2 ms·
When it comes to batteries, energy density is not a concern, it's only cost. Cost has been high enough that frequency regulation has been the biggest use. Cos
by epistasis 7y ago
When it comes to batteries, energy density is not a concern, it's only cost.
Cost has been high enough that frequency regulation has been the biggest use.
Cost is still high enough that uses from multiple revenue streams will be necessary to fully recoup costs, except in fantastically fucked up markets like where the Tesla battery went in Australia.
But the writing is on the wall. Looking at current usages, and current market penetration, and thinking its reflective of the future is exactly what Palm did when the iPhone came out. Costs are falling exponentially, but the switchover will be happen much faster than the price change once storage is cheaper than its alternatives, it's a non-linearity.
We are already seeing a lot of bids for future solar and wind installs including storage, and then bidding on capacity payments, which is a sea change from even two years ago.
Utilities, if they were more forward looking, could be using this technology switch as an opportunity to massively increase their profits. Unfortunately, nearly all I've heard of are instead living in the past and don't want to accept a world where they have to anticipate advancing and improving technology, and are scared of losing the lobbying power that comes from a tight alliance with fossil fuels. It's perhaps good to have stolid and conservative leadership in something as essential as utilities, but at some point ignoring new tech becomes more dangerous and radical than trying to embrace it.
- ThomPete 7y agoDensity is a problem and that doesn't go away by saying it's just an economic problem. Heat is just one example of a problem with density. Again there is a lot of wishful thinking out there but the second you dig into it you realize there is nothing substantial, unfortunately. You are more than welcome to send me any link to something that is even close to be ready for production and scale. You won't find it. What you will find is that places like Denmark and Germany cost go up because you need backup in the forms of oil, coal, gas, or nuclear which needs to be factored in. There is no way around that.
- epistasis 7y agoThis is the third time in a few days that I've heard the completely fabricated concern of "energy density" being a problem for grid storage. It's ridiculous, where is this false talking point coming from? Repeating it merely shows that you are willing to propagate politics without checking facts. The old AES deployment in Escondido, CA fits 5MWh in a shipping container. Let's say 250MWh per acre, with a single layer of containers. Or just look at a typical Tesla, which can power the owner's house for several days, using a tiny fraction of their garage. Battery storage can be deployed at substations, at decommissioned thermal-based generators, etc. I really wonder what sort of political industry rag has been spreading this "energy density" nonsense. If the people saying this were accountable enough for their words to be held to them in five years, they would look rather silly.
- ThomPete 7y agoI'll gladly own my words for 5 years. Lets meet in 5 and see. I have been accountable for my words for a long time now, more than 5 years. And I have still to see any of your claims come to fruition. Go back 5 years and you will see people claiming what you are claiming now. It's just not that simple. We are talking at scale here not just some Tesla projects for the 1st world or a few pilot projects paid for by governments. Density is a serious issue for any serious storage of energy on top of that getting the energy from the renewables into the storage. If it wasn't we would be living in a very different world. Economics isn't the problem here, feasibility is and the fact that we don't have any serious examples of what you claim is no problem kind of illustrates the point more than claiming it's a quesiton of conservative utillity execs. You have zero base for those claims.
- epistasis 7y agoOk, please explain what limitations there are from "physics," or what limitations the current energy density of batteries places on them for deployment. Also, what about the AES battery in Escondido, or the Tesla battery in Australia make them not count? What part of "at scale" are you talking about here? An installation of one project that contributes to the grid? The people that said that batteries were coming five years ago were correct. Deployments are going faster than anticipated, and costs are stopping faster than anticipated. If these deployments are shy of hitting some barrier that would prevent larger scale deployment, what is that barrier? I contend that the barrier is cost, which is changing all the time. Can you explain to me what barrier you think there is in addition (or in place of) cost? Is it just the politics of decision makers?
- ThomPete 7y agoIt's the other way around. You are the one claiming so you need to show how you are going to store enough energy around ex. the US to be able to reliably provide energy from renewable energy sources to everyone that needs it or let's just say 50% of the energy needs (not just electricity). Electricity is around 20% of the total energy consumption. The limitation is storing enough energy at a small enough area with enough distribution. So no, they weren't right at all. We aren't seeing any mass adoption of them only a lot of claims about potential and that is why very few people are investing. Not because they are scared but because there aren't any solutions to some of the foundational problems. That would require new discoveries. https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/renewable/battery-density-and-technology-is-a-problem-for-a-100-percent-renewables-world/ https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/renewable/battery... https://www.technologyreview.com/2018/07/27/141282/the-25-trillion-reason-we-cant-rely-on-batteries-to-clean-up-the-grid/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2018/07/27/141282/the-25-tr...