saying up to 10k iu there is no harm, anyway I heard somewhere else that vitamin D also overexpreses ACE2 so you probably just want to take between 1k and 2k covid 19 wise. Not a doc though
- lonelappde 7y agohttps://www.healthline.com/nutrition/how-much-vitamin-d-is-too-much#section3 https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/how-much-vitamin-d-is-t... "According to the Institute of Medicine, 4000 IU is the safe upper level of daily vitamin D intake. However, doses up to 10,000 IU have not been shown to cause toxicity in healthy individuals" Probably God to avoid testing the limit if you can. Are you sure you are a "healthy individual", if you've already diagnosed a health problem that vitamin D can treat?
- lonelappde 7y agoWow. 1 IU is the biological equivalent of 0.025 mcg cholecalciferol or ergocalciferol Is there any nutrient that is essential in a smaller quantity than that?
- randallsquared 7y agoMy doctor believes it's safe, at least. I take 15000 IU on his advice (ramped up in 5000 IU increments until my bloodwork came back with acceptable levels).
- tracker1 7y agoWorth considering if you're eating too little fat, you may have problems with absorption of fat soluble vitamins like D and K.
- vecter 7y agoThis is a great callout and a good warning for folks. I've had mild Vitamin D deficiency which was diagnosed by a doctor many years ago. I was given Vitamin D supplements, which I stocked up on more than usual recently due to my staying in all day due to WFH and not getting any sunlight. I used to take 50mcg of D3 1-2x a week and I upped that (without consulting a doctor) to 5x a week. Within two weeks, I started having extreme thirst. It was crazy to the point where I drank so much water that I could hear it sloshing in my stomach yet my mouth was parched dry and I was still very thirsty. I did a quick Google search and found that this was actually a thing [0]. I stopped my Vitamin D supplements the next day and my thirst went away that same day. Be careful folks. [0] https://www.express.co.uk/life-style/health/1203879/vitamin-d-deficiency-symptoms-supplements-too-much-excessive-thirst-foods https://www.express.co.uk/life-style/health/1203879/vitamin-...
- httpsterio 7y agoI read somewhere that prolonged high doses of vitamin D might have adverse effects on bone strength making them more brittle, but I'm unsure about the source. I personally have celiac disease and hypothyroidism am also having issues keeping the D up (heh heh). I take about 200ug daily with vitamin K and I'm thinking about increasing it temporarily to double of that. Generally it shouldn't be an issue with short term higher doses, but nearing a 1000ug daily dose for prolonged periods (months) can be dangerous.
- teilo 7y agoThat is only true if you also have a potassium deficiency and low K2-MK7. That's why, when testing D levels, it's also important to test Ca levels. And even then, you have to be taking very high levels of D. More on the order of 50K UI a day for a long time.
- thornjm 7y ago(Med student here with only limited knowledge). This is correct. The active form of Vitamin D (Calcitriol) can be both helpful and harmful to bone health. I think the mechanism is not fully understood but in short doses it stimulates bone growth and is a treatment for osteoporosis. In chronic doses it actives cells caused osteoclasts that reabsorb bone.
- woofie11 7y agoDo you know the breakpoint? What's a short dose, and when does it become chronic?
- Harvesterify 7y agoCholecalciferol is used in over the counter supplements, not calcitriol (which is the active vitamin D form). There also is a negative feedback for the conversion, that explain why there are so few acute vitamin D poisoning.
- macawfish 7y agoI believe that's why some nutritionists recommend supplementing with Magnesium when taking vitamin D.
- DTrejo 7y agoI hope your K formulation also has K2, which seems like the more important and bioavailable one.
- jeffdavis 7y agoAnd if people hoard it and it's out of stock, you can just go outside!
- samatman 7y agoIt doesn't take hoarding, although that doesn't help. There are precious few products that can stay on the shelves when everyone decides they need some at once. At northern latitudes, there isn't an available amount of sunlight, such that dark-skinned people can synthesize a healthy amount of vitamin D. Indeed, this is probably why light skin is selected for at those latitudes. As a silver lining, I hope this crisis will provoke awareness of that fact. In most parts of the US, people with dark skin should definitely be taking supplemental Vitamin D. Really everyone should, unless they're a light-skinned sun-worshipper living in the Sun Belt.
- jeffdavis 7y agoEven if only white people are able to improve their outcomes, isn't that still a lot of people that would benefit? It seems like you're being a bit too negative here. It might be enough to slow the virus, which helps everyone. And maybe the supplements are easy enough to make... They can probably be ramped up long before a vaccine comes along.
- lonelappde 7y agoNo. Avoiding a stroke spreads virus more than having a stroke and dying.
- jeffdavis 7y agoI'm confused. If vitamin D imoroves covid outcomes, and supplements run short, shouldn't we be happy that vitamin D is naturally accessible to many people? It's harder to obtain naturally for blacks living in Seattle than whites living in Arizona. But it's still a good thing if it reduces covid deaths, right? And may slow the spread, therefor benefitting everyone?
