4 ms·
What mindset? That preserving life is more palatable than making money? I'm ok with that. I'd rather be unemployed than dead.
by alistairSH 7y ago
What mindset? That preserving life is more palatable than making money? I'm ok with that. I'd rather be unemployed than dead.
- MrFantastic 7y agoThe mindset that we can avoid all risk by staying in lockdown is wrong. The most at risk are people over 70. They already have a 6%+ percent chance of dying every year.
- bkor 7y agoThe lockdown is to lower the curve, not to prevent all risk. Maybe your government said something different. In Netherlands it's about ensuring that the hospitals can still cope. Loads of procedures have been postponed so that they could deal with Corona. The press in Netherlands showed the different ways of communicating a "lockdown". Though the actions were often similar, the way it was worded to the public differed quite a bit across countries. E.g. France talked about "going to war" (or something similar, cannot recall exactly). Spain and Italy both had different ways of announcing the same. Trying to only protect/lock down people in a risk group (70+, plus overweight / lung problems) seems not to have worked. The virus spread already quickly despite a lockdown for all. It'll probably spread more quickly if that wasn't the case.
- dustingetz 7y ago> Coronavirus pandemic will cause global famines of 'biblical proportions,' UN warns ... the coronavirus pandemic will push an additional 130 million people to the brink of starvation. > "While dealing with a Covid-19 pandemic, we are also on the brink of a hunger pandemic," David Beasley told the UN's security council. "There is also a real danger that more people could potentially die from the economic impact of Covid-19 than from the virus itself." source: google "covid19 famine"
- makomk 7y agoIf unemployment is better than death, why stop at doing this for Covid-19? For example, the flu kills quite a lot of people each year, and even though Covid-19 is somewhat more deadly that's counterbalanced by the fact that stronger, longer measures are required to stop it. Why not shut down parts of the economy every flu season? (I've generally seen this kind of not one life argument go hand in hand with the idea that Covid-19 cannot be compared to any other cause of death, for obvious reasons.)
- steveeq1 7y agoDon't know why this is being downvoted. The flu kills tens of thousands a year, yet no one seemed to want to shut down the economy in the past. . .
- alistairSH 7y ago10s of thousands vs 100s of thousands (or millions). Between higher mortality rate and higher level of transmission, C19 is FAR more deadly than seasonal flu. The flu is a recurring problem. We can't avoid it. COVID is (hopefully) a once-in-a-lifetime occurrence (just as the 1918 flu was).
- steveeq1 7y agoBut death still occurs with the flu! Doesn't this mean you don't think life is more palateable than making money?
- throwphoton 7y agoThe same philosophical discussion can happen with respect to raising the speed limit by 5 miles per hour; it will result in more deaths... is it worth it? But letting Covid-19 run unchecked is more akin to raising the speed limit by 50 miles per hour. The prudent choice is not to go with it.
- steveeq1 7y agoBut quarantining after the flu can "save lives". But my point is that it runs counter to the "That preserving life is more palatable than making money" argument. It's a tradeoff, in other words. If you REALLY wanted to "save lives", you can quarantine during every flu epidemic.
- alistairSH 7y agoI feel like you're trying to make some sort of reductio ad absurdum argument. Yes, the flu kills people. So do lightning strikes. Airplane crashes. And anvils falling out of windows. None at anywhere near the scale of C19. There's a balance. I don't claim to know exactly where that is, but I'm confident that "meh, granny's gonna die anyways, and I want to buy stuff and get a pedicure" is a rather ghastly approach to the current situation.
- eiji 7y agoAre you unemployed?
- alistairSH 7y agoNot currently, but have been in the past. It was preferable to death then and continues to be now.