5 ms·
It amazes me how unself aware some HN users are when it comes to giving Government more power. I wonder do they know how much bad tech regulation has been both
by scarface74 7y ago
It amazes me how unself aware some HN users are when it comes to giving Government more power. I wonder do they know how much bad tech regulation has been both passed and stopped.
The government would love to have more power over tech to both gather information on people and to control the narrative.
Did anyone not see how Tim Cook was kissing up to the President and how much he enjoyed it? Do you really prefer to have a potential abusive government With the power of the state with more power.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoPerhaps you should consider that the commenter is fully self aware, but just disagrees with you at an ideological level? Conversational tone on HN would be better if we didn't make assumptions or statements about people's self-awareness, intelligence, and just debated the substance of the issues.
- rootusrootus 7y ago> It amazes me how unself aware some HN users are when it comes to giving Government more power. Completely anecdotally, I can feel a pretty big shift taking place. At least that's what it feels like online, which may not be at all representative of the overall population. A new generation has come of age, and they are far more comfortable with concepts like socialism and even totalitarianism than the previous generations are. It was evident before COVID19, but since the pandemic began it has become even more pronounced. It's fascinating, really. Maybe scary. It's weird to get a little older (I'm Gen X) and feel like the culture of your society is shifting out from underneath you. No wonder old people seem to trend conservative. Edit: And the hive mind does not care to recognize it. Welcome to the new world, introspection not welcome.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoI wouldn't call your comment a call for introspection. It's a bit more of an ad hominem attack, really. I'm also Gen X. And thoroughly socialist. And also thoroughly anti-authoritarian. I don't fit the mould of your comment, but my opinions are a target of it, and so I take umbrage with its rather denigrating tone.
- vorpalhex 7y agoIf you feel attacked by that comment, it may say more about you than the comment itself. Socialism and authoritarianism are very linked. They're not the same, and you can have a socialist society that isn't authoritarian, but many socialist countries are centrally authoritarian and that's held true historically.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoI don't feel "attacked" by the comment, I find it crude. And its tone is not one of polite debate. So it's not a surprise the "hive mind" (really?) is downvoting it [which they didn't really]. Complaining about being downvoted is also not really good HN form. Socialism and authoritarianism are linked -- in the default North American political education. That is not the case worldwide, or for all of us. Before there was ever a socialist political party or government there were regimes all through the 19th century with capitalist market economies and highly highly authoritarian governments. But that link is not made by many. Corporate structures are highly controlling in ways that governments could never get away with -- controlling their employees time and expression as well as their access to basic services such as health care. But, again, in the default (small-l) liberal concensus in North America, this is not identified as authoritarian because the classical liberal concept of individual agents participating in a free market is assumed and enshrined. If one makes broad and reductionist statements about people who don't agree with you philosophically, and do so with the tone the commenter had, I don't see why one should be expecting not to be downvoted.
- vorpalhex 7y agoAuthoritarianism is a specific thing. It doesn't mean just "very controlling", but to have a single centralized center of government that can abridge political freedoms. As an example, an early post-Roman Brittanic king would have been classed Authoritarian because they are a centralized point of control with no senate or alderman structure. Yes there was a small period in the 19th century where we had kings who had market economies but they typically had senates which contained most of the power and were generally just figureheads. A corporation can't keep you from voting. It doesn't prevent you from donating money to your favorite political candidate, or telling your neighbors about it. On the other hand as an example of authoritarianism, Xi Jinping has literally removed the ability for Chinese people to select someone else as their leader. Even their ability to elect non-CCP parties depends on his approval. Socialism depends on cohesion. You can't have 40% of the country riot because you won't be able to maintain services, whereas capitalist economies tend to survive such upsets quite well. You don't usually see mass political actions shut towns down in the US. That's part of why authoriarianism is attractive to socialist countries because it's one way of maintaining cohesion. Unfortuntely, it works because you remove the rights of people.
- kerkeslager 7y agoI'm definitely not pro-government. I want power to be in the hands of individuals, not any centralized entity. The problem is, if you don't have a powerful government, you get something worse: powerful corporations. At least government (in a democracy) has to maintain some pretense of serving individuals. The only times corporations have to pretend to serve individuals is if their customers are individuals, and even then they can just lie about it: the whole field of advertising is devoted to that. Governments can (and do) lie about serving people too, but they have it a bit harder: consider the difference in connotation between the words "advertising" and "propaganda". And in an ideal government, there's a great deal of transparency, which makes it harder to lie. In contrast, corporations have largely unquestioned active protections over their internal secrets, and corporate transparency is practically oxymoronic. The role of government is to protect the weak from the strong, and in order to do that, unfortunately, government has to be strong. In this context, that means regulating corporations so that they can't trample individuals. Ideally, government also has checks and balances so that government also protects individuals from government. Obviously that's hard to do, and no government I know of has implemented it perfectly, but it's the best idea we have--if you have a better idea feel free to share it. And so we're clear: having an anemic government isn't a better idea: that just gives you rule by corporations.
