3 ms·
Except we could just as easily turn it around and point to the genocides and failures of societies with "market systems" as well. The reality is the whole noti
by cmrdporcupine 7y ago
Except we could just as easily turn it around and point to the genocides and failures of societies with "market systems" as well.
The reality is the whole notion of talking about "government systems" like they're replaceable components that we can evaluate like scientific experiments is delusional. Societies and especially economic systems develop their characteristics organically over hundreds of years. Bolsheviks slapping a "socialist" label on their society after their revolution has little bearing on the fact that in many ways Stalin's Russia was contiguous with Tsarist practice [and in fact many top members of his bureauracy were ex-Tsarist bureaucrats, and by the 30s pretty much every leading Bolshevik from 1917 was murdered or exiled...]. Minus the drastic influence of the orthodox church, of course
- vorpalhex 7y ago> Except we could just as easily turn it around and point to the genocides and failures of societies with "market systems" as well. Holodomor is a clear example that genocides belong to socialists and communists too. You're right that we can't talk about government systems strictly in the abstract which is why we use history, and while history has different context in each instance it consistently shows us that pure socialism ends at authoritarianism, whether that's the Bolsheviks, the Maoists, or the PCV.