6 ms·
I'm wondering how long, or if ever, it takes for reasonable people to resume buying Lenovo products after they got busted using a firmware-based rootkit to rein
by sneak 7y ago
I'm wondering how long, or if ever, it takes for reasonable people to resume buying Lenovo products after they got busted using a firmware-based rootkit to reinstall their manufacturer spyware onto a freshly formatted OS install (the same year they got busted preinstalling third-party adware, which resulted in an FTC settlement/fine).
Do you wait like a year or three? five? Do you never buy Lenovo again? What's reasonable? This isn't rhetoric: I'm legitimately asking for a figure, as well as a rationale, because I don't know the answer.
Personally I'm in the market for a high end laptop for running Linux, and I just couldn't see myself buying something from them ever, no matter how good their machines are, because I just don't trust the people in the organization who develop products to take system integrity seriously enough.
- voqv 7y agoWasn't it claimed that did not happen on the Thinkpad lines?
- _eht 7y agoWasn’t it claimed that it was not happening, generally?
- _eht 7y agoIt’s two years. But seriously check out system76 hardware. I’ve been pleased.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 1MachineElf 7y agoIf system76 would put a TrackPoint onto a laptop keyboard, then I'd never need Lenovo again.
- esaym 7y agoI've thought the same thing. Doesn't IBM hold some patent/royalties on the use of a "trackpoint" though?
- toast0 7y agoSo, make it a extra cost option and have the buyer pay for the license? Or, copy trackpoints from outside of the patent window. A 20 year old trackpoint won't be as good as a modern one (probably, I'm not a trackpoint user), but it's better than no trackpoint?
- 1MachineElf 7y agoProbably. Dell/HP/Panasonic have equivelants that are nearly as good, but named differently. I don't know if those involve royalties to IBM or Lenovo. TEX Keyboards in Taiwan also makes a TrackPoint-enabled keyboard too.
- nessunodoro 7y agoIs there a way to detect such big brother firmware and flash it?
- gruez 7y agoIt's a non-issue if you're not using windows. Basically it's a windows "feature" where if a certain ACPI table is present in the firmware, it will download and execute it. There isn't actually any malware/spyware executing on the firmware itself.
- airstrike 7y ago> Basically it's a windows "feature" where if a certain ACPI table is present in the firmware, it will download and execute it. What in the actual fuck... this seems straight off a dystopian graphic novel
- sneak 7y agohttps://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html When I play movies I've paid for on my iPad I've paid for, if I want to screenshot frames from them to share or reference or meme, the screenshots come out as black rectangles.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoSarcasm: That’s because it would be trivial to screenshot every frame and reassemble the video from there. No fair use for you!
- toast0 7y agoThe intent is that manufacturers would use this to provide critical drivers for windows users. Stuff that wasn't on the retail OS cd, but you would need to get to windows update. Or something, I dunno. Of course, the race to the bottom being what it is, if you can get $20/unit to put sketchy garbage in it, it's going to happen. Just because you're paying for something doesn't mean you're not also the product.
- eropple 7y agoI wipe machines on arrival as a matter of course, so I never stopped buying Lenovo machines, but I only buy Thinkpads and AFAIK they were only pulling that shit with consumer-level machines (which are already a wasteland across most manufacturers—not an excuse, to be sure).
- wrkronmiller 7y ago> busted using a firmware-based rootkit to reinstall their manufacturer spyware onto a freshly formatted OS install Re-imaging the OS would not help in this case, so you would only be protected if Lenovo did not, in fact, put the rootkit on the Thinkpad line.
- eropple 7y agoTIL - I think I had mistaken it for that period of time when they were installing Superfish onto consumer machines. Thanks!
- josteink 7y agoThe other option is not running Windows, the only OS which is vulnerable to this UEFI malware injection. And then you just don’t care about stuff like that, because it honestly doesn’t affect you the slightest.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI still care because it's a strong indicator for the culture at Lenovo. If they were willing to do this then what else might they be doing that we haven't discovered yet.
- igneo676 7y agoMy understanding is that the Thinkpad line is a bit segmented from the rest of the company. As a result, those poor decisions haven't effected the Thinkpad line. It helps also that I immediately switch everything over to Linux I do understanding that it's entirely feasible for them to rootkit Linux from the BIOS and install malware onto their Thinkpads but I just haven't seen it happen yet
- igneo676 7y agoFor what it's worth, I also own quite a few of their older laptop lines (Mainly X230's) and I've been slowly flashing Coreboot onto them I know that's not feasible for their newer lines, which I also own
- josteink 7y ago> I do understanding that it's entirely feasible for them to rootkit Linux from the BIOS and install malware onto their Thinkpads but I just haven't seen it happen yet It’s not actually, because the mechanism which allows a vendor to provide “drivers” via UEFI is used by Windows only and nobody else. Windows exclusively is the target of such UEFI abuse. Lenovo can put as much garbage and bloatware they want in the relevant UEFI firmware-sections, and Linux will simply ignore it, like it always have. No root-kit will be triggered. As a Linux-user you are actually 100% immune against this abuse. As a ThinkPad-owner doubly so, since this major fuck-up only affected budget/non-Thinkpad product-lines.