- scarface74 7y agoThe role of government is to protect the weak from the strong, and in order to do that, unfortunately, government has to be strong. Have you read about the history of the US? Segregation? Laws against interracial marriage? “Sodomy” laws to persecute homosexuality? The Mulliford Act? Historically the US has only “protected” the majority. The same is true today if you look where the “War on Drugs” is taking place compared to “treating drug addiction like a disease” is taking place. “Powerful corporations” can’t take away your liberty or your property.
- kerkeslager 7y ago> > The role of government is to protect the weak from the strong, and in order to do that, unfortunately, government has to be strong. > Have you read about the history of the US? Segregation? Laws against interracial marriage? “Sodomy” laws to persecute homosexuality? The Mulliford Act? Government often does terrible things outside their role, a fact which I clearly acknowledged as a problem in my post. > Historically the US has only “protected” the majority. The same is true today if you look where the “War on Drugs” is taking place compared to “treating drug addiction like a disease” is taking place. The US is also one of the worst examples of a government. I think if you look at where addiction is being treated as a disease in other parts of the world, you'll find that those places have pretty powerful governments. > “Powerful corporations” can’t take away your liberty or your property. They can't take your liberty away because government says kidnapping is illegal. Corporations absolutely take away people's liberty when it's legal to do so: corporate prisons, mercenary corps, etc. In the past, when slavery was legal, it was corporations who obtained, sold, and often kept slaves. I would argue that buying up all the property, paying you a pittance, and forcing you to pay rent, so that you can't obtain property in the first place, isn't meaningfully different from taking away your property.
- bart_spoon 7y agoIt cuts both ways. Yes, there has been horrendous tech legislation that has been passed before. On the other hand, there is a lengthy list of serious abuses by individual companies and entire industries, both in and out of tech, that have been enabled due to weak or non-existent legislation that would have prevented it. At this point, both the hyper-capitalist trust in the free market, as well as the hyper-socialist belief that labor/the state are always better than private corporations are both closer to dogmatic religious beliefs than actual reality. There are certainly instances when the government will do a much worse job at running an economy than free enterprises. And there are instances when clearly government intervention and regulation is needed to protect society from bad actors (as what seems to increasingly be the case for certain megacorporations in tech, finance, the insurance industry). A balanced, case by case approach is necessary. Unfortunately, more simplistic, easy to digest platforms based on worthless platitudes get more traction, probably because those fit on a bumper sticker or in a tweet more easily.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoIt's also questionable whether we can really call Amazon a "tech" company. Yes, AWS and the foundations of their website are "tech". But the massive beast that is Amazon is mostly now a distributor/retailer/warehouser/logistics behemoth that is operating very much in meatspace. It's no more a tech company than Wal-Mart. And if we extend "tech" to include that, then pretty much any corp is "tech." So we're on much more familiar territory here -- a large semi-monopoly corporate entity with an industrial workforce. There's not a lot of Alvin Toffler here, and more of Henry Ford.
- scarface74 7y agoAmazon has 5% of retail and 30% of online commerce - neither is a monopoly.
- cmrdporcupine 7y ago30% of online commerce is rather large for one single entity wouldn't you say?
- einpoklum 7y agoWhy are you assuming "socialization" means "government control"? I would rather have various social systems be run through a cooperative, distributed-power, federated organizational model. "The government would love to have more power over tech" - the government fawns over big tech anyway. And the love is returned - with large tech companies helping the US government's military endeavors, and performing mass surveillance and feeding the subjects slanted pro-regime news.
- scarface74 7y agoThe current administration definitely doesn’t fawn over Amazon, Google or Apple until Cook gave him a photo op.
- einpoklum 7y agoTrump is playing hard to get :-P And despite the lovers' quarrel, he has been considering a $10 Billion deal to do some shady evil computing work: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/18/trump-says-seriously-looking-into-amazons-pentagon-contract.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/18/trump-says-seriously-looking... and Amazon might still get some of it: https://www.geekwire.com/2020/dod-likely-split-jedi-contract-amazon-microsoft-analyst-says/ https://www.geekwire.com/2020/dod-likely-split-jedi-contract...