4 ms·
So I saw, am still seeing, all the doctors and nurses in NYC pleading for help. But there were thousands of empty covid-specific beds open in that state. Why
by sandworm101 7y ago
So I saw, am still seeing, all the doctors and nurses in NYC pleading for help. But there were thousands of empty covid-specific beds open in that state. Why where they not sending patients to these field hospitals? Is this about money? Would private hospitals loose out on payments if they transfered patients?
I feel sorry for the frontline workers in NYC, but I don't know how to reconcile knowledge that there were open covid-specific beds availible just down the road.
- DanBC 7y ago.
- sandworm101 7y ago>> "It was very disappointing," Gonzalez said. "Everybody was here, ready to work, ready to get patients in." Many of these hospitals treated literally zero patients. Hospitals weren't overwealmed by people in care homes. They were overwealmed by people in the hospital. I don't see why some subset of those patients couldn't have been shipped to these field hospitals. NY was asking for volunteers to come from all over the country to relieve their struggling hospital system. But there were federal hospitals standing idle a short drive away? Why weren't they loading the not-yet-crititcal patients into busses and taking them to Stony Brook (capacity 1038, patients treated 0)?
- easytiger 7y agoThe field hospital concept to increase capacity to reduce deaths was based on, in the UK, the Imperial paper which was based on, frankly a non realistic interpretation of the input data from China and Italy. Meaningless admission/overadmission rates which are clearly vastly wrong/misinterpreted and in turn based on a huge percentage of over 75s being hospitalised and a majority of them in turn needing ventilation. Except in reality patients of that age are rarely ventilated because they wouldn't survive such an invasive treatment and if they are the recovery is 6-8 months and long and painful and has poor recovery outcomes. That predicate was wrong in the paper. Secondly the field hospitals built could only receive patients who had no other underlying or exacerbating conditions because the FHs lack the staff and equipment to care for them. Given that practically every person who died from a respiratory covid infection had such issues it rendered them fairly pointless. The paper also didn't do much to deal with the fact this activity will cause a surge in deaths of non covid related fatalities. Whole other issue
- euroclear 7y agoPossibly because open beds were located far from New York City. New York state is far larger than the city.
- sandworm101 7y ago>> New York state is far larger than the city. I used to live in new england. No part of NY is further than a few hours drive from any other part of the state, especially during lockdown traffic. The Stony Brook facility was on Long Island, only a 60-mile drive from downtown NYC. An ambulance/bus in a hurry could easily make the drive in under an hour.
- rb808 7y agoBuffalo to Montauk is 500 miles. Even something like Plattsburgh to NYC is 300 miles.
- afterburner 7y ago> No part of NY is further than a few hours drive from any other part of the state, especially during lockdown traffic. What? Buffalo to NY is 6 hours.
- sandworm101 7y agoYa, a "few" hours. Look at the western states, or the Canadian provinces, 6 hours between cities is literally an afternoon's drive.
- beart 7y agoThese patients can't all just go for an afternoon drive on their ventilators. That would mean tying up an ambulance + staff for at least 12 hours. We aren't talking about an "afternoon drive" in these circumstances.
- projektfu 7y agoI have heard that Albany Medical Center is taking cases from a larger area. I don’t know the specifics.
