6 ms·
Oddly, I think you will make Emacs appealing to users when you start asserting it is appealing to users. Few changes really needed. Just stop intimidating peo
by taeric 7y ago
Oddly, I think you will make Emacs appealing to users when you start asserting it is appealing to users. Few changes really needed. Just stop intimidating people before they get involved.
- striking 7y agoTo some degree, I agree. I've been playing with Doom Emacs[1] recently and it has been pretty smooth, the configuration and such more so than my regular Vim setup. 1: https://github.com/hlissner/doom-emacs https://github.com/hlissner/doom-emacs
- _jal 7y agoI tend to agree, too. It is really no worse than any other complex application, and far better documented than most. An an occasional user of both Excel and Emacs (mainly a vi guy), I waste at least as much time figuring out where "that tool" in Excel went or how to get in to one of the weird graph editing modes as I do with the more obscure Emacs features I use sometimes.
- microcolonel 7y agoMy experience with Emacs has been a steady upward trajectory, gaining understanding and access to functionality. I now use CIDER and TRAMP every working day, and no true equivalent exists for any other editor (though many are catching up to CIDER, due to Clojure being the better lisp!). The biggest problems with Emacs, to me, are the rendering performance, the lack of sufficient threading, the default keyboard-accessible windowing commands, and Elisp being unergonomic and sad. The course I'd chart for an ideal Emacs would be rendering with something like Alacritty†, some default windowing commands similar to tmux, and phasing out Elisp in favour of a Clojure dialect; the last bit would help a lot with introducing some basic sources of concurrency. † Plus smooth scrolling surfaces, since a text editor generally does not have enough surfaces that the memory overhead of tiled surfaces is a serious issue like it is for general-purpose renderers like web browsers.
- celeritascelery 7y agoAs someone who claims to be using "the better lisp" what is it about elisp that you find "unergonimic and sad"? Genuinely curious.
- microcolonel 7y agoAt least when I've written elisp, the default datastructures have involved a lot of work to construct and manipulate, and when you do it right, the ones you've chosen for convenience may perform so poorly that you have to go back and change them to get your program to complete in time. Namespaces for vars and functions being not a language feature is inconvenient. Unless you are using fakespace or intern-symbol (it seems hardly anyone does), every symbol in your program needs to include its namespace information in order to avoid it being accidentally invoked by somebody else, or accidentally convincing somebody that it's part of the base distribution. In Clojure, it's many little things: Keywords are callable, allowing you to evaluate a keyword on an associative collection like hash-map, or traverse, in an obvious and intuitive way, into a nested associative structure with the threading macros "->" and "->>". The default data structures are fast (for what they are) and hard to misuse: unless you ask politely, you are not going to mutate something your function was passed passed without noticing. seq, the interface for sequences (vectors, lists, pairs from an associative structure), pairs well with destructuring in let and macros/syntax that does binding. Things like 'let' don't use more parentheses than necessary, which has a greater impact on readability than you'd think. The use of vector syntax for bindings rather than list syntax adds a little bit of syntactic texture that makes reading programs more ergonomic. I think Clojure may not be as unfamiliar as it seems at first to a person who's written other lisps before, but I have yet to meet somebody who prefers the experience of writing Scheme or Common Lisp to Clojure; nor anyone who prefers Elisp to Common Lisp.
- celeritascelery 7y agoYou should check dash[1]. It adds a lot of those "many little things" from Clojure (such as ->, and ->>, and let) to elisp. [1]https://github.com/magnars/dash.el https://github.com/magnars/dash.el
- bitwize 7y agoI like to tell the story of how secretaries in the 70s learned how to use and customize Multics Emacs with Emacs Lisp; they were told they were simply customizing their editor, not programming it.
- dmortin 7y agoI have doubts about this. Maybe they did some simple variable settings, but I doubt they wrote proper lisp programs.
- celeritascelery 7y agoThat's the really cool thing about Emacs. The only difference between "simple variable settings" and "proper lisp programs" is a difference of scale, not a difference of kind. Variable settings are just as much code as anything else in Emacs.
- bitwize 7y agoIndeed. (+ 1 2) is a "proper Lisp program". By having all that power available from the start, users can use as much or as little as they need and shape the tool on the fly as they work with it. It's the difference between an extensible text editor and a completely malleable one.
- lkrubner 7y agoMaybe gendered on-ramps are important for getting women into programming: http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/gendered-on-ramps-are-important-to-get-women-into-software-development http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/gendered-on-ramps-are...
- acdha 7y ago> I think you will make Emacs appealing to users when you start asserting it is appealing to users I've worked with a lot of Emacs fans but everyone describes it as having a hefty learning curve. If you tell people it's appealing and the first experience is unpleasant, all you're going to do is convince them that you aren't a reliable source of advice. I think it would be much better to focus on easing that initial stage and explaining it a powerful tool which requires some up-front investment.
- MereInterest 7y agoExactly. Whenever a new developer asks what editor I use, I emphasize that while I use emacs, it has a huge learning curve. It has different conventions than any other text editor, because it predates those conventions.
- taeric 7y agoHave you ever used some of the other popular choices? Pleasant is rarely an accurate term for computer use. And I'm not saying lie. Just stop scaring people away. Emacs is by far one of the most empowering programs out there. Market that. She realize that it is marketing. You want to build a market of users? You have to have some marketing.
- acdha 7y agoRemember that Emacs is competing with things like Visual Studio Code, Atom, Sublime Text, etc. If you tell people that it's easy they're going to try it, bounce off, and conclude you have no idea what you're talking about. If, instead, you tell them what you like about it more than those others they might find they agree with you.
- taeric 7y agoSpeaking as someone that has bounced off the likes of notepad... I think you are overstating the case. I'm not saying to merely claim it and call it a day. I'm saying claim it while showing people how to use it. Make it a dialog that doesn't begin with, our way is harder. It isn't harder. Just different.
- dhosek 7y agoGetting started with Emacs and having basic skills (load, save, cut, copy, paste, search) is WAY faster than with vi. I don't use more than a tiny fraction of emacs's capabilities and likely never will, but the initial part of the learning curve is way easier than it is with something like vi.
- jimhefferon 7y agoBut emacs is not against vi. When I taught a class where I started by introducing emacs, the first question I got was how to make it have this color text and that hentai page background.
- dhosek 7y agoI generally use aquamacs when I need emacs these days (especially since Catalina no longer includes the terminal-based emacs by default). It offers a lot of customizations through menus for the appearance, not to mention that it supports standard cmd-whatever shortcuts for the basic functionality.