12 ms·
Coronavirus Came from Bats, Can Infect Cats, Ferrets, WHO Says
- ciguy 7y agoAre we really expected to believe anything the WHO says at this point? They are unreliable narrators saying whatever the CCP/China wants them to say at best, maybe outright malicious at worst.
- pixxel 7y agoThe WHO should be dissolved without debate. They are either grossly incompetent or complicit.
- ciguy 7y agoIt seems pretty clear that at least some of the WHO leadership are being compensated directly or indirectly by the CCP. Short of a complete management purge and starting over I don't see how they will ever regain any credibility at this point.
- assblaster 7y agoThe WHO also is claiming that Taiwan is just a part of China and the WHO will not accept a free Taiwan. Seems overly political and specific for an "independent" health organization.
- castis 7y agoCan you cite the information you have that makes this clear to you?
- ciguy 7y agoAlmost every single one of their statements during this entire crisis has echoed CCP propaganda. From saying that it was not transmissible between humans, to calling travel restrictions xenophobic, refusing to acknowledge that Taiwan exists. I could go on...
- hajile 7y agoThe current director ISN'T EVEN A DOCTOR. He's old guard politician for the Ethiopian government. He covered up THREE cholera outbreaks that killed a lot of people in his country. China hold over a quarter of Ethiopian debt. They also only give aid to countries that do what they say and vote as they want in the UN (countries that don't lose billions in investment -- a huge amount of money for small, impoverished countries in Africa).
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoHe's not an MD, but he is a doctor. He has a doctorate in community health, a masters in immunology of infectious diseases, and a bachelors in biology. Is there a specific reason to think that a "microbiologist and internationally recognized malaria researcher" with a doctorate in community health will naturally perform much worse as WHO director than an MD? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tedros_Adhanom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tedros_Adhanom
- nichos 7y agoI'm not big in to conspiracy theories, but this is my take on the WHO. Their handling of the Corona virus has been a huge blunder.
- rihegher 7y agoWhat part of their narration is unreliable ?
- yostrovs 7y agoIn January they said the virus doesn't transmit between humans. Then they said travel restrictions are xenophobic. Then they said the world should thank China for its efforts.
- lizardking 7y agoA representative also pretended his audio went out when asked about Taiwan.
- yostrovs 7y agoYes, and when he came back and was asked about Taiwan again, he said he already discussed China and ended the conversation. Taiwan doesn't exist according to WHO.
- tirpen 7y agoTaiwan is not a member of the UN so WHO kind of have to act that way. It sucks, but that's a problem with the UN, not with WHO specifically.
- yostrovs 7y agoWHO, being staffed by scientists, should recognize that Taiwan indeed exists, that it has its own government that responded to the pandemic, and that China is not in charge there. Pretending otherwise leads to losing credibility, as everyone knows Taiwan does indeed exist. I've actually seen it.
- tirpen 7y agoPretending that horribly complex geopolitical issues are simple does not magically make them simple.
- austincheney 7y agoUnsubstantiated conspiracy theories are such a poor man’s distraction.
- ciguy 7y agoWhat conspiracy theories are you referring to exactly? Because just based on facts (Their handling of Taiwan, their statements parroting CCP propaganda in January claiming the virus was not transmissible between humans, their condemnation of travel restrictions as xenophobic etc...) they are pretty clearly not on the side of facts or truth. Make of that what you will, but you can't deny the facts.
- austincheney 7y agoYour comment that I replied to directly describes a conspiracy and you did not substantiate it with evidence. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/conspiracy https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/conspiracy
- ciguy 7y agoNo it does not? Stating facts is not a conspiracy.
- austincheney 7y agoA conspiracy is any agents coming together, even if unknowingly, to a achieve a common objective. This is very directly what you wrote whether or not it is factual, though the writing appears very much an opinion.
