5 ms·
It's hard to see any other course of action when we saw what was happening in Northern Italy. In fact if anything I would say most Western countries didn't lock
by tonyedgecombe 7y ago
It's hard to see any other course of action when we saw what was happening in Northern Italy. In fact if anything I would say most Western countries didn't lock down early or hard enough.
Countries that ease the lockdown before they have a handle on the virus are in for a lot of pain further down the road. Probably more economic damage as well.
- LastZactionHero 7y agoAs an example, 9 million people die each year due to hunger or hunger-related issues, many of them children. 135 million face food insecurity. Due to lockdowns and recession, the World Food Program estimates the toll will double this year. And hunger is just one cause of death that a recession can lead to (suicides, substance abuse, etc). Lockdowns might save lives, and I can't blame public health officials for protecting their community, but I personally fear more lives will be lost due to economic costs. They just might be poorer, quieter lives. And while death is, of course, final, suffering in life should count for something too. https://www.wfp.org/news/covid-19-will-double-number-people-facing-food-crises-unless-swift-action-taken https://www.wfp.org/news/covid-19-will-double-number-people-...
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Lockdowns might save lives, and I can't blame public health officials for protecting their community, but I personally fear more lives will be lost due to economic costs. They just might be poorer, quieter lives. That's a real issue in the developing world; in the developed world the resources exist to buffer the temporary additional low-end economic impact; not doing so effectively is a policy choice (and, in practice, a deliberate active one made when the alternative of providing the aid is presented), not an inherent corollary of lockdowns.
- LastZactionHero 7y ago> That's a real issue in the developing world; in the developed world the resources exist to buffer the temporary additional low-end economic impact That seems like a pretty sterile way to describe it. Right now, in the (presumably) developed US, 1 in 5 children don't have enough food, 3x the amount during 2008. That's a result of years of policy choices, but one particularly policy choice caused it to spike. If there's a resource buffer, it's not buffering. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2020/05/06/the-covid-19-crisis-has-already-left-too-many-children-hungry-in-america/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2020/05/06/the-covid...
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Right now, in the (presumably) developed US, 1 in 5 children don't have enough food, 3x the amount during 2008. That's a result of years of policy choices, but one particularly policy choice caused it to spike. Yes, the policy choice not provide the kind of mass aid (whether directly to citizens or through firms in a way which reasons the mass of the citizenry to protect empmoyment and pay) to the population that pretty much every other industrialized country facing this crisis has, even the ones (like Sweden) without mandatory lockdowns. The US federal response to COVID-19, both in narrow public health measures and broader, including economic policy, measures (and structurally much of this has to be done at the federal level because of the way state and federal financing works) has been nothing short of mass murder by depraved indifference.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoLife expectancy correlates strongly with per capita GDP in the developed world. The losses in GDP caused by lockdowns will therefore very likely have a cost in lives in the developed world too.
- mytherin 7y ago> Lockdowns might save lives, and I can't blame public health officials for protecting their community, but I personally fear more lives will be lost due to economic costs. They just might be poorer, quieter lives. And while death is, of course, final, suffering in life should count for something too. The choice between "saving people" vs "economy" is a false choice. Lockdowns might help the economy more in the long run. People that live in fear of the virus will not consume, and lockdowns reduce the amount of time that the virus is out there. You can force people to go back to work, but you can't force people to consume.
- RealityVoid 7y ago> Lockdowns might help the economy more in the long run. It might. We're not really sure. Either way, I think OP has a good point. It is not entirely impossible that we do the lockdown, still same number of people die and we also grind economic activity to a halt leading to other kinds of shortages. If this is what will happen, then the lockdown is a would be a bad choice. Sweden actually is banking on this. They might be wrong, but it's not an entirely crazy stance, there is a reasoning behind it.
- ramblerman 7y agoThose are not opposing viewpoints though. Given what we saw in North Italy it would have been foolish not to go to lockdown imo. But with hindsight we might still assess it was the wrong measure.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoBut with hindsight we might still assess it was the wrong measure. I suspect we will be debating that for years or even decades.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoThe other course of action was what South Korea did: mass testing and contact tracing. South Korea didn't lock down the entire society. As for getting a handle on the virus, it's entirely possible that only herd immunity will do that, and the countries delaying that happening with lockdowns are just delaying the inevitable while incurring unnecessary economic damage in the process.