4 ms·
It’s not just assuming they match our own. The kinds of distributions we see in our civilisation (country land are distribution, population distribution, etc) a
by simonh 7y ago
It’s not just assuming they match our own. The kinds of distributions we see in our civilisation (country land are distribution, population distribution, etc) are also seen in many, many other phenomena. Species ranges, species population sizes, planet and asteroid size distributions, island size distributions, mountain size distributions and many many other phenomena. All it’s assuming is that the number of a thing inversely correlates to the size of the thing. Small things tend to be numerous and big things tend to be scarce. We see this in all sorts of phenomena. Not all phenomena, but many, many.
On that basis, the argument would be that since that inverse correlation seems to be extremely common, it”s also likely to be found in the distributions of Intelligent species. Not guaranteed, but very likely. I think it’s an interesting argument.