7 ms·
So I was recently looking at those as options for a very low budget video editing PC for someone, and yes, AMD destroys intel in raw CPU performance for the sam
by gambiting 7y ago
So I was recently looking at those as options for a very low budget video editing PC for someone, and yes, AMD destroys intel in raw CPU performance for the same price, however in those low-budget applications Intel has an upper hand - integrated GPU. With AMD you either have to go with the super crappy 3400G, which is a really poor CPU(but also very cheap), or for literally anything else + a dedicated GPU(which increases the cost significantly above Intel's offering). I was surprised to find out it's actually cheaper to go with say i5 9400 with an integrated GPU than with Ryzen 5 3600 + cheapest dedicated GPU. Yes the dedicated gpu will be better than intel's offering(marginally so) but if you only care about the CPU performance, don't have a lot of money and yet you need something to drive your monitor, then Intel has that integrated GPU to offer that AMD lacks.
- XzAeRosho 7y agoYou still have the Ryzen 5 3400G with integrated graphics
- jeffbee 7y agoThis is the problem with AMD's intentionally misleading marketing. The Ryzen 5 3400G is an APU with a Zen+ CPU. The CPU core that's actually good, that everybody wants, is the Zen2. The Zen+ is pretty slow. It has performance comparable to $99 Intel CPUs from last year.
- zrm 7y agoCan you name this Intel CPU which is as fast, has an iGPU and costs $99? Zen2 is faster than Zen+, but Zen+ isn't that slow.
- jeffbee 7y agoNo, I think the nearest thing is probably the $140 Core i3-9100. But look at Anandtech's comparison of the Zen and Zen2: at the same clock speed and core count, Zen2 stomps all over Zen. It's a much slower CPU. https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2333?vs=2590 https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2333?vs=2590
- zrm 7y ago> No, I think the nearest thing is probably the $140 Core i3-9100. Which has approximately equivalent CPU performance and a slower iGPU than a 3200G which costs $40 less. > https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2333?vs=2590 https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2333?vs=2590 The 2400G is Zen1. The APUs use different numbering. The 2500X is Zen+: https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2259?vs=2590 https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2259?vs=2590 Zen2 is something like 15% faster give or take. Zen+ was never really that slow.
- jeffbee 7y agoIf by "15% ±" you meant 30-50% then we agree. I don't see any individual results (other than GPU-limited games) where the Zen2 is not at least 15% faster, and on most of them it's at least 20% faster, on specific relevant workloads like 7-Zip compression the newer part is almost twice as fast, while drawing 2/3rds the power.
- zrm 7y agoIt's ~6% faster for GIMP, <4% faster on AES encoding, ~10% faster on Cinebench ST, ~11% faster on Blender, ~3% faster on Luxmark etc. It does really well on 7zip in particular. If you spend all day unzipping things you should be very interested in Zen2. Also, the 3100 and 2500X are both 65W.
- jeffbee 7y agoYou're right, I looked at the wrong link.
- NullPrefix 7y agoThis benchmark compares Zen against Zen2, not Zen+ against Zen2
- bryanlarsen 7y agoYes, the article expresses some surprise that the new Ryzen 3 chips are based on binned Ryzen 5/7 3000's, rather than on the new and exciting Ryzen Mobile 4000's which do have integrated graphics and are benchmarking very well. Hopefully some Ryzen Mobile based desktop chips are coming soon too.
- SomeoneFromCA 7y agoHopefully some inventive friends from Aliexpress retrofit these mobile cpus for AM4 socket, like they did with mobile i7s.
- toast0 7y agoIf you wait a little longer, AMD is expected to release these as Desktop APUs; I don't think I've seen a comitted release window yet, though. My guess is sometime q3, but I would love for it to be sooner.
- gautamcgoel 7y agoI totally agree. A lot of these CPU review articles are aimed at gamers and hence ignore integrated graphics entirely, since it's assumed you'll go out and buy a nice discrete graphics card.
- Exmoor 7y agoI think this is why you mostly see these cheap articles called out as being ideal for gaming rigs where you're highly likely to be adding a dedicated GPU anyway. Even a low end card like a $120 RX 570 is going to be 600+% faster than the built in Intel GPU: https://gpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-UHD-Graphics-630-Desktop-Coffee-Lake-i5-i7-vs-AMD-RX-570/m356797vs3924 https://gpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-UHD-Graphics-630... Even for video editing the math might change a bit since modern video editing apps can leverage GPU for rendering. That said, I agree with the folks who say that AMD releasing desktop chips built on Zen 2 with built in GPU cannot come fast enough.