- simion314 7y agoWhat I remember reading was something like "there is no evidence that the virus can be transmitted by humans" , was it uncovered that there was such evidence and was hidden? I see that is a lot of China blaming but I seen US politicians and media were also pushing strong into "there is no evidence" and is just the flu. Anyway this entire "show" just confirms my view on politics, the big trick to use is "Blame the others, we had the power but all the other parties are at fault we have no blame",
- ssijak 7y agoIt is funny for non americans to read opinions of americans which are obviously implanted by the US media narative. Yeah, China is all bad, and the US never influenced any international organisation or government? And saying that WHO should be dismanteled because of some errors on Covid handling (while working with early and unreliable data) is just plain dangerous and childish (and influenced by Tramp narrative with which he wants to save himself from concequences from his own wrong doing).
- ciguy 7y agoI haven't lived in the USA for almost 10 years, intentionally don't follow or consume USA media and I am far from a fan of Donald Trump. Try again CCP troll.
- dang 7y agoYou started a wretched flamewar in this thread and perpetuated it egregiously, breaking several of the site guidelines badly. We ban accounts that do this kind of thing. Would you please review the rules and stick to them when posting here from now on? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- yostrovs 7y agoIt's not clear how the WHO is actually helping with the pandemic. Do they treat patients, develop vaccines, tests, antibody tests, or treatment protocols? What do they do exactly? Seems like they talk and have press conferences where they say with confidence to the world, as China is locking up a city, that the virus doesn't transmit between humans. It's funny you consider WHO a serious organization.
- _Microft 7y agoIf you are curious, the wikipedia article on the WHO answers the question of their mandate in the first few paragraphs already.
- twawayhb 7y agoI completely agree with you and even "crazier" I don't hang out with Alex Jones type of people, though the vast majority of I've recently talked to about it also agree with us. I don't get why you're being downvoted, I had to create a throwaway for obvious reasons; I usually find myself not ready to "out" any of my opinions.
- ciguy 7y agoAppreciate it, it's pretty interesting to see the CCP propaganda machine come out in full force here.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- foolzcrow 7y agoWHO is no longer credible.
- quantumwoke 7y agoUnpopular opinion (for HN maybe :) - the WHO, which does not solely deal with infectious diseases, much to the world's chagrin, is doing the best job that they can considering the situation. On average the advice from the WHO on a whole range of medical topics has been nothing but excellent, and I am loathe to discount them entirely based on a few press statements that have been taken wildly out of context by the media and the internet as a whole. I feel like I'm taking crazy pills when HN unfailingly dogpiles onto the WHO in yet another thread. Are people missing the forest for the trees?
- ciguy 7y agoSorry but this is just hopelessly naive. Have you seen their handling of Taiwan, their statements parroting CCP propaganda in January claiming the virus was not transmissible between humans, their condemnation of travel restrictions as xenophobic? I could go on.....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- EE84M3i 7y agoAll international organizations have the same handling of Taiwan. It's not a WHO specific issue, it extends to basically every other similar intergovernmental organization you can think of, even the ones that aren't specialized agencies of the UN (which the WHO is), like INTERPOL.
- pfortuny 7y agoApart from the impossibility of doing the “best” (as there is no such thing except in mathematics), it is not a frw press statements. It is knee-jerking before China. Like always.
- Nursie 7y agoI wouldn't want to discount them entirely, but their recent foray into TCM has left me less than entirely on-side. On average I'm sure they do a great job, but they're not perfect and should be pushing back against damaging woo like this.
- not_a_moth 7y agoWHO said for weeks it wasn't transmittable between humans, that countries should not impose travel restrictions, and insisting late into the pandemic that you don't need to wear masks unless you're infected. Arguably the WHO has blood on its hands for allowing the virus to spread. They unquestionably are influenced by China and CCP's politics, not just denying Taiwan's existence, but the many statements praising China throughout the entire pandemic, on virtually all talking points, while being critical of western nations handling of the virus. If ever there was a time to take action, point fingers, and restore some dignity to supposedly independent health organizations, it is now, by creating a new organization.