- aesh2Xa1 7y agoHm, it was a problem on the professional ThinkPad line as well. https://thehackernews.com/2015/09/lenovo-laptop-virus.html?m=1 https://thehackernews.com/2015/09/lenovo-laptop-virus.html?m...
- Stratoscope 7y agoNaw, that story is ridiculous. One person bought two "refurbished" ThinkPads from IBM and claims they found some stuff on them. Show me one example - any example - of Lenovo installing any of this kind of stuff on a factory fresh ThinkPad, and then we'll have something to talk about. Until then, I suggest ignoring biased and axe-grinding sources like "thehackernews".
- tobyjsullivan 7y agoIt seems to me this would be a function of available alternatives more than anything else. Some Lenovo products, as best I can tell, make for excellent Linux machines. What are the alternatives if that's your criteria? There are alternatives which might be acceptable depending on your other requirements for hardware, form factor, price, or geographic availability. But for some subset of requirements, Lenovo is still going to be the best option by a wide margin which is going to push someone to making that tradeoff. I don't think it's a function of time. edit: "some Lenovo products"
- javajosh 7y agoThe odd thing is that I don't remember this, do you have a link. I mean, I remember the Bloomberg article that claimed unauthorized physical embeds on PCBs from China. But I don't remember the Indestructible Lenovo Spyware scandal!
- sneak 7y agohttps://www.zdnet.com/article/lenovo-rootkit-ensured-its-software-could-not-be-deleted/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/lenovo-rootkit-ensured-its-sof...
- rahimnathwani 7y agoNice explanation of how it works: https://www.howtogeek.com/226308/the-windows-platform-binary-table-why-crapware-can-come-back-after-a-clean-install/ https://www.howtogeek.com/226308/the-windows-platform-binary...
- onemoresoop 7y agoThe trend seems unstoppable, windows telemetry is not optional, apple owns your system, google reads theough your personal information, etc. Pointing only to lenovo isn’t better than pointing to this general tendency of collecting our data non-optionally
- freeone3000 7y agoI should be bothered in a theoretical sense, but I'm just not in a practical sense. I just bought a Legion series because it was the best deal (because Asus doesn't sell in my country). If I'm running Windows, I'm going to get random arbitrary bloat anyway, so I don't really see the mechanism as important.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI’d have no problem buying Lenovo if that’s what my local computer store was offering as refurbished reasonably priced laptops. When I was last in the market they were offering HP, so that’s what I got. That Lenovo fucked up at some point in the past is immaterial to my purchasing decisions. And I consider myself a fairly reasonable person.
- deepspace 7y agoFor me, it is never. I tend to trust people and companies to do the right thing, but when they violate that trust, they get on my permanent blacklist. I also don't fly United or park in Impark lots for the same reason. And I will never again turn off my ad-blocker after the Forbes fiasco, despite sites begging me to do so.
- wmf 7y agoYou can find a reason to blacklist every company and then you can't buy anything.
- McAtNite 7y agoThere’s a difference between being nit picky and blacklisting a company for being openly hostile to their customers. Will I ever create a new Facebook account? No. Will I ever open a Wells Fargo account after their habit of making faking ones? Nope. Writing off a company for adding root kits to their machines out of the box seems to be perfectly reasonable.
- burnishing 7y agoDo you use Aspirin?
- toast0 7y agoDo you acetylsalicylic acid or a specific manufacturer's product? Regardless, a lot of people would say no to either, acetomenephen and ibuprofen have largely replaced Asprin for most uses.
- distances 7y agoI've never had aspirin to my knowledge. I wonder how it's possible it's been gone for decades and it's still somehow a known product name.
- 7y ago
- wmf 7y agoArguably you might want to buy from the company that had the most recent scandal because they're more likely to be on their best behavior.
- Tepix 7y agoDoesn‘t seem true for Facebook.
- TACIXAT 7y agoI'm in the security industry and bought a ThinkPad (X1 Carbon) 6 months ago. It has the form factor and specs that I want. What is the threat model? They will not be using the rootkit for hiding useland malware. Are they extracting my documents and misuing them? Are they performing MITM on my connections and doing something harmful? While the capability is there, I don't see the software being used in a way that will inconvenience me. It is a weak point in the system, maybe someone else exploits it, but I have so much software that I can say that about. When looking at threats the question for me is what is most likely to get me owned. It will probably be phishing or a malicious document. That's not going to change based on the manufacturer I buy from. If I do get owned by some targeted malware that uses a Lenovo driver for priv esc, well they were probably going to get me with or without that. As good as it would feel to boycott a company with poor security practices, I'm over running unrefined System76 laptops.
