4 ms·
The article says: “Imperial College London’s Neil Ferguson has said, as many of two-thirds of 'Covid deaths' would have happened anyway” Would these deaths ha
by lostlogin 7y ago
The article says:
“Imperial College London’s Neil Ferguson has said, as many of two-thirds of 'Covid deaths' would have happened anyway”
Would these deaths have happened in a massive spike? If not, then it isn’t anything like the same and if so, why?
- sesutton 7y agoPresumably he means they would've happened in the same time period otherwise it's a meaningless statement. On a long enough timescale everyone who died of Covid would've died anyway.
- dboreham 7y agoWhether it's meaningless depends on the timescale. For zero months its very meaningful while for infinity months it's completely meaningless. And in-between it's meaningful, e.g. they would have died in the next 12 months.
- marcell 7y agoThe implication is they would have died soon, like in the next 6 months. About half of Covid deaths are in nursing homes. The median lifespan after entering a nursing home is 5 months, and the mean is 13 months. Coronavirus is very infectious, so if it enters a nursing home, it could easily spread and wipe out everyone who was on the brink of dearth, or on a fragile state.
- lukas099 7y agoAccording to The Economist, the average lifetime lost per covid death is over 10 years. https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/05/02/would-most-covid-19-victims-have-died-soon-without-the-virus https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/05/02/would-mo...
- marcell 7y agoWell, it's worth keeping in mind that the risk of death from a coronavirus infection is comparable to the annual risk of death from all causes. Coronavirus infection though is a once per lifetime risk, whereas all-cause mortality occurs every year. Just as a random comparable, the annual risk of getting cancer if you're 35 years old is around 0.1%, and the annual risk of having a heart attack is around 0.5% (higher for men, lower for women). All of those diseases would have similar average lifetime lost as covid, but the risk is continuous, not a once per lifetime occurance.
- easytiger 7y agoSounds like they took the life expectancy of certain age groups without taking into account individual preexisting conditions whatsoever.
- lukas099 7y agoNot according to the article: "Then the authors accounted for other illnesses the victims had, in case they were unusually frail for their age."