10 ms·
> How do you get rid of renormalization? First, why do you need to? Second, renormalization only has to be done at all in perturbation theory, and perturbatio
by pdonis 7y ago
> How do you get rid of renormalization?
First, why do you need to?
Second, renormalization only has to be done at all in perturbation theory, and perturbation theory is just an approximation anyway. There is plenty of work done in non-perturbative QFT, in which renormalization doesn't even arise at all.
> Are those not incompatible paradigms to the best of our knowledge?
I'm not sure what you mean. Different approximations to the same underlying theory don't have to be compatible unless their domains of validity overlap, and even then the only compatibility they have to have is that they have to make predictions that are consistent with each other.
More generally, s/approximations/models/ in the above, since approximations are one kind of model.
> "really not any different" and "strings instead of point particles" don't seem compatible
Why not? There's nothing about the fundamentals of QFT that says it can only apply to point particles, or that applying it to point particles and applying it to strings are inconsistent. They're different models.
> it is in conflict with other paradigms that attempt to "complete" the Standard Model in other ways.
To the extent that the different attempts at a fundamental theory are inconsistent with each other (e.g., string theory vs. loop quantum gravity, which AFAICT are not consistent with each other), yes, I suppose they could be considered different paradigms. But there will never be a transition from one of them to the other. The most that could happen is that we transition from our current theories as the best we have, to our current theories being approximations to whichever more fundamental theory wins out. (Or it's possible that none of the current candidates will win out.)
- guscost 7y ago> why do you need to [get rid of renormalization]? What does renormalization actually represent? Why does nature do that? Those rules seem kinda tacked-on after the fact, to me... > There's nothing about the fundamentals of QFT that says it can only apply to point particles String Theory does not present a serious challenge to QFT or the Standard Model yet, but it is a massive set of additional ideas that are completely unnecessary for either one, and it is a paradigm in vigorous conflict with all of the other proposed completions to the Standard Model right now. If any of these completions ever wins conclusively, it will also "win" against the Standard Model, in the sense that the Standard Model will turn out to be a higher-level approximation of some truer lower-level theory, one which will never explain any of its fine-tuning, and therefore one which will fail. It's very similar to GR vs. Newtonian Dynamics, and I would argue that Newtonian Dynamics is in fact a failed paradigm, and it has been replaced by a better paradigm, no matter how useful it may remain.
- guscost 7y agoOh, also: > There is plenty of work done in non-perturbative QFT, in which renormalization doesn't even arise at all. Yes, because that stuff doesn't even attempt to be compatible with GR. There is no conflict between the probably-incompatible paradigms of GR and non-perturbative QFT because their respective predictions have zero overlap.
- pdonis 7y ago> that stuff doesn't even attempt to be compatible with GR Sure it does. You can do non-perturbative QFT in curved spacetime.
- guscost 7y agoWhen you say "do non-perturbative QFT in curved spacetime" you don't mean "make a risky prediction that could be falsified in non-curved spacetime", right? As I understand it the whole purpose of perturbation is to approximate QFT so that it can predict macro-scale things.
- pdonis 7y ago> When you say "do non-perturbative QFT in curved spacetime" you don't mean "make a risky prediction that could be falsified in non-curved spacetime", right? I don't understand what you mean. If I make a prediction in curved spacetime, it's a prediction about what will happen in curved spacetime, not what will happen in flat spacetime. So you can't falsify it by doing an experiment in flat spacetime. You have to do an experiment in curved spacetime. Non-perturbative QFT can certainly make falsifiable predictions about the results of experiments done in curved spacetime, just as it can do so about experiments done in flat spacetime. But the predictions won't be the same, because they are about different experiments under different conditions. > As I understand it the whole purpose of perturbation is to approximate QFT so that it can predict macro-scale things. I have no idea why you would think that. Perturbation theory is applicable to any QFT problem; its first major successes were predicting the Lamb shift and the shift in the magnetic moment of the electron due to quantum field effects. Neither of those are "macro-scale" things. The reason not to do perturbation theory, in cases where it is possible to find a non-perturbative (i.e., exact) solution, is that perturbation theory is inherently an approximation, and why would you settle for an approximation if you can compute the exact answer?