3 ms·
Do we have any idea about what kind of ISP these rotating detonation engines can achieve? And secondly, want to bet that the KSP2 devs are rushing to add this
by ashtonkem 7y ago
Do we have any idea about what kind of ISP these rotating detonation engines can achieve?
And secondly, want to bet that the KSP2 devs are rushing to add this engine ASAP?
- bbarn 7y agoEvery time a new space/rocket/propulsion story shows up, it makes me try to get to the mun and back again for the next few hours.
- montenegrohugo 7y agoIf I understood this table [1] correctly, theoretically these kind of engines could increase thermal efficiency by a lot , almost doubling them. Which of course would be incredible and result in a much higher payload/rocket percentage [2]. In terms of Isp, the same paper [1] quotes 1000-1200!!! Isp for small rotating detonation engines. Which is insane (state of the art rocket engines are around ~400) [1] https://www.intechopen.com/online-first/a-theoretical-review-of-rotating-detonation-engines#tab1 https://www.intechopen.com/online-first/a-theoretical-review... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation
- baybal2 7y agoI think you are not reading it right. I think they are putting it for an air breathing version.
- montenegrohugo 7y agoYeah, that seems more plausible. Pity, it was the only source I found of ISP values of Rotating detonation engines. Now I still have no idea what kind of ISP increase we could see if RDE's were to be practical.
- valuearb 7y agoThe theoretical max for chemical rockets using standard fuels is around 530 using hydrogen. 1,000 requires it to be using the atmosphere, ie a jet.
- mppm 7y agoIt will not be much higher than current rocket engines. The theoretical upper limit, for the exhaust velocity of a hydrogen-oxygen engine is about 5270m/s. The best actually constructed rocket engines have c=4600m/s in vacuum. So the thermal efficiency of rocket engines can already be upwards of 75%. So there's not that much room to improve. Since the authors seem to be careful not to mention the actual exhaust velocity, I'm guessing that it is actually lower than that of rocket engine. It can potentially be higher, but there is probably still a ways to go. Another factor is thrust to weight ratio. For modern rocket engines it is close to 100. For this detonation prototype it's probably very low. So no, don't expect detonation engines on rockets any time soon.