3 ms·
> the next thing that happens is the company goes out of business As long as the company pays its owners more than their lowest-paid employees, it can afford t
by vkou 7y ago
> the next thing that happens is the company goes out of business
As long as the company pays its owners more than their lowest-paid employees, it can afford to pay their employees more, without going out of business.
There's plenty of profitable firms that can't just pack up and move to Mexico.
- karpierz 7y agoNot exactly. Its owners could always pack up and work elsewhere. Or in the case of capital, invest elsewhere. You have to beat the alternative option.
- vkou 7y agoWhat is going to stop wherever they pack up to go to from organizing in a similar manner? Does the factory that the employees work in also disappear if the owners pack up and leave? Why would things be any different for the owners, under new ownership? Plenty of profitable businesses can afford to pay employees more. The fact that they are profitable is testament to it. They choose not to, because their employees don't have enough leverage in the employee-employer relationship. Unions change that.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> What is going to stop wherever they pack up to go to from organizing in a similar manner? The fact that not unionizing was how they got the work to begin with. If they tried to do the same thing there, the company wouldn't have any reason not to move back, which the workers in the new place obviously don't want.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> As long as the company pays its owners more than their lowest-paid employees, it can afford to pay their employees more, without going out of business. If the CEO makes a million dollars a year in a company with 100,000 empoyees, wiping out that entire salary would add less than $0.01/hour to each of the employees' wages. Also, then you would not have a CEO, which you might actually need sometimes.
- vkou 7y agoThe CEO is rarely the owner of a company big enough to require unionization. When they are, their primary remuneration is rarely in wages.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou're basically arguing that if a company pays a CEO what good CEOs get paid then they could pay their workers more instead. But that doesn't work, because you have to pay a CEO what good CEOs get paid if you want a good CEO. The shareholders can't just hire a random janitor at a janitor's salary to be the CEO and expect to not lose more money to unqualified decisionmaking than they would've had to pay a real CEO. Likewise, they can't just make zero profits forever, because otherwise they couldn't raise capital. If they're a new company they need that investment in order to buy land and build the factory etc. If they're an existing company then they still need that, or the shareholders would sell their shares and the only buyer would be a corporate raider who wants to tear down the factory for scrap and sell the land to a condo developer. Salaries and profits are relative to the market average. Unless the company is paying its executives more than the average company, or making more profits than the average company, they don't really have a surplus they can give to the workers without becoming uncompetitive.