- bkor 7y agoThis seems to be a "look over there" response. China had a big issue. In Netherlands not much was done. Italy had big issues. Netherlands ignored it. It spread to Netherlands, suddenly extreme measures had to be taken. Meanwhile, not much was done in USA, aside from things like "meh, everything will probably be fine". Now instead of acknowledging that things went wrong, it's because of someone else, say WHO. And China! UK had a report saying that a pandemic was the biggest threat. They recommended a tactical amount of ventilators to be kept, plus various other actions. Nothing was done. > If ever there was a time to take action, point fingers Blaming doesn't really help anything IMO. Figure out the various causes and take action on them. Blaming, too easy.
- thdrdt 7y ago> WHO said for weeks it wasn't transmittable between humans This is not true. They posted: "Preliminary investigations conducted by the Chinese authorities have found no clear evidence of human-to-human transmission of the novel #coronavirus (2019-nCoV) identified in #Wuhan, #China," I agree this was not very wise from the WHO to post this, but China refused any other investigations so the WHO had to rely on information from China.
- saiya-jin 7y agoAt that time, they relied only on chinese info, which turned out false. They didn't have much more. Do they still claim it? By your logic, we should dissolve US government too - they knew very well what's coming, the scale of it, and focused more on attacking and blaming anything external rather than working on preparation and minimizing the spread. Do you remember top of US government claiming covid is hoax? Trump's mis-handling of this created by far the biggest epicentre of covid - this concerns whole world, not US only. And US had quite a bit of time to prepare.
- aorth 7y agoFirst, this doesn't belong on HN. Second, we already know for weeks or months that ferrets and cats are susceptible to SARS-CoV-2—they even find it in their feces. This paper was released to preprint in March 31st and today is May 8th: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.30.015347v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.30.015347v1 Third, virologists and especially those who have studied Coronaviruses for decades say the intermediate species could not have been a pangolin: https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-609/ https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-609/ I recommend HN mods lock or delete this thread.
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoThis has been flagged off the front-page, likely because it mentions the WHO. I haven't really been following the criticism of their handling of this all that closely, so this might be worth reading for others in the same boat: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Health_Organization%27s_response_to_the_COVID-19_pandemic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Health_Organization%27s_... This article seems to directly contradict some of the claims made by anti-WHO folks here. In particular, this portion of the timeline jumped out at me, contradicting the claim that the WHO was claiming no human-to-human transmission as late as early February: -- On 14 January, Maria Van Kerkhove of the WHO told in a press briefing that "it is possible that there is limited human-to-human transmission, potentially among families, but it is very clear right now that we have no sustained human-to-human transmission" The WHO recommended countries to take precautions due to the human-to-human transmission during earlier SARS and MERS outbreaks. On the same day, the WHO's Twitter account reported that "preliminary investigations conducted by the Chinese authorities have found no clear evidence of human-to-human transmission". On 20 January, the WHO released a tweet that it was "now very clear from the latest information that there is at least some human-to-human transmission" that has occurred, given that healthcare workers had been infected. On 22 January, WHO issued a statement stating that the data "suggests that human-to-human transmission is taking place in Wuhan", and called for more investigation. -- This certainly sounds to me like they initially said that we weren't seeing human-to-human transmission in mid-Jan, but within a week or so, the data was starting to show the opposite, and they said so. What exactly is the controversy here?
- ghostDancer 7y agoUS media and some of right wing European media is charging against WHO because they have to blame someone. That way the can put all the death people numbers on WHO and not take any responsibility fro their handling of the situation.
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoI completely agree that there's a political element, but I'd like to hear from the individuals who are so up-in-arms about this as to why they personally are so aggrieved and how they interpret the facts to indicate such culpability on the WHO's part.
- lablabla 7y agoThis article misrepresents the lab theory. At least in its most common version, the lab theory is not "it came from a lab, not bats". It is "it came from bats, was being used for research, and got out accidentally". The article omits this, creating the impression that animal origin is evidence against the lab theory, when of course both could be true. They wouldn't have left this out by accident. It's an obvious omission once you know about it and it changes the meaning of the story. I have no opinion about whether the virus came from a lab or didn't (how the hell would I know), but when I see someone trying to manipulate me this way, it makes me angry and suspicious and pushes me toward the other side. I've had no interest in the criticisms of Bloomberg reporting before now, but this article incriminates itself.