5 ms·
Imagine how much a company could make if the guy at the top was a hard cutter that didn't put up with unscientific money wasting! They could clean out all of th
by whatshisface 7y ago
Imagine how much a company could make if the guy at the top was a hard cutter that didn't put up with unscientific money wasting! They could clean out all of the people who anti-did their jobs (managers who pollute the information stream for personal interest reasons, consultants who give you advice that was worse than what you would do otherwise), and then they would clean out any market.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIf it’s so easy, why isn’t everyone doing it?
- jlbnjmn 7y agoBecause cable advertising sales reps take you out to lunch, give you box seat tickets to NFL games, and create all of your reports for you. Which is even easier. Also, some people measure their self worth on the size of their company's ad budget. And those same people tend to have stupid amounts of money compared to their childhood peer groups. So buying ads is like adding a set of metal balls to a truck hitch. Revenue was never the point. Also, a lot of entrepreneurs have short attention spans and constantly change things out of fear, taking it from easy to do well to impossible to know.
- steventharlow 7y agoWhat would you say is the best advertising for a small business or application to do?
- jlbnjmn 7y agoWhat product or service is being sold, and to who?
- steve76 7y agoProbably more going on under the radar. $20 million is a big advertising account. You buy access to other people at that level. It's both cut throat and charitable. No hesitation in labeling failure and bad management. Beloved brands and concepts do not fail because people like them. Listen closely and you can hear what leadership wants. Neurological and genetic research. Education. Social reforms limiting violence and poverty. Taking care of the most vulnerable, the elderly and sick and the abused. Also nothing wrong with having fun! Really, what would the top of the food chain do if they were me? Having money often ties you down. You can't just brute force your solution because there's too much too loose.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoLook at all the biggest spenders in Advertising: most of them are all big brand advertisers where proving ROI is nearly impossible. In that type of environment, in the absence of a good ROI calculation, a lot of BS can prosper.
- austincheney 7y agoPeer pressure and lack of confidence. It doesn’t really matter how obvious, in hindsight, or how wonderful some decision is. Moving against the tide or investing in something original scares the shit out of most people.
- carapace 7y agoI hate that question so much.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIf someone doesn’t ask, how will we learn from those with something to teach? I ask because I’m curious!
- carapace 7y agoSorry, it's not you, it's a pet peeve of mine. I used to collect ideas and there are so many things out there that no one seems to know about. Whenever I tried to talk about them there's always someone who asks that question. It's a BS question though, because it presupposes that humans somehow always instantly adopt the great new thing, but history shows that we just don't. (E.g. Marconi was called before US Congress to testify because they thought radio might be a scam.) We have all kinds of awesome stuff that gets ignored. Or even simple obvious things that no one notices (Why do refrigerators have doors instead of drawers?) Sorry for picking on you. Nothing personal. :-)
- toomuchtodo 7y agoNo sorry necessary! I did not take it personally.
- whatshisface 7y agoIt's actually not easy, scientific thinking is easy to fake and hard to get right.
- wastedhours 7y agoI spent three years "managing upwards" on that point. Was like a breath of fresh air when I got a manager who listened in that way - he needed some education, but soon came around and pushed our media agency to stop BS-ing us. Oddly, up to that point I was senior enough to daily manage the budget, but not senior enough that my opinion on what to do was taken seriously. We're talking > 50% wastage, so I just didn't do my job in the end and stopped providing the creative for the wastage part, saved money, made no difference to the end result. Never underestimate how so much of bad advertising is because of clueless people in the chain of command.
- jlbnjmn 7y ago> Never underestimate how so much of bad advertising is because of clueless people in the chain of command. Hello fellow person with in-house advertising experience.
- bryanmgreen 7y ago> Oddly, up to that point I was senior enough to daily manage the budget, but not senior enough that my opinion on what to do was taken seriously. Good freaking lord you hit the nail on the head here about most of marketing career! Then you get in trouble because your boss's boss wants better ROI and blames YOU for an overextended budget because you manage the money, but you just have to sit there and take the blame because your immediate boss won't budge on the strategy. Thankfully I've moved up, but I feel that pain so bad.