- headmelted 7y ago“ Are they extracting my documents and misuing them? Are they performing MITM on my connections and doing something harmful? While the capability is there, I don't see the software being used in a way that will inconvenience me.” Please explain this further. Not snark, genuinely curious.
- TACIXAT 7y agoThere are capabilities that can be misused, but I generally trust the companies with those capabilities to not misuse them. Maybe Lenovo will include a sketchy driver, but I trust Lenovo to not use that driver to drop ransomware on my machine. In the same sense I trust Google with my location and emails. You may trust an AV company that can upload any file on your machine to not grab your tax returns and open a new credit card in your name. Even if Lenovo starts intercepting my private web traffic or placing files on my machine there is only so much damage they can do. They are not about to frame me by dropping plans to overthrow the government in my downloads folder then blackmailing me to design more secure drivers for no pay. There are threats I'm afraid of and a computer manufacturer, no matter how negligent, is not one of them. Is OP avoiding Intel too? Meh.
- 7y ago
- the_pwner224 7y agoUntil upper management changes. They are the ones who encourage this behavior (if not directly, then indirectly so they have plausible deniability - see Wells Fargo - but still intentionally). Only when they change is there a hope of this sort of behavior changing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chmln 7y agoThe very first thing I do after buying any laptop is completely wiping everything and installing Linux or re-installing Windows. I think it's best to always start from clean slate because even 'good' manufacturers put a tonne of shit in there. So in that sense, it doesn't really matter what the manufacturer does, apart from the terrible decision making that they should learn from.
- fhelik 7y agoThey used to use firmware-based rootkit to reinstall their manufacturer spyware onto a freshly formatted OS install. So, not matter what you do, they will reinstall even if you format the hard drive.
- josteink 7y agoBut only if you use Windows. The person you replied to also suggested running Linux instead, in which case you are not affected.
- jlgaddis 7y agoMany manufacturers, invluding Lenovo, are starting to support the "Linux Virtual Firmware Service" [0]. Honestly, I would not be surprised if one of them, at some point, tried something like this with Linux, too. --- [0]: https://fwupd.org https://fwupd.org
- josteink 7y agoBut that is a good thing, really. The only thing this does, is enable you to update your UEFI BIOS and other machine-firmware from Linux, without having to have a separate dual-boot OS like Windows (or bootable USB sticks) to do that one task, and it frees you from having to download and obtain proprietary firmware-installers/checks per device you want updated etc. I consider it apt-get for firmware and use it all the time. Everything in one place, easy to keep up to date etc. It's great! And very importantly: It does in no way enable the UEFI-abuse with bloatware "drivers" as outlined earlier, which is still a Windows-only phenomena, because Linux does not check for nor use these drivers. Edit: Oh hey there Jeremy. Long time no see! Where did my good ol' IRC buddy go these days? :D
- darren0 7y agoI honestly don't think most people care about this and have already forgotten about it.
- elric 7y agoI don't like Lenovo. Their laptops have steadily declined by every metric I care about since the X220. But Thinkpads are still better (by those same metrics) than anything else I've come across. Would be willing to buy something else. Anything else. But most other laptops out there have even worse keyboards (which I deeply care about), terrible form factors, specs that are stuck in 2010, awful support/warranty, no Linux support, or all of the above! If someone builds something I'm happy with, I'll buy it. Price is not an issue. My laptop is my toolbox. I want it to work the way I like it. If it breaks, I need to have fixed preferably today, but tomorrow or the day after can be acceptable as well. That basically leaves Lenovo & Dell.
- nunodonato 7y agoSystem76?
- esaym 7y agoNo AMD option, I don't think.
- modzu 7y agoif only they werent plastic. my laptops would be toast after about a year but my mbp is going on 5 (did have to replace the screen, but was done under warranty)
- sam_lowry_ 7y agoThe web is full of complaints about System76. And the, they have really cheap parts compared to Thinkpads.
- joey_bob 7y agoI just looked at the System76 laptops, and they are strikingly similar to the Powerspec(Micro Center)/Sager laptops? Is the resemblance superficial or something else?
- cowmoo728 7y agoSystem76 uses Clevo/Sager laptops. However, they don't "just" pull off the shelf computers and put an OS on them, they're involved with the design of the laptops from the beginning. This thread has more information from someone who works at System76. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17039414 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17039414
- kohtatsu 7y agoThank you for the reminder; I firmly believe in voting with wallets, and they haven't done enough to regain my trust after Superfish and the BIOS bloat installer fiasco.
- pmlnr 7y agoThat.was.not.the.thinkpad.line. Please, ffs, learn the difference.
- sam_lowry_ 7y agoThey had rootkits on Yoga, Ideapad and other fancy models. Business-oriented laptops did not have rootkits.