6 ms·
I turn ABP off for domains that have made it a point to never have abusive ads (popovers, moving, flashing, expanding, generally being a nuisance). I'd highly r
by potatolicious 16y ago
I turn ABP off for domains that have made it a point to never have abusive ads (popovers, moving, flashing, expanding, generally being a nuisance). I'd highly recommend this to others. The advertising economy is crucial to maintaining free (as in beer) access to information on the internet, and complete rejection of it is just going to mean more paywalls in the future.
I don't mind banner ads or text ads so long as they are neither deceptive (mixing ad content with real content or masquerading as such) nor abusive (flashing! look at me! you're the 1 millionth visitor! tiny dismiss buttons, or worse, no dismiss buttons!)
- barrkel 16y agoI don't think it's my responsibility to ensure third-party companies' business models work. I have a TCP pipe open to a remote web server; however I manipulate the data after it has come out of that TCP pipe is up to me, providing I don't violate copyright etc. Trying to prop up businesses in spite of economic forces - free-riding in this case - is usually pointless. Economic forces are too powerful; it's a waste of effort. It's better to work on more sustainable models that aren't as weak.
- AdamTReineke 16y agoWhat about terms of use for sites where they specifically disallow the use of ad blocking software?
- rhizome 16y agoSuch as?
- _delirium 16y agoI'd take terms of use more seriously if they were presented as something resembling a real contract with a choice to accept/decline, e.g. they showed me an up-front page with the terms, and made me check that I agreed to them before letting me view the site. Obviously sites don't do this, because they would lose a bunch of readers who would just close the window. I don't consider fine print buried in a footer that I "implicitly" agree to to be an actual contract.
- potatolicious 16y agoEven in a completely self-serving frame of mind you may want to "prop up" a business model. The idea is that either you look at some ads, or you pay directly for content. Moral or issues of principles aside, that's simply the way it will go. Personally, I choose to look at ads instead of paying for content, but that's a personal preference. If you don't like paywalls it would benefit you in the long term to turn off adblockers for sites that "behave".
- lsc 16y agoReally? There's a "third way" to pay for content... reputation. This, in fact, is how the original article was paid for, I think. The author felt the value added to his reputation was greater than the value of the time spent writing. This is also how most technical books are paid for. Most technical book authors make a small fraction of what they could make as contractors from writing technical books; yet the books still get written... why? Reputation. Nothing improves your reputation quite like being a widely read.
- MikeCapone 16y agoI don't think this scales to any large fraction of the content that is being created right now, though. It does work for some, but I doubt this will become the way things are done on a large scale.
- lsc 16y agoReputation is the primary means whereby creators of nearly all the content I consume on a daily basis are remunerated. Blog posts? Tech books? I doubt very much that there are many people who do either for the money directly earned through ad or book sales. Now, I agree that this model doesn't work for, say, big-budget action movies and for many (maybe, as you say, most[1]) other media types. But, these people working for "free" have always been a big part of the press; I don't think that writing has ever paid particularly well, except for a few at the very top. Edit: There is a corporate equivalent to this that dominates the trade magazine industry. Corporations write something very much like a press release advertising their new product, and send it off to a writer for the magazine, who publishes it, perhaps with a few changes, as if it were a story. Hell, speaking of high-budget action flicks, BMW did something similar a while back; they released a series of short action films[2] that featured their vehicles. Being something of a fan of action films myself, I rather enjoyed them, even though they were obviously commercials. [1] Thinking more on what "more media" is, I'm starting to come around to your position. Now, I certainly spend /more time/ consuming media like blog posts or technical books where the author was primarily remunerated in terms of an increased reputation compared to media produced for the money. However, even if you say I spend 100 hours reading tech books or blog posts for every 1 hour I spend watching big-budget action flicks, that one hour of action movie probably took more human hours to produce than the 100 hours of tech book or blog post. Of course, if you measure the the cost of production divided by the number of people watching it, then it's possible that the flashy action movie was actually cheaper to produce than the tech book, I mean, per human hour spent watching the thing. [2]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hire http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hire
- bad_user 16y agoRewarding companies that behave or provide a valuable service is "voting with your wallet", which is the backbone of capitalism. By using an ad-blocker, offensive websites become less annoying. Let me put it into context: for every website featuring offensive ads you can find well-behaved websites with similarly or even better content (expertsexchange versus stackoverflow). By using an ad-blocker, you're rewarding the websites with offensive ads or business models - your traffic is still valuable as (for example) you may pass links around, or they may just serve you with commercials hidden in the actual content. Personally, if a website bothers me that much with ads, then I stop using/reading it. Made me find better content too. That's why I won't be using an ad-blocker any time soon.
- barrkel 16y agoI don't consider exposing myself to ads to be a payment. It's more like getting some sand in one's eye, or being stuck in a queue. It's an irritant, a distraction, an annoyance. I loathe animated Flash ads, and that disgust infects my perceptions of brands associated with them. I have never bought anything via a display ad link, ever. To be frank, I almost believe I'm doing the advertisers (in contrast to the content providers) a favour by not letting their ads into my consciousness.
- bad_user 16y agoYou're taking that statement too literally. By giving traffic to an ads-based websites, you're generating revenue for them even if you block their ads. Even if you're not paying them directly, that's "voting with your wallet" in my book.
- pzxc 16y agoThat's the exact reason I don't use an ad blocker at all. I use the internet with such frequency that I know what is an ad and what is not, and as a result I am pretty much ad-blind with or without an ad blocker. It's been years since I've clicked on an adsense ad for example, but I don't use any adblockers because they provide essentially zero benefit to me but I know they take away a lot of benefit from other people (the people that make money off the ads and use that revenue model to provide free content).