3 ms·
Between the states. So the President could, for example, close the border between Georgia and South Carolina. But he couldn't, for example, close Georgia inte
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Between the states. So the President could, for example, close the border between Georgia and South Carolina. But he couldn't, for example, close Georgia internally.
- throwaway_USD 7y agoWell that is how the law reads, but its not how it is applied. Put it this way the federal government uses the commerce clause to regulate everything from farmers growing marijuana; farmer feeding their live stock excess crops they grew; restaurants from discriminating against diners on race; etc... There is no shortage of case law over 200 years showing how States rights have all but completely eroded to the Federal Government through the commerce clause...you don't see many farms or restaurants crossing state boarders but federal government can regulate them on the basis of effecting interstate commerce.
- gamblor956 7y agoThe President could not order Georgia closed internally or close the border between Georgia and South Carolina because the President does not have that power. Congress could pass a law allowing the President to do so in response to health emergencies or other national disasters (a delegation of its powers under the Commerce Clause), but no such law currently exists.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> but no such law currently exists. It could effectively be done under the existing broad quarantine provisions of the Public Health Service Act, especially if it didn't expressly order a lockdown but instead ordered that anyone engaging in the kind of activities that would normally be prohibited in a lockdown was subject to summary detention for examination until shown not to be infectious.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 7y agoThe PHSA only grants the power to quarantine someone who is infected, or reasonably believed to be infected. The PHSA does not grant the Executive the power to issue a broad quarantine that could cover non-infected individuals. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/264 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/264