4 ms·
What if the law said that the company has to serve EU users the same way it serves non-EU users, and to do otherwise would be considered an act of trade war by
by derefr 7y ago
What if the law said that the company has to serve EU users the same way it serves non-EU users, and to do otherwise would be considered an act of trade war by a private US corporation against the EU (the same as if e.g. a US private defense contractor, hired by some other power, hacked into EU corporations and caused property damage against them)—basically making the whole thing into a “diplomatic incident” each time it happened?
Heck, what if they said that everyone doing things their way is their condition on staying in WIPO, and if a country can’t bring its corporations into line, then the EU will declare all WIPO IP-right assertions originating from that country null and void within the EU, free for any EU corporation to exploit?
- Maskawanian 7y agoI don't think anyone should be forced to service foreign nations. As a citizen of a non EU country, I'd take issue with being compelled to work with them. EU would effectively be declaring war on a significant percentage of the world. They have no jurisdiction beyond their borders. Taking your ball and going home, while not the best for business, should be an option.
- derefr 7y agoI mean, you're not forced to service foreign nations. But if you are trading with foreign nations, then you've got to realize that that is fundamentally a voluntary relationship—trade doesn't exist by default, it is created by a spirit of mutual cooperation, on a foundation of compromise. If that spirit of cooperation and foundation of compromise don't exist, then the trade cannot exist. Or, to put that another way: WIPO itself is something the US "forced" on the rest of the world. But it wasn't actually force; it was just a condition on other nations continuing to trade with the US.
- levosmetalo 7y agoYou mean like EU companies are not forced to stop trading with Iran, it was their free decision.
- shkkmo 7y agoYes, I believe Iran sanctions function similarly to WIPO, the US requires people to follow certain rules if they want to do business with the US.
- Maskawanian 7y agoAs I said, taking your ball and going home should be an option. That implies NOT trading with EU. As per wiktionary.org: "To cease participating in an activity that has turned to one's disadvantage, especially out of spite, or in a way that prevents others from participating as well." You are assuming a point I did not make.
- wlll 7y agoJust block EU IP addresses if you want. No-one is forcing you to allow access to any particular country or region.
- martin8412 7y agoDoesn't make a difference. If I access your site as a EU citizen through a VPN, then you must follow GDPR.
- wlll 7y agoHonestly I'm not sure about what the outcome is there, has it ever been tested?
- cortesoft 7y agoAn act of trade war? What does that even mean? Lots of companies won't ship things to certain countries, that doesn't make it a trade war.