- SomeoneFromCA 7y ago$120 is sensitive amount of money for someone who wants to use a machine only for development. I am wondering why AMD would manufacture ultra low end potato cards which would cost like $35, only for office use. That would boost the sales big time.
- morsch 7y agoPCI Express cards based on NVIDIA GeForce GT 710 are available new for <40 EUR. Presumably there's a large clearance and used market with much lower prices. None of that is an option?
- pedrocr 7y agoI looked at this exact thing yesterday and those are currently the best option. They're also passively cooled which is nice. Having to use NVIDIA is annoying because of the story around Linux support. I mostly worry about these being old new stock and having poor reliability because of that but maybe it's fine.
- toast0 7y agoNew old stock is probably not a big deal for GPUs ... There's not a lot that's going to go bad on one that's just been stored for a couple years. From arcade collecting experience, big things that go bad in storage are batteries, and capacitors, and maybe dust accumulation. But a GPU doesn't have batteries, and capacitors usually take 10+ years to degrade in absence of heat from usage or bad chemicals (and heat makes that worse, so you'ld already know there was another bad cap scourge). You can also avoid all that by getting a new design GT 710 https://www.anandtech.com/show/15713/asus-launches-an-old-gpu-the-nvidia-gt-710-with-four-hdmi-ports https://www.anandtech.com/show/15713/asus-launches-an-old-gp...
- bane 7y agoThere's an important market segment though that these will suit well. People on budgets doing upgrades of cheap systems. They'll likely continue to use their old video card, which will probably be better than Intel's integrated GPU, but will swap out the motherboard and CPU (and maybe RAM). When I was much younger, and on much more of a budget, these "computers of theseus" were my main rigs for a long time. The meta-game was to try to see how few parts you had to swap out from piecemeal upgrade to piecemeal upgrade.
- leetcrew 7y ago> When I was much younger, and on much more of a budget, these "computers of theseus" were my main rigs for a long time. The meta-game was to try to see how few parts you had to swap out from piecemeal upgrade to piecemeal upgrade. I still do it like this, despite having plenty of money to spend on hardware. if it ain't broke...
- pedrocr 7y agoThis is really annoying when building a NAS too. Great value CPUs with ECC support make the configurations great and then you need to spend 50-100€ to just get boot graphics even though the machine will be headless 99% of the time. Buying something second hand or from aliexpress defeats the purpose of trying to build something reliable. The market for low-end discrete GPUs has all but vanished thanks to Intel integrated GPUs. AMD should add a very basic GPU to every CPU part just good enough for boot graphics and consoles. All the motherboards already include the outputs themselves so only a little bit of silicon in the CPU is missing.
- derefr 7y ago> and then you need to spend 50-100€ to just get boot graphics even though the machine will be headless 99% of the time. Buy a serial-over-USB patch cable; connect it from the NAS to your laptop; open an STTY emulator on the laptop. No boot graphics needed.
- toast0 7y agoStill need something for boot graphics for the BIOS, unless non-server motherboards are coming with serial redirection default enabled and nobody mentioned it.
- kllrnohj 7y agoSet it up with a temporary card and then yank it out after it's setup. You don't tend to access the BIOS that much.
- ciupicri 7y agoI wonder if it's possible to set up the UEFI firmware by setting some EFI variables from the operating system for example by running efivar [1]. [1]: https://github.com/rhboot/efivar https://github.com/rhboot/efivar
- derefr 7y agoI mean, why not use a server motherboard (i.e. one supporting AMT; not necessarily one that requires RDIMMs) if you're building a NAS? NASes are servers in terms of their workload. Take advantages of the features designed for server customers.
- derefr 7y agoI would presume that, if you have a low-budget application with high scale (e.g. you're a company designing a NAS, or other "Turing-complete but still embedded" system), then you'd ignore both Intel and AMD and look at ARM-based SoC solutions, no? You can get significantly better integrated graphics, for cheaper, on e.g. Nvidia's Tegra platform. Thus why Nintendo—ROI penny-pinchers to a fault—chose it.
