10 ms·
Firefox for Mobile now supports NoScript, PrivacyBadger, HTTPS Everywhere
- kibwen 7y agoI was one of the people criticizing Mozilla for forcing Mobile Firefox users to upgrade to the newly-rewritten codebase while it still lacked support for any extension other than uBlock Origin, so I was pleased to see that they're making progress on supporting other highly-requested extensions.
- freakcage 7y agoFor someone who want firefox to success, I still am not happy with the performance of firefox preview. Currently there is kiwi browser on Android not sure if they have for ios as well, which is chromium based and support extensions. Recently the developer also make it open source. Shout out to the devs. https://github.com/kiwibrowser/android https://github.com/kiwibrowser/android
- DubiousPusher 7y agoBut did you use the older Firefox for Android cause after that you will believe this KIA is a Lamborghini.
- freakcage 7y agoyes I use and I totally agree that the preview version is much faster compare to the old firefox.
- morsch 7y agoI honestly didn't notice any difference in performance when Firefox Android Beta was switched to the new codebase a couple of weeks ago. Not saying it's not there, just that I couldn't tell. I have trouble getting used to the new UX. I keep hitting the address bar to open a site from my top sites in the current tab. That used to work, now it just opens the search interface. Instead you have to hit the -- much smaller -- tab overview button to open a top site in a new tab. Which means I end up having to manually close old tabs all the time now, something I don't remember doing. (To be fair, Chrome works the same way.) I don't know how I'm supposed to use the new Collections feature. It's extremely prominent in the UI, I assume everybody else must be finding it super useful?! They broke the offline reading list? You used to be able to bookmark a page in Reader Mode and have it available even when there is no connection (subway, airplanes). Instead of promoting this really neat (and given that Reader Mode is still a thing, cheap) feature, I think they just got rid of it. I had like a dozen of long articles in that list I still wanted to read (I think the bookmarks are still there). Hopefully they'll restore it before it transitions from Beta to Release, but who knows.
- ropeladder 7y ago> the offline reading list I've wanted a feature like this for years but I had no idea it already existed! Thank you for this info. And yes, please don't break it, Mozilla.
- morsch 7y agoIt is (used to be) somehow very well hidden and easy to reach, both at the same time.
- mjayhn 7y agoKiwi is the only one I'm aware of with a real dark/night mode for the entire browser. I was sold just on that.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoFirefox is my browser of choice on desktop and the new mobile version is brilliant but I badly need an extension that will reverse light background websites to be dark. This is the only thing blocking me adopting it as mobile browser of choice.
- kbenson 7y agoIs there an extension for desktop that does it? Install it on the mobile version. New (chrome) style extension just work, from what I know (there are a few APIs that don't, but those that use them are likely the extensions that don't make sense on mobile). An extension I made for work just worked without problem. Edit: Sorry, I was referring to Firefox mobile, and this is regarding Firefox preview, which I don't have any actual experience with. I'm not sure how much applies.
- ishanjain28 7y agoDark reader is available on the Firefox Nightly app on Android.
- iamkroot 7y agoHave you tried dark reader? https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/darkreader/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/darkreader/
- boustrophedon 7y agoFrom this blog post: "With Dark Reader, websites on mobile will be easy to read when the lights are dim. The extension automatically inverts bright colors on web pages to offer an eye-pleasing dark mode. There are a number of configuration options allowing you to customize your experience."
- yoavm 7y agoI'm just using "invert colors" from the Android toggles panel. No need for an extension (DarkReader is heavy), nothing to install and works everywhere.
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoHoly cow - I am a regular user of Firefox on Android, and I just installed Firefox Preview - it's obviously a stark improvement. The lack of noscript and darkreader kept me from trying it before, but now I'm wishing I had tried it earlier.
- blinkingled 7y agoSeconded. It's great - old Firefox for Android was clunky and slow. The new one I am using as my primary browser with full sync enabled and with uBlock Origin and NoScript and apart from the occasional crash (they seem to fix it quick) it's great.
- rapnie 7y agoIt is certainly great, but I'm confused.. I use Badger, uBlock and Sync for a long time already on my Android.
- _Microft 7y agoFirefox supported this with the normal Android app already. It is the new Firefox Preview that was limited in that regard.
- blinkingled 7y agoI was using it with old Firefox for Android too, just that it was too slow and clunky compared to the new rewritten Firefox for Android, which being a complete rewrite in Kotlin, only recently started supporting extensions.
- floatingatoll 7y agoIn a lot of role-playing games, people sometimes end up using low-level gear that can’t keep up because there are perks on that gear that they don’t want to lose. Sometimes it’s necessary to set aside perks and see if it’s better with more advanced gear without the perks is worth it, but there’s an emotional attachment to them that alters the evaluation of value. It’s interesting to see a relative to that sentiment show up about browser addons. Thank you for sharing!
- vinay427 7y agoI got my hopes up a little too quickly. Turns out "now" => "soon". The extensions in question, linked in the post, still display the same message of not being available for Android, and the article says the change will be within a few weeks: "These add-ons will be available in Firefox Preview within the next 2 weeks."
