4 ms·
Roomba is a very old concept, missing almost everything that makes modern robots interesting. No vision; not much memory; no model of the environment; no knowle
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Roomba is a very old concept, missing almost everything that makes modern robots interesting. No vision; not much memory; no model of the environment; no knowledge of physics. Just a tuned mechanism and simple algorithm to wander around an barely pick up some dirt.
Don't get me wrong; its terribly useful. I own a knockoff. But not a model of what robots could be, today. Think of facial-recognition drones delivering voice messages to people in a crowd. Think auto-drive cars and the terabytes of data and kilowatts of energy they command. Think of the Netflix algorithm for suggesting movies. Lightyears beyond Roomba.
Yes, automation will eat our lunch. Because automation is eating our lunch. Factories, city planning, scheduling, diagnosing - all sorts of automated processes are in industry and consumer space right now. Just ask Siri about it if you still have doubts.
- simplyaccont 7y agoActually Roombas for a while already have vision and model/map their environment.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOk. But they have tiny little processors (5?) that each do a tiny little task with a smidgen of RAM. Is the 'vision' feature real, or just a light intensity detector? Can you get a picture out of it? I'm dubious. As for the model/map, how does it sense location? Dead reckoning? Not a very significant feature if it can't find itself on the map, nor use the map to choose a route. Which I doubt (from videos of the Roomba in action)
- qchris 7y agoIt depends on the model, but I think that your impression of Roomba, either through experience or the technology that the author of this article presented is really out-of-date. Even on past models, they have Visual Simultaneous Location and Mapping (VSLAM) tech that is far, far beyond dead reckoning. The even more recent version (not sure if there's been a release since) also has persistent maps, so it actually can find itself on the map and choose routes[2]. I'm not sure what exactly the processors are, but considering the supply-chain investments that've gone into mobile processor development for smartphones, I think it's likely unfair to characterize them as "tiny little processors". Disclosure: I did an internship at iRobot a few years ago, although the overwhelming majority of my work wasn't related to Roomba products. [1] https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/home-robots/irobot-brings-visual-mapping-and-navigation-to-the-roomba-980 https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/home-robots/iro... [2] https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/home-robots/new-roomba-i7-features-persistent-maps-room-cleaning https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/home-robots/new...
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThat's a big name. I'm suspicious it means "light intensity map" or something far less interesting than it sounds. Turn a light on or off, and then what? My Shark (ok Not a Roomba) manual says to leave the lights on. I suspect that's because its navigating by light intensity (light fixture bright spots).
- simplyaccont 7y agoRoomba usually runs during the day when lights are off and all windows are darkened. If I open windows/turn on lights - there is no difference. Also you can draw on the map (that roomba makes) "no-go" area, and it will obey it.
- qchris 7y agoI don't like to be dismissive, but your suspicion isn't well-founded and is very likely based on little or no background research on the topic. If you had, you'd have found that SLAM and VSLAM as a subset is a well-defined category of computer with a strong mathematical background in optical flow and pattern matching on images[0]. You'd have found a number of iRobot patents still in their enforceable time period directly referencing the use of cameras in those algorithms[1][2]. You'd have found marketing materials describing how those systems work that directly correlates with the technology described in those patents[3]. That's based on no special previous knowledge of those materials on my part, just the top few results from a couple minutes of DDG and Google Scholar searches. Implying that is just "a big name" that means "something far less interesting than it sounds" is an uninformed opinion. Plus, even [0], which is 15 years old directly refutes your comments about the effect of lighting. Lighting is helpful because it illuminates the scene that a camera is seeing, in the same way that it's easier to go on a night hike on during a full moon. We don't reference our position off the moon, it just makes it easier to see where we're walking. [0] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1570091 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1570091 [1] https://patents.google.com/patent/US9286810B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US9286810B2/en [2] https://patents.google.com/patent/US9910444B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US9910444B2/en [3] https://www.irobot.com/roomba/s-series https://www.irobot.com/roomba/s-series
- carlosf 7y agoI wouldn't call Roomba old fashioned. It's based on emergent behavior instead of forecasting and complex rules. I haven't touched this area since 2016, but I remember coding swarms of of robots that could manage to do very complex things from simple rules. In addition, they would be quite robust as they made very few assumptions about their environment / problem space.