- jeffdavis 7y agoA double-blind study for respiratory infections (before covid-19): https://www.bmj.com/content/356/bmj.i6583 https://www.bmj.com/content/356/bmj.i6583
- Exmoor 7y agoPrevious Vitamin-D/COVID discussion with many informative comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23023703 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23023703
- Alex3917 7y agoFor what it's worth, I've been curating research on over-the-counter interventions for Covid-19 here: https://www.reddit.com/r/covid19stack https://www.reddit.com/r/covid19stack The research on vitamin D has been discussed extensively there over the last couple months. This article (and the linked citations) misses a bunch of the most important theorized mechanisms of action, most notably that vitamin D plays a role in regulating blood clotting and having adequate levels may prevent the kind of sudden deaths from stoke we've been seeing in people who seemed to have gotten over the disease with otherwise mild symptoms.
- kpfleger 7y agoAuthor of the review here. Happy to have addition suggestions for papers to include in the review. I looked at the Reddit group you linked and saw only citations of Alipio et al and Grant et al (from several posts), both of which I already cite. The review says of the Grant et al paper that it "broadly reviews evidence for D to help with infectious diseases, pneumonia, and inflammatory cytokines that damage the lungs and discusses some of the aspects of COVID-19 infection that are known to relate to things known to be also relevant to vitamin D." So not quite sure what it is that you are suggesting be covered that is not. The review is not meant to be a thorough description of the biology at the intersection of vitamin D & COVID-19. The point of bring up the refs I have in section 8 is to point out that there are good causal mechanistic biological arguments for D's usefulness against C19, to help justify a call for additional data gathering. Your reddit group looks fine and all, but it isn't the same as a single document that concisely collects all the best evidence for the potential of vitamin D in a well organized way.
- cleandreams 7y agoVitamin D is under studied because it cannot be patented (my doctor told me).
- tootie 7y agoYour doctor is talking nonsense. There's mountains of studies on things that can't be patented. We don't have studies on much of anything wrt COVID-19. And most of the energy has gone to hydroxychloroquine whose patent expired long ago.
- ColanR 7y agoI've heard the same thing. No economic incentives compared to making a custom drug.
- qayxc 7y agoYou've heard nonsense. There's tons of studies and clinical trials about the use of vitamin D. Here's an article listing just a few: https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/322619 https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/322619 Every time you "hear" something about a topic that's important (e.g. in this case: health), just don't take anyone's word for it (doctors are people, too and have their cognitive biases and non-fact based opinions). It's not that hard to look this stuff up and just do a quick check in relevant publications or sites like research.net - https://www.researchgate.net/search/publication?q=vitamin%20d https://www.researchgate.net/search/publication?q=vitamin%20... - to get a more accurate picture.
- ninetyfurr 7y agoSunlight as a treatment for COVID-19? Where did I hear about this before.
- tinus_hn 7y agoPerhaps irradiating yourself with UV rays might help after all!
- synaesthesisx 7y agoThere was some discussion about this on another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23079976 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23079976 Essentially, one of the theories is that severely low Vitamin D can cause a hypercoagulable state and also increase the risk of the “cytokine storm” often observed in Covid-19 patients.
- sirsuki 7y agoHere is a fantastic list of compelling resources about Vitamin-D: https://www.grc.com/health/Vitamin-D.htm https://www.grc.com/health/Vitamin-D.htm
- cpncrunch 7y agoNot a very good review. We know that sunlight exposure is associated with lower all-cause mortality [1]. However, vitamin D supplementation has no effect on mortality [2]. Current thinking is that it is the nitric oxide rather than vitamin D that causes the benefit from sunlight [3]. So, if you want to have the best of both worlds, you should go out in the sun rather than using vitamin D supplements. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24697969 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24697969 [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31405892 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31405892 [3] https://www.karger.com/article/FullText/441266 https://www.karger.com/article/FullText/441266
- lern_too_spel 7y agoMoreover, more outside time is associated with many other healthful activities. The correct model is that people who care about their health spend more time outside and therefore have higher vitamin D levels, not that higher vitamin D levels cause a dramatic effect on health. Taking vitamin D supplements if you are not deficient isn't going to make you care about your health more and is unlikely to have a significant effect on your mortality.
- snth 7y agoDon't people who take Vitamin D supplements _also_ care more about their health though?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stevehawk 7y agoEh or just want to pretend to care about their health and the cost of being guilt free about it is a monthly vitamin D bottle.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoIn that case, the direction of causality is also reversed. Caring about health -> higher vitamin D, not the other way around, exemplifying my point. It's the caring about health that significantly reduces mortality, not the vitamin D, so implementing vitamin D supplementation as public policy to fight Covid-19 is unlikely to have an effect.