- drannex 7y agoDownload the Firefox Preview Nightly builds (in the play store), you'll have access and the nightly builds are usually* relatively stable.
- kibwen 7y agoNote that this blog post was from April 14, I (the submitter) went looking for it after my copy of Firefox notified me of the change a few days ago. I am indeed using the nightly branch, but I find it to be quite stable.
- vinay427 7y agoThanks, I didn't notice the date of the blog post and certainly didn't mean it as a personal affront because I appreciate the post. I'm going to switch to the nightly branch to try it out!
- bzb3 7y agoI'm frustrated by the amount of versions of the Firefox browser that there are in the play store: five. It's not immediately clear which one is the closest to trunk. Beta? Nightly? Preview? Preview Nightly? (The other one is the stable branch)
- EquallyJust 7y agoIt goes Stable -> Beta -> Nightly in terms of closeness to trunk. I believe Preview == Beta and Preview Nightly == Nightly now. The Preview apps are going away since the new interface is releasing soon
- rohan1024 7y agoYou did not mention Firefox Focus!
- jml7c5 7y agoIt'll be simpler once the switch to the rewrite (currently called "Firefox Preview") is done. Then presumably we'll just have: "Firefox" / "Firefox beta" / "Firefox nightly for developers" "Firefox Focus"
- input_sh 7y agoThe private windows in Firefox Preview behaves exactly like Firefox Focus. You can open links by default in a private window in settings. I'm not sure if this means that Focus will be deprecated in favour of Preview, or will it remain a stripped down version of Preview.
- guug 7y agoWill this new firfox support the full web extension API? That is, will it eventually run any web extension currently on addons.mozilla.org?
- kibwen 7y agoThat appears to be the intent, yes. https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2019/10/23/fx-preview-geckoview-add-ons-support/ https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2019/10/23/fx-preview-geckov...
- swrobel 7y agoI so wish we could have this on iOS...
- liquidise 7y agoMy mobile web usage on iPhone is limited to HN strictly because of ads. I simply refuse to adopt patterns that cover my screen with them. When i do switch to Android, which i will, ad block will be the primary factor in my decision.
- whycombagator 7y agoHave you tried installing Firefox focus and either using it as your mobile browser or setting it as the content blocker for Safari? You can also try an ad blocking app like AdGuard. Or set up something like PiHole at home (or VPS) and use a VPN to connect to your home network (or VPS).
- gilrain 7y agoiOS supports content blockers. Why not install AdGuard? I use default Safari on my iPhone and see zero ads.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoIts incredible how microsoft got in loads of legal trouble for bundling IE with windows but Apple got away with banning alternative browsers.
- jedberg 7y agoI got super excited until I realized this was only for Android.
- aidenn0 7y agoAn actual firefox for iOS is disallowed from by the app-store rules.
- jedberg 7y agoI know. That’s why I was excited. I thought they found a workaround.
- enitihas 7y agoEven if they find a technical workaround, Apple will just reject the app though. Not sure there is a workaround for that.
- userbinator 7y agoI believe jailbreak or those other "developer" methods (certificates/enterprise?) are still available.
- enitihas 7y agoYeah, both of them will see mozilla kicked out of App Store
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoI'm given to understand that it's not even a technical issue; you can build an iOS app that uses a real browser engine of your choice, it's always just been that Apple by policy won't let you publish it. (This is all second-hand, though, so take with a grain of salt.)
- enitihas 7y ago
- sloshnmosh 7y agoHmm. Every Firefox browser I've downloaded from Mozilla and sideloaded onto my LineageOS devices has always supported uMatrix, HTTPSEverywhere and NoScript.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agonon-firefox preview browsers are on life support.
- lukaa 7y agoFinally complete Dark mode with addon for mobile. Now I can forget Chromiums.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoThat's worked in the non-preview (old) version of Firefox on Android for ages. (Speaking as a happy user)
- kbumsik 7y agoTried Search by Image extension and it is great! My major complaint is the tab management and the New Tab page. To be honest it is the worst I've ever seen. I hope that Mozilla invest much more on UI/UX.
- edjrage 7y agoYour comment isn't worth much if you don't say what you don't like about it. It's not perfect but to me it's pretty good.
- ta17711771 7y agoDoes it have per-site process isolation yet?
- nootropicat 7y agoI fear they're going to force it as the release version while supporting just 1% of most used extensions, forgetting that it's a fat-tailed distribution. I use video background fix to play youtube with a minimized browser (no I don't want to use a separate app if I don't have to). At that point I'm just going to switch to Brave.
- jraph 7y agoYou don't have to, but using YouTube through the NewPipe app is light years ahead in terms of experience. You can listen to videos and playlists, program which videos will play next, reorder videos that are going to play, no ads. When playing on the background only the audio track is downloaded which is easier on your battery and internet connection. The UI is smooth. The app itself is lightweight. It remembers your history and search history but this happens locally on your device. It also supports PeerTube and SoundCloud. You can watch videos in popup mode though I never do that. The fullscreen player has vlc-like controls to easily change the brightness and volume level. I could go on and on. All that with completely free software. Experience on the mobile website is shit in comparison especially on slow devices. I use Firefox mobile with the same extension + ublock origin but, as someone who hates installing apps when websites should do, do yourself a favor and don't ditch Firefox for Brave, try NewPipe, it's worth it :-) Same thing for the Slide app to go to Reddit by the way.
