4 ms·
> All of us who do creative work, we get into it because we have good taste Like saying “How bout them Cowboys” at a club in Dallas. Everybody wants to think
by paulcole 7y ago
> All of us who do creative work, we get into it because we have good taste
Like saying “How bout them Cowboys” at a club in Dallas.
Everybody wants to think they have good taste and everybody wants to be told they have good taste.
Of all the people who read that quote and nod along thinking, “yes this is me” how many are actually right?
- v64 7y ago> Of all the people who read that quote and nod along thinking, “yes this is me” how many are actually right? Those who actually fight their way through their creative difficulties as the quote suggests, as opposed to those who read the quote and think "yup, no one recognizes my good taste, screw em".
- khazhoux 7y agoSome people have innate creativity that just needs to be tuned through hard work. Many (most) don't have it in them to begin with. We should all be OK with the idea that we're not all geniuses (creative genius, business, mathematical, whatever) waiting to be unlocked. This says it best: https://mashable.com/video/jj-watt-robbie-rudy-snl-sketch/ https://mashable.com/video/jj-watt-robbie-rudy-snl-sketch/
- paulcole 7y agoExcept as the quote actually says, it is advice to beginners.
- v64 7y agoEvery expert started out as a beginner.
- paulcole 7y agoYes but the quote is to be told to beginners, none of whom have yet to “actually fight their way through their creative difficulties.”
- v64 7y agoI don't think we're in disagreement. You asked: Of all the people who read that quote and nod along thinking, “yes this is me” how many are actually right? Of those people who think "yes this is me" as beginners, those who stick with it and move beyond the stage of beginner by fighting their way through their creative difficulties will be the ones who actually did have good creative taste and were right. Those who reach creative roadblocks and blame the cause on external circumstances are not among those with good creative taste.
- khazhoux 7y agoI don't think you should be downvoted, because you speak truth. The comment/quote is factually wrong: not everyone who gets into creative work has "good taste", nor is Ira Glass correct that you just need to plow through it. Go peruse an end-of-senior-year art exhibit or dance recital at your local college. Bless 'em, they worked hard and gave it their best, but usually the raw creativity and talent isn't there.
- mulmen 7y agoI don't think your example disproves Glass' statement. Surely students are in the beginner phases and their work does not represent their full potential. Glass' statement seems to say forgive students (and yourself for being one) instead of writing them off as hopeless.
- paulcole 7y agoLook at the first sentence of Glass’s statement. It is meant to be told to beginners to encourage them. He’s telling beginners that because you’re trying you must have good taste (which is clearly not true) so stick with it.
- v64 7y ago> He’s telling beginners that because you’re trying you must have good taste That's not how I read the quote. I read it as him saying, you can't know whether or not you have good taste without first producing a lot of bad work, and that producing bad work is not necessarily a sign that you have bad taste. If anything, those who judge themselves harshly are demonstrating good taste because they can see the flaws in their work compared to the works of others. It's those that don't feel any sense of criticism toward their own work that lack good taste, but they wouldn't feel this quote applies to them in the first place, because they wouldn't feel that their work is disappointing. They would instead be blaming others for not recognizing their superior work.
- jerry1979 7y agoIra is obviously trying to point out that the self-hatred comes from the fact that you know enough about your work to hate it. He turns pessimism into meta-cognition.
- bnjms 7y agoMost likely: all of them. Most people have above average taste in some subject they are, for whatever reason, overly interested in. And you can't really judge this based on how good they are now or will be because that doesn't say anything about their taste just their current ability. It's kinda like your example. No one in Dallas really thinks the Cowboys are any good. Not anymore. It's just something mildly amusing you can say. In fact the comment is rooted in being obviously tasteless. It's just the local team that was really good way back when. Those with taste may recognize that Romo was actually good or that he's made a good commentator but no one actually thinks the Cowboys are or were good since their heyday. (Though honestly I don't know or care about the team. I'm basing this on listening to sports people.)