- fattire 7y agoDr. John Campbell, an educator in Northern England who's been doing daily Youtube updates on Covid news since January I believe, has put out a few videos from time to time related to vitamin D: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5yVGmfivAk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5yVGmfivAk - A month ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCSXNGc7pfs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCSXNGc7pfs - 3 weeks ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-mHCn74E5o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-mHCn74E5o - 3 days ago He suggests vitamin D deficiency may play a partial role in explaining higher mortality rates among people with darker skin (other important social disparities notwithstanding).
- sslalready 7y agoI believe he has claimed that vitamin D deficiency is associated with worse upper respiratory tract infections in one of the earlier videos.
- t0mmel 7y agoHe did. And he recently did a video talking about british research, which, having adjusted for socio-economic factors showed that the darker the skin colour the more likely the person would be to develop complications. His point here was that, dark skin impedes vitamin d generation.
- Cantbekhan 7y agoIt should be noted that while he does have some qualifications due to being a nurse and a nursing teacher, he's a Doctor in Philosophy and not in any medical/science field. It doesn't dismiss his claims per se but I still think he's using his Doctor title in a somewhat misleading way in this Covid19 context where a lot of people seem to think he's actually a medical doctor which he's not (edit: and this can be easily verified by just skimming through most comments on his videos which praises him in that regard).
- fattire 7y agoThis is kinda true, though he has earned the right to call himself a doctor, and I dunno if he should have to constantly have to add "though not in medicine!" Maybe he should? I don't know if "misleading" is the right word. He does seem to have expertise in the nursing field he's teaching FWIW, but yeah I researched him several months ago and found his linked in page which said the doctorate is in philosophy.
- whoisjuan 7y agoCan someone tell me why HN is so obsessed with Vitamin D? I see a Vitamin D related article on the front page every few months. Also, https://hn.algolia.com/?q=vitamin+d https://hn.algolia.com/?q=vitamin+d shows a lot of articles about Vitamin D with a lot of upvotes. Note: I supplement with Vitamin D daily, so no hate at all, just curious.
- riffic 7y agoPeople who spend a lot of time indoors are generally deficient.
- drawkbox 7y agoProgrammers tend to not go outside as much, in the batcaves creating value many times in the dark of night.
- mcswell 7y agoBring up a picture of the sun on your monitor?
- mustachionut 7y agoA low-cost Vitamin D blood test was FDA approved in 2011, and since then Vitamin D deficiency diagnoses have skyrocketed. Plus, the narrative works (humans need sun for vitamin D, but now humans are inside, thus humans need to supplement D).
- thinkingemote 7y agoMy guess would be, its a low toxic, proven beneficial substance that health hackers can play with. Less controversial politically than drugs. Additionally those in North Europe and Canada often cannot get it naturally for about a third of the year.
- nemo44x 7y agoNot sure but I’ll submit a hypothesis that many people here sit inside mainly dark spaces all day and don’t always feel great. And because that doesn’t seem avoidable, hacking the system is a natural action of many here. We all know we should probably get outside more for health.
- DanielBMarkham 7y agoAs a layman observer of the scientific debate, the Vitamin D guys have been quite persistent about the correlation between Vitamin D levels and deaths. Is there causality? Beats me. The best I've heard by way of explanation is that inflammation depletes Vitamin D stores. That idea is usually followed-up with the additional theory that CV-19 causes inflammation and high platelet activity, clogging up small blood vessels and producing most of the major effects that are observed.
- kpfleger 7y agoAs with many comments in this thread, carefully reading the originally linked review: http://agingbiotech.info/vitamindcovid19/ http://agingbiotech.info/vitamindcovid19/ would help. One of the 3 recent preprints specifically noted repeated testing of C19 patients and they did an ANOVA statistical test and determined that D blood levels were not declining in the patients over the course of the infection. This doesn't prove causality, but it rules out the reverse causality you hypothesize in this post. There is a good, concise (3-paragraph) sub-section on the causality question in the discussion section called "Correlational data supported by many pieces of causal evidence". Mandatory reading for anyone who reacts with "correlation doesn't imply causation" as a criticism. Karl (author of the review)
- mrtweetyhack 7y agoI'm surprised it hasn't cured cancer...yet
- tgafpc2 7y agoSure, being healthy on many levels seems to be the best offense against C19 and lot's of other things.
- thedudeabides5 7y agoIf this is right, it means there's a natural non-intervention-based treatment for COVID called "going outside and getting sun." What a concept. Positively medieval! Funny how you don't see many doctors or pharmaceutical companies trumpeting this new treatment as a part of a treatment regime. Obviously there are second order social-benefits to staying at home, but it's just funny that so little attention has gone into something as simple and reasonable as 'get more sun' compared to the billions spent on equipment, drugs, and hospitalizations.