2 ms·
First mover advantage. It's like asking why no one has created another Reddit, or another HN. When the original exists, a derivative doesn't gain traction unles
by sillysaurusx 7y ago
First mover advantage. It's like asking why no one has created another Reddit, or another HN. When the original exists, a derivative doesn't gain traction unless something goes seriously wrong.
The sole time that Reddit was in danger was when their front page was blacked out over the moderator rebellion. Luckily for them, Voat's servers completely died under the load. Then Reddit came back online, and the rest was history.
I would imagine your questions have straightforward answers along those lines. No one switches because inertia, not quality.
In general, a new thing has to be fundamentally different in some way. It's rare that an internet product is out-competed by someone else doing literally the same thing. Even Reddit was fundamentally different from digg. They were both link aggregators, but that's about where the similarities stopped.
- eitland 7y ago> First mover advantage. It's like asking why no one has created another Reddit, or another HN. When the original exists, a derivative doesn't gain traction unless something goes seriously wrong. Good point, yet here we are: - slashdot feels like a shadow of its former self - reddit replaced digg - lobste.rs is a healthy alternative in addition to hn - stackoverflow replaced expertsexchange I still think someday someone will create a better q/a site and if I was an a position to do a startup to change the world for the better that would probably be high on my list of ideas. I admit I could be wrong, but I am surprised that nobody has tried as far as I can see: after all the early bird gets the worm but the second mouse gets the cheese, and there's a lot to be learned from what works and doesn't work today.
- the_af 7y agoAgreed about the first mover advantage. Do note StackOverflow is only relatively a first mover: expertsexchange came first, and StackOverflow killed it. Evidently, they did something better. Wikipedia also had challengers. I don't remember their names (heh) but many years ago there were forks. I don't mean Wikia, but actual alternatives to Wikipedia. Nobody uses them. > In general, a new thing has to be fundamentally different in some way. It's rare that an internet product is out-competed by someone else doing literally the same thing. Possibly right, too! But if an inclusionist attitude is not something "fundamentally different" enough to succeed, then might it be that it wasn't important enough to say that deletionism is killing Wikipedia/StackOverflow? If people don't flock to inclusivist forks, maybe inclusivism isn't important enough?