3 ms·
Also, NTFS has very different (multi-file) ACID guarantees and transaction semantics compared to most POSIX file systems. A lot of performance differences betwe
by WorldMaker 7y ago
Also, NTFS has very different (multi-file) ACID guarantees and transaction semantics compared to most POSIX file systems. A lot of performance differences between Windows and POSIX file APIs make some sense in a NoSQL versus SQL database analogy: they make very different guarantees about what the "atomic commit" level is, what is stored and how it is stored, what is locked and how and when it is locked. They both have great uses and there are trade-offs to both approaches, you can't always rely on the performance of an application built for one running performatively on top of the other.
- mycall 7y agoI thought ReFS was suppose to give Windows different atomics and I'm surprised they haven't push it further into their client OS.
- WorldMaker 7y agoThe impression Microsoft gives to me is that ReFS is meaningfully only beneficial over NTFS in RAID configurations with multiple physical drives (otherwise NTFS and ReFS have very similar semantics on a single physical drive), so pushing it any further than "Windows Storage Spaces" sounds unlikely, and few consumer machines have more than one physical drive in any configuration much less a software RAID configuration. In relation to the above conversation about WSL1 performance characteristics, my impression is that ReFS would be equal or worse to NTFS for what Linux/POSIX file operations expect. (ReFS is still very much on the "SQL Database" side of the analogy, like NTFS as it was of course designed to support much the same transactional semantics, and some additional ones as well at the "virtual storage space" level above the physical pool of drives.) In danger of getting further aside into tangential spaces, Ubuntu's current experimentation with ZFS by default is probably one to watch to see if the user experience of complicated multi-physical disk file systems like ReFS can be made to fit and is useful to a broader user base than just power users. (Though arguably compared to the broader spectrum of casual Windows users, even some of the more casual Ubuntu users might be considered power users in comparison.)