4 ms·
Sure, and in most cities incredible amounts of condos have been built and prices of rent for low-income individuals have increased massively. It does not work
by sudosysgen 7y ago
Sure, and in most cities incredible amounts of condos have been built and prices of rent for low-income individuals have increased massively.
It does not work in the real world. Supply is not supply. For one, these condos being built can essentially not be rented, and that means that they are not supply for low and middle income individuals.
- WalterBright 7y agoIf demand increases faster than supply increases, then prices go up. It does not mean supply&demand theory is invalid.
- sudosysgen 7y agoSo, demand and supply has increased dramatically in almost every single city in the world, and in almost no cities has supply outpaced demand? The world is not an economics 101 textbook. In Canada for example, the only province with functional and affordable housing is the one that enacted serious rent control and public housing, and they didn't have to build a lot. Seems to me that supply and demand isn't the whole thing if your goal is to have affordable housing.
- WalterBright 7y ago> in almost no cities has supply outpaced demand? Detroit. Rural communities. In real estate, it takes a while (years) for supply to catch up with demand. What you're seeing is simply city populations are rising quickly.
- sudosysgen 7y agoDetroit has some of the greatest increases in rent in the US[0]. Despite its population decreasing [1]. As for rural communities, they are not comparable in the slightest to cities. [0] : https://detroit.curbed.com/2020/3/4/21164568/detroit-rent-rates-increase-downtown-midtown https://detroit.curbed.com/2020/3/4/21164568/detroit-rent-ra... [1] : https://worldpopulationreview.com/us-cities/detroit-population/ https://worldpopulationreview.com/us-cities/detroit-populati...
- WalterBright 7y ago> As for rural communities, they are not comparable in the slightest to cities. Anything can be proven by discarding data that doesn't fit. Rural population is in decline, and prices drop with it. You can even buy entire towns in Appalachia for a song. > Detroit Your own cite says: “New housing construction has barely kept pace with the growth in housing demand over the past decade.”
- sudosysgen 7y ago>Your own cite says: “New housing construction has barely kept pace with the growth in housing demand over the past decade.” This is an empty statement the article writer wrote to attempt to justify it. Housing demand in Detroit cannot have increased, because the population of Detroit was and is decreasing. If you can explain to me how a decreasing population can mean an increase in demand, I'd be all ears.
- asdff 7y agoWhat groups of people are moving in and out of Detroit? One explanation could be that people who previously could afford rents in Detroit can no longer do so, and the ones moving in are the ones who can afford these rents and mortgages. A lot of these low income neighborhoods in inner city Detroit have been raised and left to nature over the years, historic supply in the city center has been destroyed and what is left or is currently being constructed might be pricier housing comparatively. The working class greatly outnumbers the capital class everywhere. Take it with a grain of salt as I don't have any data in front of me, I'm merely postulating, but this would explain this trend.
- sudosysgen 7y agoThe rate of occupied housing in Detroit has drastically decreased, while average rent has increased. If the supply and demand hypothesis of the real estate market held, one would believe that given the fungibility and non-stratified nature of housing in a given city, cratering occupancy rates would correspond to a decrease in average rent priced. If you believe that housing is indeed stratified and that the surplus of affordable housing has so little an effect on the average price of rent in the entire city, whose average income I should remind you is of under 30 000$ while the average price of rent is of more than 12 000$ a year, then I see no way that building luxury apartments could still mean a sizeable decrease in the price of affordable housing in say, Toronto.
- jeromegv 7y agoToronto (as a region) is getting about 100 000 new residents every year. It's hard to say that supply and demand isn't working because really, there is SO MUCH DEMAND, supply can hardly catchup. Montreal still has a decent cost of living for housing and guess what, that's because their demand is lower (harder for non-French speaking people to establish themselves there)
- sudosysgen 7y agoThat is true, but it is not the whole answer, as rent increases even in cities where population is stagnant or decreasing. But yes, Toronto needs more affordable high density rental housing, as well as much better transit.
