3 ms·
Classics! And the Wikipedia pages do a great job of explaining them. I have a real life example. A friend in college was helping a girl prepare for her english
by gruseom 18y ago
Classics! And the Wikipedia pages do a great job of explaining them.
I have a real life example. A friend in college was helping a girl prepare for her english-as-a-foreign-language exam. They were looking over English verb tenses and he wanted to correct a mistake she had made. Without thinking about it he said, "If you had had 'had' here, you would have had to have had 'have' there." She freaked out.
Edit: can't figure out if that last "had" belongs in there or not. :)
- Xichekolas 18y agoIt does. Although to make slightly more clear: "If you had had 'had' here" => "If you would have put 'had' here" "you would have had" => "you would have needed" "to have had 'have' there" => "to have put 'have' there" That is the kind of really amusing sentence we say every day without thinking about it. I've caught myself saying similar things while speaking to non-native speakers, and it's always a crapshoot. We really are lazy and use the verb 'to have' a lot. Nice example.
- silentbicycle 18y agoIt's probably used considerably more in spoken English, where intonation can help with the ambiguity. I have a hard time believing somebody would use "had" so many times together in writing without trying to rephrase themselves. 'Have' is also an interesting case, because aside from meaning the act of possessing, it is also a kind of case/tense modifier for other verbs. ("I ate" vs. "I would have eaten" + "the whole tub of gelato.") In the writing above, you put the third had in single quotes, which implies you're discussing the word usage itself rather than trying to use it again. Similarly, your intonation would probably be elongated. Granted, a non-fluent speaker may not yet pick up on these cues, but they are there.