3 ms·
Right. But somebody who uses both word processors and slide programs can definitely cross-compare in terms of UI quality and polish. To pick a more obvious dim
by wpietri 7y ago
Right. But somebody who uses both word processors and slide programs can definitely cross-compare in terms of UI quality and polish.
To pick a more obvious dimension, if somebody said, "Word is buggier than Powerpoint", nobody would say, "You can't compare them because they don't do the same thing." Bugginess is an abstractable quality across kinds of product.
The same thing is true about UI quality. It goes well beyond intuitiveness. You can look at fit-and-finish details. You can look at number of unnecessary actions. You can look at difficulty for novices completing common tasks. You can compare utility of error messages. How much are key concepts related to a task obvious vs hidden? Et cetera, et cetera.
In my experience, Inkscape is better in that dimension. I think this even though I have used GIMP a lot more, and so normally would be biased the other way, because familiarity makes its UI issues less obvious to me.