3 ms·
> I don't like that they're being driven to an ad-supported website, but the simple act of not having Wikipedia eat all of the web seems like a good thing. No,
by vkou 7y ago
> I don't like that they're being driven to an ad-supported website, but the simple act of not having Wikipedia eat all of the web seems like a good thing.
No, having all of this content under Wikipedia would be an amazing thing. For all its warts, Wikipedia (When it has the information you are looking for) is the gold standard in what the the web should be. It's amazing that it exists as a website, and compared to the mountains of crud that surrounds it, it has an amazing UX.
The inclusionist argument is that the web would be better if more of its content was available under the same high standards that Wikipedia set.
Competitors can't deliver that same standard because of economies of scale.
- notriddle 7y ago> Competitors can't deliver that same standard because of economies of scale. The invasion of policy-driven jerks seems like a good counterargument; it's an anti-economy of scale, since smaller websites have less of the problem. edit: Arguing about scale also kind of ignores that there's a good space between the scope of the website being "everything" and having a website dedicated to the IDW "Sniffles the Mouse" comics. IMDB is well-respected, TVTropes has been successful with a very different culture from IMDB, the Arch Linux Wiki has a reputation for being useful even if you aren't technically using Arch, and, as we've already proven, Wikia has pretty much made a business out of this.
- vkou 7y agoSmaller websites have this problem, it's just that the holy wars waged within the Pokemon fandom rarely make it to the HN front page. If anything, the politics get even more personal and vicious in smaller communities. The business of Wikia may be successful, but as a user, it's complete rubbish.