7 ms·
I didn't know about the Red Cross and its donuts. The example I've always used for this is helping a friend move. If the friend asks "hey, will you help me mov
by karaterobot 7y ago
I didn't know about the Red Cross and its donuts. The example I've always used for this is helping a friend move.
If the friend asks "hey, will you help me move? I'm buying pizza and beer afterwards!" I will more than likely say yes, even though I can buy my own pizza and beer.
If they instead say "hey, will you help me move? I'll pay you $21.58 for your time," I'd probably bristle. Even though that might be the equivalent price of a few slices of pizza and a beer, the category has changed from showing appreciation to placing an actual value on my time, at which point working all day for $21.58 stops making sense.
- Zenbit_UX 7y agoYou got weird friends, no one's ever had to ask or bribe me, I would just offer to help. In turn I'd also be uncomfortable asking others to do manual labor for me, if they didn't offer when I said I was moving I wouldn't ask. Buying them supper after would be a given, no bribe required.
- ashtonkem 7y ago“I’ll buy you pizza for helping me move” is an extremely common social interaction, to the point of being a trope. It’s not a bribe, it’s an acknowledgement that helping somebody move is a huge amount of work and some token of appreciation is wise. GP doesn’t have weird friends.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoSitting down and having a meal is breaking bread with friends. Thats always more than a simple financial transaction of $20 or so. There was an article that time is our most important resource... Having a meal with someone is giving your most important resource to them, and them to you.
- jhbadger 7y agoAnd when I was TA grading exams, the professor would buy us all pizza as well. It was technically unnecessary as grading was part of why were being paid as TAs, but it was a nice touch and put us all in a better mood and with a favorable view of the professor.
- ncallaway 7y agoI think you've badly missed the point. If you take issue with an analogy, try one that fits your experiences better. You offer to help, and then your friend says: "awesome, afterwards I'll buy you pizza and beer" vs "awesome, afterwards I'll pay you $21.58". The order of offering vs asking for help wasn't at issue in the analogy.
- andrewflnr 7y ago> Buying them supper after would be a given, no bribe required. I think this is actually kind of the point. By offering to provide pizza, you're casually confirming that you're still operating in the paradigm where friends help each other out without looking too closely at the balance sheet, as opposed to offering nothing (awkward) or paying them (turning it into a transaction).
- jrs95 7y agoI think the idea is partly "I could use some help with this, but I'll get some food and drinks and we'll try to hang out and have a good time even though the work part sucks"
- SirSavary 7y agoI've always interpreted it as a "reason" to hang out, or a politeness thing. It also makes it clear that your buddy doesn't plan to shoo you out of their new apartment once you're done the job.
- imperialdrive 7y agoWeird friends are great. Everyone secretly appreciates special handling. Little bribes make the world go round. It's quite an art getting someone to help without them eventually feeling a tiny hint of being taken advantage of, and vice versa.
- hijp 7y agoYeah for me the hangout with the pizza and beer is the real reward!
- boulos 7y agoIn behavioral economics that’s sometimes referred to as “social norms versus market norms” [first useful link, 1]. The example given (I think it’s via Ariely) is that you wouldn’t pay your friend to have cooked you dinner. This is the same thing: there’s social contract value in helping your friend out, and they’re showing appreciation with a token. In fact, if you friend offers you more money than the pizza and beer, you are likely to be insulted by the lowball offer, since you now evaluate the suggestion in terms of work for hire via market norms. Social norms are so powerful though, that even if the friend offers you higher than your market rate, it’s still not worth it to take it, as it would shift your relationship (with lifetime value X) from a social one to a commercial one. Usually when people say “humans are irrational” they should be saying “people have complex utility / reward functions”! [1] https://www.behavioraleconomics.com/resources/introduction-behavioral-economics/ https://www.behavioraleconomics.com/resources/introduction-b...
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoInteresting comment! I have this relatively unconventional theory that, if we use automation just right and make the cost of food production, delivery, and preparation low enough, and also do so where ownership of the machinery is distributed throughout society, that we could make it a social norm to give anyone who needs it free food. All in a voluntary system. We just need to make the actual cost of the whole supply chain low enough that people don't care about giving away a bit for free. Like in the extreme case how cafes give out free wifi because the marginal cost of delivering wifi to one more person is so low. I could imagine shops having a "free food" option made using some low cost proteins and fiber and prepared using some cheap robot. And then they would charge for hand made food or something, using the free food as a loss leader. So my theory is that those robots need to be made as cheaply as possible. And that makes me think they need to be open source so anyone capable of manufacturing them can compete to supply them. Like how 3D printers got so cheap once the patents expired. They went from $30k to $300 in 20 years. The real trick is sustaining robotics businesses that can pay engineering talent to produce open source robotics. Prusa Research has succeeded here with their 3D printers, and I am hoping I am able to reproduce that success with the farming robot I am working on now. But we aren't certain we will make it open source. It depends on how we can sustain funding. I think it's very possible though and I'm committed to it. I think it's extremely interesting that Prusa Research can give all of their IP away and coexist in the market with clones at less than 1/2 the price. Users understand that the first party product is higher quality, and those that can afford it still buy from Prusa. There seems to be room in that market for both Prusa and the many clones. I wonder if we can reproduce this success with automation in other areas.
- mormegil 7y agoAlso, there is this case of a daycare center which started to collect fines for late child pickups. The result? The rate of late pickups increased. Picking the child late stopped being a shameful thing to do, causing the poor worker to wait for you, it started being a normal paid service you could use every time you wanted. https://freakonomics.com/2013/10/23/what-makes-people-do-what-they-do/ https://freakonomics.com/2013/10/23/what-makes-people-do-wha...
- tripzilch 7y agoEven more interesting, and relevant to this discussion, was that the rate didn't decrease again (within the measured time frame) after the fine was removed again! (from the paper linked in your article)
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYou make me think of some study that concluded "Pay enough (market rate) or pay nothing." People who will do volunteer work for an organization because they believe in the mission will walk away and cuss you if you offer them 5 cents an hour for the same work because it's all you can afford to pay.
- alharith 7y agoYou are not just saying yes to 21.58, you are saying yes to the satisfaction of helping a friend and the reward of receiving their appreciation in the form of their chosen gift back to you: pizza and beer, plus the time shared enjoying that pizza and beer together.
- lifeformed 7y agoWhere does a few slices of pizza and a beer cost $21?
- MetallicCloud 7y agoThey said beer, not a beer. In Australia, the cheapest 6 pack you can buy is about $22.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]