4 ms·
Sure, but killing a kitten is illegal, and accepting cookies isn't. They aren't asking for someone to commit a crime. I assume it would be legal to charge mone
by cortesoft 7y ago
Sure, but killing a kitten is illegal, and accepting cookies isn't. They aren't asking for someone to commit a crime.
I assume it would be legal to charge money for reading the content... could they require that you create an account?
- dbrgn 7y agoThe whole point of the article (and of GDPR) is that accepting non-essential tracking cookies without user consent is illegal.
- cortesoft 7y agoYeah, some other comments made that point more clearly. I think I understand better (it seems to be similar to anti-prostitution laws, where it is illegal to trade something you can give for free) It does seem to lead to some strange loopholes though, like requiring an account for access.
- ratww 7y ago> It does seem to lead to some strange loopholes though, like requiring an account for access. That's false. Requiring an account or even payment for access does not replace or imply consent of any kind, and all rules still apply even if the user is still logged in or paying. In fact, it's probably more complicated for logged-in users since you have to comply to requirements of data-scrubbing, removing/anonymising logins/emails/passwords from your database upon request, etc.
- umvi 7y agoDetermining whether a user has "consented" is impossible, as evidenced by this thread, so the law is folly.
- ahartmetz 7y agoIn a highly technical sense, it is maybe not. In a legal sense, which applies human common sense when necessary, it absolutely is.
- ferzul 7y agoit is easy to determine if a user has consented. but if you go out of your way to mix in “i consented” and “i want this box to stop annoying me as quickly as possible” into one bucket, the fact that you have trouble separating them is a problem you created