- hpoe 7y agoI've been wondering a lot about that as well. It seems to me it may be a combination of factors. 1) New York was the area hardest it, it got hit initially, it has incredibly high concentration of people, and since it got hit early we had the least amount of information about the virus. Because of the small geographic area, high population density, and quick spike of infections you get a subset of hospitals strained for resources in that area, but not the whole nation. Similar to pulling a hose and it gets caught on something which makes it harder to pull, it isn't there isn't enough slack in the hose, it is that there isn't enough slack in the hose at one spot. 2) There has been a heavy politicization of the whole 'Rona situation and so different factions are either trying to downplay it, or exacerbate it to try and score political points. 3) Fear gets more clicks than, sunny day stories. 4) Pushing an over the top message of worry may convince people to be more cautious who otherwise wouldn't be. Like if you want a 3% raise, you don't go in and ask your boss for a 3% raise, ask him for 5% or 7% that way he can negotiate you down to a 3% and still feel like he won, and kept you for less than you wanted and you still get what you wanted. 5)There is an alternative possiblity. There is a grand conspiracy by either, the deep state, the Illuminati, the elite, the superwealthy, secret neo-Nazis, the Communists, the bicoastal liberal elite, the CIA, to kill people by the millions using COVID-19 and it turns out the conspiracy is really bad at it. EDIT: I also want to make clear I don't want to downplay the situation of various healthcare workers who have been heroically making sacrifice. I believe many of them are honestly expressing their opinion and are worried about PPE or other issues, and may have experienced it; however there are probably hundreds of thousands of people involved in the New York healthcare system, if only 1% of 100,000 people feel overwhelmed at some point and post a video, or send a tweet about it that is 1,000 stories, but may not represent a consensus view.
- djsumdog 7y agoNo one seems to be covering whistle-blowers like Nicole Sirotek except the shitty tabloids. I want some other NYC reporters to investigate/interview all the doctors/nurses that have been brought in from other regions (blured out/anonymously) Maybe that video is fake, but I am wondering how many of these deaths might be due to malpractice.
- projektfu 7y agoI’ve seen it covered only by the NY Post and several tabloids. There are a couple possibilities in my mind. Of course editorial discretion is one, but what if they looked into her story and couldn’t confirm basic facts? It’s hard to write a story around that unless the underlying thing gets a lot of currency. Sometimes newspaper ombudsmen are interested in finding out why a story wasn’t reported. Perhaps send tips there?
- twic 7y ago> But there were thousands of empty covid-specific beds open in that state. Why where they not sending patients to these field hospitals? There is a somewhat similar situation in the UK, where hospitals are dealing with a lot of COVID patients, but the 'Nightingale' hospitals, our equivalent of these field hospitals, are mostly empty. Something i have heard, but do not have a source for, is that the Nightingale hospitals were built on the assumption that COVID patients just needed a bed and a ventilator, but it turns out that COVID causes multiple organ failure, treating which needs a wider range of facilities, and can progress very quickly from respiratory symptoms to that, so they aren't actually much use.
- razakel 7y agoMy understanding is that they were built to treat more minor cases, where someone does need monitoring, but they weren't intended to be ICUs.
- ryankemper 7y ago> but it turns out that COVID causes multiple organ failure, treating which needs a wider range of facilities, and can progress very quickly from respiratory symptoms to that, so they aren't actually much use. Just to be clear, COVID-19 contributes to organ failure in very limited cases from a statistical sense. So this is absolutely something that is happening, but just wanted to be clear that we are not seeing hordes of people keeling over from strokes, organ failure, etc. It's known that the complications that come into play when the body has entered a cytokine-storm type state are very far-reaching. For the same reason that inflammation is a critical part of the healing process, systemic inflammation can cause incredible damage to organs and other physiological systems.
- humaniania 7y agoDo you have a reference for those assertions?
- ryankemper 7y agoThe burden of proof is on the person claiming the widespread organ failure. I can't provide a study saying it doesn't happen because there's not studies saying it does happen for those studies to debunk :) But, here's one group of case reports that is commonly held up as evidence of the supposed strokes in young people / widespread organ failure / etc: "Large-Vessel Stroke as a Presenting Feature of Covid-19 in the Young" - https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2009787?query=recirc_mostViewed_railB_article https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2009787?query=rec... EDIT: Oh, or were you referring to sources around the impacts of systemic inflammation? I can certainly provide those if you're interested.
- tathougies 7y agoWeren't they wanting protective equipment? These hospitals didn't have any extra of those.
- ISL 7y agoQuite a few still don't. Check out findthemasks.com for a map of almost 4,000 institutions seeking donations in the US. We also list a number of countries worldwide.