4 ms·
I'm sorry, but you seem to be responding to a strawman. No one is claiming you can't make apps that target an iPad: they are saying there is no rudimentary way
by saurik 16y ago
I'm sorry, but you seem to be responding to a strawman. No one is claiming you can't make apps that target an iPad: they are saying there is no rudimentary way to make apps USING an iPad.
The original comment was that people don't need Macs anymore: that kids can just have an iPad. This article claims that that overlooks the importance of programming.
Meanwhile, the points in the article are both about a lack of a development environment /and/ that the input mechanisms available aren't even appropriate for the task.
You can disagree with those points if you want, but you can't just claim "dude: JavaScript", and believe you won some battle. Yeah: there's JavaScript... now what? Can I edit HTML files on the device and load them? No.
An argument you /could/ try to make is that anyone can get an account on EC2 and then use iSSH from the App Store and the bluetooth keyboard to do development, attempting (painfully) to task switch between a browser that barely has a memory cache (and has no disk cache) and an SSH client that is killed if you leave it in the background for longer than a minute. Of course, that's all assuming you manage to get your EC2 server bootstrapped using the web console, which I think might actually be a flash app... I guess there are other hosting companies, right?
- shawndumas 16y ago"JavaScript Anywhere"[1] is a simple & portable development environment for Web Programmer. ---- [1]: http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/javascript-anywhere/id363452277?mt=8 http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/javascript-anywhere/id3634522...
- Tycho 16y agoThere's an app called Textastic that let's you code in many languages, but if you are doing HTML then you can actually run/preview the page, and it will also link to resources in the same folder, like JavaScript or CSS files. There's also Code2Go which sends your code to a server and returns the output. It has shells/compilers for many languages.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoOkay, my mistake, I apologize. One of the problems with living in a fast-moving world is that sometimes I lose track of what is obvious and what is not. I just saw a demo of Eclipse Orion: http://jaxenter.com/eclipse-orion-the-new-ide-paradigm-33431.html http://jaxenter.com/eclipse-orion-the-new-ide-paradigm-33431... ... so at the moment it is blindingly obvious to me -- apparently so obvious that I forget to mention it to other people -- that you could easily build an HTML5 app that allows students to edit and run Javascript from Safari on the iPad. Having grasped that, I have already started assuming that such apps exist and acting accordingly. But I'm ahead of myself, so I'll concede: It might be impossible to usefully write executable Javascript on an iPad today. We might have to wait a few more weeks. If iPad-friendly HTML5-powered Javascript editors don't already exist, I don't know why not. Perhaps there is too little demand. Perhaps we were all waiting for something like Orion to provide the proof of concept. Perhaps nobody has gotten around to it yet. Perhaps the founders of the appropriate startups are still building it and haven't launched yet. Or perhaps nobody wants to edit code on an iPad when PCs are a dime a dozen. I can hardly blame them for that. I like real keyboards for hacking, just as I like oscilloscopes for designing audio electronics. But it's not Apple's fault, exactly, that the iPad isn't particularly well designed for typing code. They make other machines for typing code. The iPad is designed for iPad things, just as my car is designed for daily driving and not for stock-car racing.