4 ms·
> In the US, normal citizens are often legally armed, and criminals are very often illegally armed. It's a fairly common occurrence in the US for the highway p
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> In the US, normal citizens are often legally armed, and criminals are very often illegally armed.
It's a fairly common occurrence in the US for the highway patrol to pull over a driver for speeding, the driver has a firearm, the police issue a speeding citation and everyone goes on their way.
How does that require the police to be armed? Do you think it likely that typical motorists would be willing to shoot a police officer in order to avoid a traffic citation? Or that the infinitesimal minority crazy enough to do that are going to be deterred if the police are armed as well?
Ordinary police officers don't need firearms because ordinary police officers are not especially likely to have anyone try to shoot at them.
The situation is different if they're executing a warrant on a meth lab, but exceptional situations are exceptional and routine situations are not.
- sokoloff 7y agoIt's a fairly common occurrence for me to drive to the grocery store, buy my groceries, and return home without crashing. Yet, I wear my seatbelt for the worst-case outcome not the typical or most common outcome. Likewise, I wouldn't issue police equipment based on the extremely common case where a policeman doesn't need a vest nor a gun all day and, in fact, on the majority of days doesn't even need their set of handcuffs.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe difference is that a seatbelt or a vest or a set of handcuffs doesn't escalate existing conflicts or cause civilian fatalities. Or to put it another way, aren't you arguing that all civilians should carry firearms as well? After all, there could be a mugger, or a rapist, or a grizzly bear. Better to have it and not need it, right?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoDon't they then become targets? There is a subculture of anti-police thought and behavior in the US (witness this thread). Do the mental exercise: will police injuries/deaths increase/decrease if they were unarmed?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWhy would they be targets any more than they are now? If anything they would be less, because you stop getting all the "cop shoots innocent civilian" stories that are driving that sentiment. Meanwhile attacking a police offer would still be a life-ruining mistake, because you still go to jail for a very long time.
- tehwebguy 7y agoCop killers are arrested and prosecuted in record time. The system throws the book at them and even the book is heavier when the victim is a cop (enhanced sentencing etc) even though the occurrence is rare. Meanwhile, cops are murdering people with impunity at a rate of about 10x the former. "Police" is a subculture of anti-society though and behavior and for some reason we keep giving them guns.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoNothing about that scenario refutes "cops need guns". Its a violent society; the police are under attack in some places. I don't like it; but it's not helpful to shout blame. Have to understand where we are, to drive any change.
- mrguyorama 7y agoGarbage collectors are 3x more likely to die on the job than a cop https://qz.com/410585/garbage-collectors-are-more-likely-to-die-on-the-job-than-police-patrol-officers/ https://qz.com/410585/garbage-collectors-are-more-likely-to-...
- JoeAltmaier 7y ago...and garbage collectors aren't armed! Thank you for the confirmation.
- FireBeyond 7y ago> There is a subculture of anti-police thought and behavior in the US (witness this thread). I don't think this thread demonstrates anti-police thought in general. I think it demonstrates anti-police abuse of power/double standards/hypocrisy and other undesirable issues. It's certainly not littered with people chanting "ACAB!".