- glram 7y agoDefinitely. If you're going for something integrated, Intel/AMD (and maybe x86 in general) are out of the question. For a PC, though, using ARM can be tough if you're trying to use Windows. I'm not sure how many Windows programs have ARM binaries.
- ksec 7y agoAs you suggested I think there is market for Desktop using the Ryzen Mobile 4000 Parts. This used to be a thing where the Motherboard maker would sell the Board + Mobile Chip soldered. Not sure if you could still do that. And it is not like Zen 2 Desktop APU aren't coming. Just a tad later. I think the current roadmap from AMD is pretty solid. Although I do wish their sales and marketing execution to be much better.
- greggyb 7y agoAliexpress has some good mini-PCs based on mobile CPUs. It's been a while since I went shopping for one, so I'm not sure where they are, right now. Since these are typically <=15W parts, they can be passively cooled. Most are fanless, from what I've seen. I run OpenBSD on an i5-5200U I picked up a few years ago (probably 2015, or early 2016). It serves as my router and runs a bunch of services for me. It lives in my basement next to the fiber line coming in from the road. I wouldn't be surprised if an AMD -H part comes to market soon in this category.
- Macha 7y agoThere never was a 3600G or 3800G. So I'm imagine the next APU will also stop at a 4400G, which given its priced/placed so low in their stack, may not actually be better as a CPU than some Zen+ parts still hanging around like the 2600x or 1600AF, and almost certainly won't be as good as higher tier Zen2 parts like the 3700x or 4900H. I also think there would be a market for a 4900H in a desktop form factor but I don't think AMD will make one.
- gameswithgo 7y agoZen2 desktop cpus with integrated gpus are the next thing AMD will be releasing.
- greggyb 7y agoFew thoughts for your friend. This is not a "you're wrong" post, but a "here are some options to consider, with different tradeoffs." 1. The AMD R3-3300X is neck and neck with the Intel i5-9600K in most productivity benchmarks in the GN test suite.[0] The 9600K is a step up from the 9400 you're looking at, so you could likely do an R3 build. With the clock differences, it's likely that the R3 would pull ahead of the 9400. The processor is $120 MSRP, but not available just yet. Also, you'll likely want to pair it with a B550 motherboard. Nevertheless, with a cheapest-available graphics card, this should be price-competitive with an i5-9400. The future upside is huge, as you could get a beast R9-3950X in a couple years when the price has come down a lot. 2. The AMD R5-1600AF is actually a Zen+ part, and MSRPs at $85. The theme of the entire 3300X review video I linked is to get one of these if you can. Availability is limited and resellers are marking up significantly. AMD is committed to providing more, though. 3. Depending on where your price/performance threshold is, dropping to an R5-2600 brings your price difference to $26 ($224 vs $250 for CPU+mobo and CPU+mobo+graphics, respectively). This should edge out the 1600AF mentioned above, and regularly beat the i5-9400.[1][2] Of the options above, I'd lean toward the R3-3300X. This gives future expansion to a 16-core monster that is a chart topper for productivity workloads. You cannot make that jump with Intel, because their competitor is the 10980XE on a different chipset than the i5. Additionally, Ryzen 3000 and B550 supports PCIe gen 4, for double the bandwidth. Again, this is a future expansion option that you don't get with Intel. My preference is definitely subjective, and there are good reasons to go for the Intel i5, first among them that you can buy the system today, instead of in a month. [0] GN 3300x review: https://youtu.be/NM2fFpzPKPg?t=1063 https://youtu.be/NM2fFpzPKPg?t=1063 [1] Cheapest i5: https://pcpartpicker.com/list/B3pFtp https://pcpartpicker.com/list/B3pFtp [2] Cheapest R5 2600: https://pcpartpicker.com/list/HttVyk https://pcpartpicker.com/list/HttVyk
- greggyb 7y agoAn update. Phoronix's benchmarking includes the i5-9400F, which is the no-iGPU version of the Intel chip. F chips are typically expected to edge ahead of their iGPU siblings. The 3300X beats the 9400F in nearly every single benchmark (I think two or three total exceptions). Additionally, the 9400F seems to struggle to even beat the 8400. Their composite scores are insignificantly different. Perhaps this is why a 9400 is cheaper than an 8400.... https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd-ryzen-313&num=1 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd-ryze...
- AlfeG 7y agoFor this reason, I bought used cheapest GPU with 3 outputs. More than happy.