3 ms·
To be a bit more concrete, this is a bit like saying "Computers could be used to simulate/represent physical theories, hence studying computers could lead to a
by jiggawatts 7y ago
To be a bit more concrete, this is a bit like saying "Computers could be used to simulate/represent physical theories, hence studying computers could lead to a theory of everything."
That's not even wrong! Studying computation, computation systems, or even just mathematics in general almost certainly could assist with progress towards a TOE.
That doesn't mean that pointing at a computer running a few dozen lines of code[1] and saying "A TOE could be in there... somewhere" is materially useful.
[1] I'm paraphrasing Stephen himself here!
Personally, I feel that if Stephen really wanted forward progress towards a TOE, he's uniquely positioned to do so. He controls a company that makes one of the best Computer Algebra Systems. He's in a position of power over a large, highly talented staff of mathematicians, and he could push Mathematica's features towards multiple relatively unexplored areas of computational mathematics where there isn't much available at the moment.
Unfortunately, he's made the decision that the only two such areas worthy of his time and his company's resources are cellular automata and graph rewriting.
Sigh.
Meanwhile, he could have done added all sorts of features for things like handling Einstein summation convention, tensors, Geometric Algebra (and noncommutative algebras in general), topology, etc...
Those would at least have immediate utility to working physicists, and if pushed to the extreme could maybe help uncover some fundamental theory somewhere.
But nope. He likes to play with graphs, like a kid with with a Spirograph only interested in making pretty patterns.
- mycall 7y ago> Einstein summation convention, tensors, Geometric Algebra (and noncommutative algebras in general), topology, etc... Are python libraries taking up this challenge?