- asdff 7y agoCalifornia is short by millions of units. This number can be calculated. A cheap city example is Cleveland. The reason why it's so cheap? In 1960, 900,000 people lived there. Today, 400,000 people live there. The population of LA in 1960 was 2.4 million. Today, its over 4 million in the city proper. Units in LA are on the market for a weekend, you sign your lease on monday, and move in by thursday. In Cleveland, listings stay up for months. The result is that 600k buys you two bedrooms and a bath in LA, and six bedrooms and seven baths in Cleveland. It's a very basic supply and demand problem.
- maxsilver 7y ago> A cheap city example is Cleveland. The reason why it's so cheap? In 1960, 900,000 people lived there. Today, 400,000 people live there. Cleveland is not actually that cheap (it just looks dirt cheap to people earning Californian dollars). And Cleveland would instantly be as expensive as California, if Silicon Valley headquartered there instead of California -- the fact that 900k people once lived there would not help in any way. The prices of places is largely not determined by supply or demand. It's determined by the value of the property around it, and that property in aggregate is determined by the wealth of the jobs congregated there, and the concentration of capital located there. Only by redefining "demand" to not mean "persons needing homes" but instead to mean "anything that impacts the price" can you make a supply vs demand model work for housing. > The population of LA in 1960 was 2.4 million. Today, its over 4 million in the city proper. Units in LA are on the market for a weekend, you sign your lease on monday, and move in by thursday. The population of Grand Rapids, Michigan was ~198k in 1970. Today, it's still ~198k in 2020 -- same population, almost exactly. Despite this, units in Grand Rapids are on the market for a weekend, you sign your lease on Monday, and move in by Thursday. Despite this, units cost has increased by about 700% during that time. Because, again, supply and demand are not the primary factors in housing costs in the US. They haven't been for over 50+ years now.
- WalterBright 7y ago> It's determined by the value of the property around it, and that property in aggregate is determined by the wealth of the jobs congregated there, and the concentration of capital located there. The value of something is set by what people are willing to pay for it. I.e. supply and demand. > Despite this, units cost has increased by about 700% during that time. Average inflation since 1970 is 565%. 700% is within that, as inflation measurements are inexact and there are regional differences as well.
- triceratops 7y ago> For one, these condos being built can essentially not be rented, Non-occupancy tax. Vancouver has one.[1] 1. https://vancouver.ca/home-property-development/empty-homes-tax.aspx https://vancouver.ca/home-property-development/empty-homes-t...
- sudosysgen 7y agoA non-occupancy tax is orthogonal to this particular issue, a lot of high rise condos cannot be rented, reasonably. And so they are only accessible to people that can afford to buy them, occupied or not.
- triceratops 7y agoWhy can't they be rented?
- sudosysgen 7y agoExorbitant HOA/Condo Association fees and regulations that make renting out a condo unfeasible, or outright banned.
- triceratops 7y agoCool. So then people who buy condos for investment will have to choose between paying the non-occupancy tax or putting their money in property that isn't encumbered by those regulations. Accordingly the price of condos in buildings with such regulations should fall. Alternatively, if a city council has the votes to implement a non-occupancy tax, they may have the votes to nullify HOA clauses that forbid renting. Or levy additional taxes on such HOAs. Since it's the HOA that's forbidding renting, the HOA should foot the bill for the non-occupancy tax, not the owner of the unit. It's fairly common to include HOA dues and fees in the rent when renting out a condo.
- sudosysgen 7y agoI would like to see that happen then. It might work. However, even in Vancouver the occupancy tax is not being enforced nearly rigorously enough for such an effect, and the occupancy tax is still too little.
- matchbok 7y agoThis is incorrect. Those homes are expensive because the land beneath them is expensive. The finishes are largely irrelevant. And the land is expensive because there are not enough places like them.
- asdff 7y agoIt all comes down to job growth driving demand on housing supply. The better the local economy, the more hiring is going on, the more people are recruited and look for housing convenient to work. Hardly anyone uproots themselves and moves to a new city without having a job lined up first. The value of the underlying land is speculative based on demand induced by job growth.