9 ms·
I think Steve Jobs puts it best; The problem with Microsoft is that they “simply have no taste.” Windows has always had their Windowish / Microsoftish smell t
by ksec 7y ago
I think Steve Jobs puts it best;
The problem with Microsoft is that they “simply have no taste.”
Windows has always had their Windowish / Microsoftish smell to its design. Much like Linux, You could spot a linux desktop from 100 miles away. And everyone thought these were simple you could just copy it. Turns out there are trillions of small details that make it all coherent and beautiful.
- flowerlad 7y ago> The problem with Microsoft is that they “simply have no taste.” You can say that about Apple today too. After all, in iOS7 they copied the Flat UI from Microsoft, including thin fonts, and buttons that don't look like buttons and so on. Although more recently they have removed thin fonts in their designs.
- ksec 7y agoI felt that is what happen when you put a Industrial Designer in charge of Software Design. I know it feels a little harsh, but Jony without Steve is a Designer without Product Manager. Steve Jobs is great being an Editor and Product Executive.
- philistine 7y agoThe decisions made since Ive has left Have me hopeful for a better future at Apple. They’re never going to be perfect, but things are going in the right direction. Their laptops are getting ticker for crying out loud!
- ksec 7y agoYes, and lot of Software and UI element are coming back. I am glad despite the massive changes, those quality were not loss. I cant help but think Jony knew he was getting burn out without Steve. And he wanted to get those last design to be perfect before he left.
- rayiner 7y agoI just got a new 16” MBP after hanging onto a 2013 MBP forever (with a brief detour to Windows and running screaming back). It’s practically perfect in every way.
- hundt 7y agoYup, had this exact experience, except my prior mac was a 2015.
- agumonkey 7y agoIt was also the first time Apple was reacting since the imac days. They were leading of computing UI innovation almost everywhere since.. and then they started to have a me-too moment, trying to make flat-ui right the Apple way. Very odd.
- wayneftw 7y agoI think I put it best: "Apple likes to make people think they have taste and that they're good at design, but they're actually really, really bad at design and their tastes are quite obviously very shallow." Windows and all the Linux desktop environments that copied Windows have so much more functionality than the brain-dead macOS that can't even get basic features like window management right. Imagine thinking an OS that won't let you easily maximize or snap application windows is any good?
- tapoxi 7y ago> Imagine thinking an OS that won't let you easily maximize or snap application windows is any good? What's so difficult about clicking the green button (maximizing) or holding it (snapping)?
- toast0 7y agoWhatever the green button does is not maximizing.
- na85 7y agoIt maximizes on my mac? Do you have some kind of extension installed?
- eyelidlessness 7y agoOption-clicking the green button (usually) maximizes. Full screen in a separate desktop space may resemble maximizing in some ways, but it significantly changes the interaction model when switching between windows, especially when some of the windows are not maximized. Example: 1. Open two apps, at least one of which supporting fullscreen. 2. Open three windows in the app that supports fullscreen. 3. Fullscreen one window. 4. Cmd-tab to the other app. 5. Cmd-tab back to the previous app. If your window from step 3 was maximized (filling the screen in the same desktop space), you would return to that window, but instead you are now looking at some completely random other window that you were not interacting with at all. For people who cmd-tab (and cmd-`) frequently to switch between apps, this is super jarring and not at all what we intended to do.