3 ms·
> your theory makes a risky prediction (spacetime is curved, therefore we should see X) and then you go check. If spacetime is actually flat, you're gonna see Y
by pdonis 7y ago
> your theory makes a risky prediction (spacetime is curved, therefore we should see X) and then you go check. If spacetime is actually flat, you're gonna see Y instead
So basically your issue here is that QFT doesn't predict that spacetime is curved? Or it doesn't make a prediction either way about whether spacetime is curved or flat? This amounts to saying "we don't yet have a good theory of quantum gravity". Yes, this is true.
> it sounds like you think that the final theory will not be built on QM/QFT/Standard Model foundations
I am skeptical about whether string theory will turn out to be the quantum gravity theory we are searching for, and string theory is the only candidate I'm aware of that is a QFT of any sort. So yes, if string theory doesn't turn out to be right, I think we will be in the position you describe.
> and will be different enough that QM and GR will remain incompatible approximations forever
Only in the same sense that, for example, Newton's laws and Maxwell's Equations are incompatible approximations. I don't see that sort of thing as a problem.
- guscost 7y ago> This amounts to saying "we don't yet have a good theory of quantum gravity" Er, yep. Thanks for taking the time to do roundabout arguments that lead to this very simple thing that we're not even disagreeing about. Sorry for not just stating this in a better way outright. > string theory is the only candidate I'm aware of that is a QFT of any sort. Loop Quantum Gravity is built from a QFT called "Group Field Theory" too, that's why they still have their renormalization problem. I suppose you could argue that it's "not comprehensive" enough, or that it's not a serious contender. > Newton's laws and Maxwell's Equations are incompatible approximations. ...and they are therefore both failed paradigms, but we're not going to agree about that opinion. All I can add is to say that we're never going to find a fifth Maxwell equation that works with the other four and explains more things within that framework. That's all I mean by "failed" and it's probably a controversial perspective.