7 ms·
> has anyone ever seen this happen? My take on this, largely from reading Kuhn, is that the picture of "scientific revolutions" that philosophers have doesn't
by pdonis 7y ago
> has anyone ever seen this happen?
My take on this, largely from reading Kuhn, is that the picture of "scientific revolutions" that philosophers have doesn't really apply to anything that has happened in any particular field of science since that field became a science. That's not an accident: it's because the examples the philosophers were actually thinking of in a particular field happened before that field became a science.
For example, when Kuhn talks about paradigm shifts in physics, what he's actually thinking of is the shift from Aristotelian to Galilean/Newtonian physics. That was a truly revolutionary shift, but it was a different kind of shift from, say, the shift from Newtonian physics to relativity, or from classical physics to quantum physics. Steven Weinberg, in a review of Kuhn's book published years ago in the New York Review of Books, notes that, in the latter cases (i.e., in any transition to new paradigms in physics since physics really became a science), the old theory lives on as a special case or particular approximation within the new theory. Newtonian physics still gets used extensively today, because it's a valid approximation to relativity when gravity is weak and speeds are slow compared to the speed of light, and classical physics still gets used extensively today because it's a valid approximation to quantum mechanics when there are a large number of degrees of freedom and quantum interference effects are negligible.
By contrast, nobody does Aristotelian physics today, nor has anybody done it since Newtonian physics took over. Aristotelian physics is not a special case or an approximation to any physical theory we have today; it's a totally different theory of physics that simply is not useful any more, because we've found a much better and more accurate way of modeling the world. So comparing Aristotelian to modern physics is much, much more of a "gestalt switch" or "paradigm shift" than trying to compare Newtonian physics with relativity, or classical physics with quantum physics. And that kind of shift is what Kuhn was actually describing.
Lakatos seems to recognize that there are limitations to Kuhn's approach, but I don't think he really grasps the degree to which all modern science is one thing, and all fits together, and the sort of "revolution" that took us from Aristotelian to modern physics simply doesn't happen once a field becomes a science.
- guscost 7y agoModern science is absolutely not a single paradigm. QM has been in conflict with GR since its invention. Lambda-CDM is in conflict with MOND and other cosmological paradigms. String theory is a paradigm. And that's just talking about theoretical physics. I appreciate your argument, and yes if there have been no paradigm shifts in the past few centuries that would neatly resolve the problem. But I can't possibly agree, and regardless I would still love to find a counterexample where something which anyone considers a paradigm shift happened in a non-political manner. For a great example outside of physics, I can't imagine how anyone could read the story of plate tectonics and not understand it to be exactly what Kuhn was talking about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plate_tectonics#Development_of_the_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plate_tectonics#Development_of...
- pdonis 7y ago> Modern science is absolutely not a single paradigm. I think you're confusing "paradigm" with "model". See below. > QM has been in conflict with GR since its invention. "Conflict" in the sense that neither one can possibly be a final fundamental theory, yes. But whatever final fundamental theory we come up with is going to have our current QM and our current GR as special cases/approximations in the relevant regimes. In terms of any such final fundamental theory, current QM and current GR would simply be particular models built for particular applications. So current QM and current GR are not different or conflicting "paradigms" in the sense that Aristotelian and Newtonian physics are. They're just our best current models. > Lambda-CDM is in conflict with MOND and other cosmological paradigms. These aren't paradigms, they're models. Both of them accept the same underlying framework for model building. They just make different claims about which models are more accurate. > String theory is a paradigm. String theorists like to make it seem that way, but it's really not any different from any other quantum field theory in the fundamentals. It's just QFT using strings instead of point particles. The original justification for it as a fundamental theory candidate was that gravity just pops out (since the simplest closed string mode looks like a massless spin-2 particle at low energies, and that's the graviton), so it seemed to be an easy way to get a quantum theory of gravity that would reduce to GR in the classical limit. (I think it's fair to say that the jury is still out on whether this promise has been realized.)
- guscost 7y agoHow do you get rid of renormalization? Are those not incompatible paradigms to the best of our knowledge? About string theory, "really not any different" and "strings instead of point particles" don't seem compatible. I agree that it is largely an attempt to explain the fine-tuning in the Standard Model, not to overthrow it. But it is in conflict with other paradigms that attempt to "complete" the Standard Model in other ways.
- pdonis 7y ago> How do you get rid of renormalization? First, why do you need to? Second, renormalization only has to be done at all in perturbation theory, and perturbation theory is just an approximation anyway. There is plenty of work done in non-perturbative QFT, in which renormalization doesn't even arise at all. > Are those not incompatible paradigms to the best of our knowledge? I'm not sure what you mean. Different approximations to the same underlying theory don't have to be compatible unless their domains of validity overlap, and even then the only compatibility they have to have is that they have to make predictions that are consistent with each other. More generally, s/approximations/models/ in the above, since approximations are one kind of model. > "really not any different" and "strings instead of point particles" don't seem compatible Why not? There's nothing about the fundamentals of QFT that says it can only apply to point particles, or that applying it to point particles and applying it to strings are inconsistent. They're different models. > it is in conflict with other paradigms that attempt to "complete" the Standard Model in other ways. To the extent that the different attempts at a fundamental theory are inconsistent with each other (e.g., string theory vs. loop quantum gravity, which AFAICT are not consistent with each other), yes, I suppose they could be considered different paradigms. But there will never be a transition from one of them to the other. The most that could happen is that we transition from our current theories as the best we have, to our current theories being approximations to whichever more fundamental theory wins out. (Or it's possible that none of the current candidates will win out.)
- canjobear 7y agoAristotelian physics is an approximation to Newtonian physics for objects immersed in a fluid. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/157866135.pdf https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/157866135.pdf
- pdonis 7y agoThis is interesting, but note carefully this statement from the introduction: "I reformulate and derive Aristotle’s physics in modern terms." Not that this is not a useful thing to do, but it means that what the author is calling "Aristotle's physics" is not the same thing as what Aristotle himself would have called "Aristotle's physics". The author is taking a modern viewpoint--develop a model and test its predictions against observation and experiment--that Aristotle simply did not take. That change in viewpoint is a major part of the paradigm shift from Aristotelian to modern physics that I have described elsewhere in this thread. It's also worth noting that Aristotle's explanation of why his physics worked the way it did is completely different from that of the author of this paper. It's not so much that the author treats Aristotle's physics as an approximation whereas Aristotle did not. The author is taking a modern, mechanistic viewpoint in analyzing Aristotle's physics: hey, it turns out that you can derive it as an approximation to Newtonian physics valid under certain conditions! But Aristotle himself would have been shocked by such a claim. He viewed his physics as part of a teleological view of the universe: objects behaved as they did because of their telos. There is no analogue to his concept of "telos" anywhere in modern physics, nor in the author's version of Aristotle's physics.