5 ms·
> It's not a matter of economics but physics What physics principle can you cite here? There are no physical limits that have stoped the current grid scale dep
by epistasis 7y ago
> It's not a matter of economics but physics
What physics principle can you cite here? There are no physical limits that have stoped the current grid scale deployments.
It's all economics: how cheaply can you get materials to your factory and how cheaply can you roll your batteries.
(And just a warning, this sort of invocation if physics when it doesn't apply is a way to scare off technical people from wanting to let you invest in them.)
There are real, grid scale installations in California, Australia, and other places in very recent years. Another GWh will be deployed to Moss Landing, CA soon.
The real problem is convincing utility execs to try something new. Based on how they are regulated, saving money doesn't necessarily mean that they can increase their profits. And in fact rate-basing means that they often want to spend a ton of money on unnecessary projects.
- ThomPete 7y agoIt's always a feedback loop. You can get it cheaper because we have better technologies that make it possible and we have better technologies available because we can make it cheaper. There are real attempts at all sorts of things. That doesn't mean they are feasible at- scale. And we are talking energy here not just electricity. Thanks for the warning but you couldn't be further from the reality with regards to that part.
- epistasis 7y agoTrue about the feedback loops! However I think we often underestimate what can be done simply by scaling up an economy. Nobody (as in no published estimates) anticipated the precipitous drop in battery costs, or solar PV costs. And even more people were skeptical of the dramatic costs on wind turbines. Many (most?) utility executives and planners aren't aware of these cost drops, based on their planned deployments and their IRP processes. They often use old cost estimates rather than projections of costs into the future, even! I wish you tons of luck on your ventures, we really need more people like you out there!
- ThomPete 7y agoI wish it was that simple. Solar and wind are less than 1% of world energy consumption and not expected to grow substantially. It's nothing what so ever and there is a reason why a lot of funding for renewables died out in the beginning of this century and only countries with a political agenda is left. China reduced their investments into alternatives last year too. With regards to storage until we have proper fuel-cells that are mobile and easy to fill up we aren't closer to anything useful than we are to fusion or Thorium, in fact Thorium and fusion might be more likely to happen.
- Tade0 7y agoSolar and wind are less than 1% of world energy consumption and not expected to grow substantially. Citation needed, as I was unable to find a source that backed up any of these claims. in fact Thorium and fusion might be more likely to happen. What signs point to that?
- ThomPete 7y agohttps://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/?country=WORLD&fuel=Energy%20consumption&indicator=Total%20final%20consumption%20(TFC)%20by%20source https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/?country=WORLD&fuel=... With regards to Thorium and Fusion. Again i don't think anyone here really appreciates how hard a problem energy storage is. Fuel Cells that can actually be used like oil or gas or coal is sci-fi and the some still to be seen magic grid won't change that. A good tell is that I have gotten 20 downvotes from this discussion but not a single piece of evidence that what I am saying is wrong. Not a single technology or system in use at scale. Only wishful thinking.
- epistasis 7y agoYou have been very wrong, and refused to acknowledge the rebuttals to your false points. For example, you point to IEA'a current solar usage stats, so you are presumably using them for your far more controversial statement "not expected to grow substantially," which is a somewhat comical thing to say. The people who have been making that prediction of "not expected to grow substantially" have been ludicrously wrong, for a looooong time. This is from way back in 2017, and the IEA has not improved their projections since then: https://steinbuch.wordpress.com/2017/06/12/photovoltaic-growth-reality-versus-projections-of-the-international-energy-agency/ https://steinbuch.wordpress.com/2017/06/12/photovoltaic-grow... The IEA stats are probably correct for current usage. It's a lot harder to put your thumb on the scale when it comes to grid measurements. But when it comes to renewable tech, the IEA has been hilariously wrong because they are backward looking and refuse to acknowledge the reality of what's going on right now. Accusing others of "wishful thinking" when you can't back up your own claims, is not a very civil thing to do. To ignore the cited examples of where storage has worked is also not a very civil thing to do. To make such broad proclamations about the feasibility of a technology without even being aware of the current deployments is not a very wise position to take. Talking about shipping technologies low adoption rates as proof that they cannot grow is a logically incorrect statement. But to then propose technologies that are not shipping and are no where close to shipping (thorium, fusion), as more realistic, well, let's bring up again who is doing the wishful thinking and wearing rose colored glasses.
- netflixandkill 7y agoEssentially all existing gridscale battery deployments are for voltage or frequency support, not for meaningful energy storage. That is, they do not discharge to provide scheduled generation but instead to alleviate very short term flow problems or transmission congestion. That's all good stuff and I've been involved in planning out several such installations with utility executives, but the basic question of energy density is always going to dictate whether or not a battery installation can be be scaled up to offset a generator by timeshifting surplus generation to when the load exists for it. A moderate size city can easily pull GWh. The sum total of all current grid scale installations in California would cover the Western Interconnect for something like .0002 seconds if you handwave transmission.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoYou're mostly incorrect here, most grid scale installations are for DCM and local capacity in areas where the grid is oversubscribed. You're correct that current storage capacity is small but there are a lot of companies installing storage so that'll change quickly. The software works fine for this stuff, too, I wrote some of it at one company, it's not a hard software problem at all.
- ThomPete 7y agoPlease point to a single place where this works at scale. It's wishful thinking.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 7y agoWhen it comes to batteries, energy density is not a concern, it's only cost. Cost has been high enough that frequency regulation has been the biggest use. Cost is still high enough that uses from multiple revenue streams will be necessary to fully recoup costs, except in fantastically fucked up markets like where the Tesla battery went in Australia. But the writing is on the wall. Looking at current usages, and current market penetration, and thinking its reflective of the future is exactly what Palm did when the iPhone came out. Costs are falling exponentially, but the switchover will be happen much faster than the price change once storage is cheaper than its alternatives, it's a non-linearity. We are already seeing a lot of bids for future solar and wind installs including storage, and then bidding on capacity payments, which is a sea change from even two years ago. Utilities, if they were more forward looking, could be using this technology switch as an opportunity to massively increase their profits. Unfortunately, nearly all I've heard of are instead living in the past and don't want to accept a world where they have to anticipate advancing and improving technology, and are scared of losing the lobbying power that comes from a tight alliance with fossil fuels. It's perhaps good to have stolid and conservative leadership in something as essential as utilities, but at some point ignoring new tech becomes more dangerous and radical than trying to embrace it.