5 ms·
It's incredibly disappointing to see DEF CON, a conference where you can still show up and pay for entry in cash, adopt a centralized, hosted, unencrypted syste
by sneak 7y ago
It's incredibly disappointing to see DEF CON, a conference where you can still show up and pay for entry in cash, adopt a centralized, hosted, unencrypted system (Discord) that requires both:
1. that you enter into an abusive legal agreement wherein you agree to give up your civil rights
and
2. that you dox yourself to get an account (you have to give either a non-VPN IP, or a non-VoIP phone number)
My Discord account got banned from being created from Tor and using a burner number and linking my own friends to my own website in DM (because they spy on all the unencrypted messages, natch).
This means I won't be able to participate in DEF CON this year. :(
- some_furry 7y agoI think we can, with a little bit of preparation, setup a bridge between Discord and e.g. Matrix.
- jtl999 7y agoHow well does such a bridge work in practice? I realize this isn't the case for all bridges but the matrix.org->freenode bridge is rather infamous for failing in strange ways (asymmetric message forwarding, intermittent lag, etc.) And I'd assume such a bridge would lose some interactivity features proprietary to Discord. sigh
- cmeacham98 7y agoThe discord bridge is pretty reliable in my (albeit low-user count) usage.
- PenguinCoder 7y agoI agree with you entirely. Discord is a poor choice for this, in any form.
- rafael09ed 7y agoWhat do you think would be better?
- saagarjha 7y agoIRC, presumably.
- dijit 7y agoOff the top of my head: IRC, Matrix, SILC, Mattermost, Zulip, Rocket.Chat, XMPP
- droopybuns 7y agoAltspace vr
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoNo non Windows client.
- kstrauser 7y agoAren't you the guy famous for scraping everyone's Mastodon toots, even when people don't want you to?
- Endlessly 7y agoSource for below text: https://blog.freeradical.zone/suspended/ https://blog.freeradical.zone/suspended/ ———— Suspended sneak.berlin TEK 9 MAR 2020 • 1 MIN READ The sneak.berlin instance is a small or single-user instance operated by a software author who writes hostile instance-scraping bots. On the web page for that software, in the ironically named "ethics statement", he writes: “Publishing your toots/messages on a server without marking them private or requiring authentication and thus making them available to the web is an act of affirmative consent to allowing others to download those toots/messages (usually by viewing them in a browser on your profile page). If you don’t want your toots downloaded by remote/unauthenticated users on the web, do not publish them to the web. If you publish them to the whole web (and your home instance serves them to all comers), do not be surprised or feel violated when people download (and optionally save) them, as your home instance permits them to.“ This is an interesting take on online privacy, to be sure: "because you have not physically restricted me from harvesting your information, you are affirmatively consenting to it". This is much the same argument as "you shouldn't have let me hit you" and carries about the same moral weight with me. By choosing not to talk to this instance, I hope we make clear that the Free Radical community does not wish to interact with the author or his software.
- eqvinox 7y ago> This is much the same argument as "you shouldn't have let me hit you" and carries about the same moral weight with me. I'd rather compare it to not locking your bicycle and then complaining someone stole it. It may be illegal but you're a bit naive for expecting otherwise. Also, in this instance the users were able to notice the data collection. What about the instances where they aren't, because the scraper just keeps to themselves? And then maybe they start getting very well-targeted spam or phishing, and maybe never find out how they were able to do that? In a way, this scraper is a service to awareness.
- 7y ago
- mike_d 7y agoI would like to point out that you are posting this very comment on a centralized, hosted, unencrypted system. But in all seriousness, the DEF CON Forums are generally full of helpful knowledgeable people who can help guide you in creating a non-attrib Discord account if you are having problems.
- novok 7y agoIt's public, doesn't require an email even I think and you can use tor with it anonymously and is upfront about all of it.
- unethical_ban 7y agoI would like to point out that one can assume different identities on the web, and that I am fine giving my personal email and address to my bank, but perhaps not to a hacker conference. Why? Because it's my choice.
- sneak 7y ago“Hosted” means, in this instance, by a third party: not DEF CON or the DEF CON attendee, but the external service Discord. HN is first-party, it is not SaaS or “hosted” in this sense of the term. HN doesn’t have DMs, which is a very important distinction. There are no write interactions on HN other than votes and display/noprocrast settings that are not expected to be fully public. There are no interactions with HN that are assumed to be private, such as talking to other people directly.