- trog 7y agoConfused, I have been running NoScript in Firefox on Android for months now. What has changed?
- dblohm7 7y agoThis is referring to the rewritten Firefox for Android, codenamed “Fenix.”
- surround 7y agoFirefox preview.
- dmix 7y agoWhich features a more Rust-heavy rewrites included in GeckoView via their Project Quantum work on desktop. https://www.infoq.com/news/2019/08/geckoview-firefox-preview/ https://www.infoq.com/news/2019/08/geckoview-firefox-preview... https://old.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/ep3tbx/eli5_what_happened_to_the_gecko_rendering_engine/feh2h2c/ https://old.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/ep3tbx/eli5_what_h...
- dblohm7 7y agoThat stuff was also included in Fennec (the current Firefox for Android). GeckoView is completely orthogonal to Project Quantum. (I work on the GeckoView team).
- kelnos 7y agoI'm pretty confused as to what I'm running, then. I always had Firefox Beta installed, and a month or so ago it got updated to what I think is Preview -- different UI, URL bar on the bottom, only uBlock Origin supported. Just checked right now, and the last update was April 21, but in my Addons list, it's still showing Privacy Badger and HTTPS Everywhere in the Unsupported list.
- fireattack 7y agoSo they are hand-picking extensions now? Is this trend going to continue (i.e. they continue to add more but still with a manual process) or they're aiming to be on par with the old Firefox (supports most of extensions automatically)?
- kibwen 7y agoAFAICT the intent is to eventually support the full WebExtensions API, i.e. every extension that runs on Firefox 57 or later. From an older blog post discussing this: "We’re happy to confirm that GeckoView is currently building support for extensions through the WebExtensions API. This feature will be available in Firefox Preview, and we are looking forward to offering a great experience for both mobile users and developers. Bringing GeckoView and Firefox Preview up to par with the APIs that were supported previously in Firefox for Android won’t happen overnight. For the remainder of 2019 and leading into 2020, we are focusing on building support for a selection of content from our Recommended Extensions program that work well on mobile and cover a variety of utilities and features." https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2019/10/23/fx-preview-geckoview-add-ons-support/ https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2019/10/23/fx-preview-geckov...
- realharo 7y agoThe answers here seem to suggest otherwise. https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2020/02/11/faq-for-extension-support-in-new-firefox-for-android/ https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2020/02/11/faq-for-extension... My guess would be that they'll try to make it curated-only unless users complain too much. Or maybe allow other extensions behind serious warning screens. If that ends up being the case, depending on their review process, it kinda sucks for any potential new extensions created after the ecosystem lockdown, that won't get a chance to attain enough popularity to be relevant - unless Mozilla agrees to do a review for any project that asks, which doesn't seem likely.
- fwn 7y agoWould also be bad for all extensions Mozilla does not allow in their extension store. All software stores can be pressured to remove content. Keeping the ability to load non-store extensions fixes that specific deplatfoming problem.
- aasasd 7y agoNeed Stylus to make ‘collapse comment’ buttons on HN adequately sized and quit sniping them.
- def8cefe 7y agoAnyone know where to get the APK without building yourself or using Google services?
- lymph 7y agohttps://firefox-ci-tc.services.mozilla.com/tasks/index/project.mobile.fenix.v2.beta/latest https://firefox-ci-tc.services.mozilla.com/tasks/index/proje...
- wazoox 7y agoUse F-Droid. Firefox (and FF Klar) is available there. https://search.f-droid.org/?q=firefox https://search.f-droid.org/?q=firefox (edit: confusion)
- dTal 7y agoI don't see FF Preview in there. Nor would I expect to, as it is not currently Free Software: https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/fenix/issues/162 https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/fenix/issues/162
- surround 7y agoFor iOS users wanting similar functionality: use Safari’s content blocker API. The app HTTPS4All uses the same rule set as HTTPS everywhere: https://github.com/bouk/HTTPS4All https://github.com/bouk/HTTPS4All For script blocking, AdGuard for iOS supports custom rules. Try: *$script And to whitelist: *$script,domain=~example.com,~example2.com Kind of a hassle. Mozilla could just include something like this in their iOS browser skin of Safari.
- bad_user 7y agoAfaik Safari's content blockers don't work in iOS's Firefox. Has this changed? Also browser extensions aren't allowed on iOS due to Apple's policy. AFAIK you can't build your own browser engine that does JIT, you can't do remote code execution.
- surround 7y agoCorrect, Safari’s content blockers only apply to the Safari app. But Mozilla could use their own content blockers in the Firefox iOS app (which is just a skin of Safari). And yes, Safari’s content blocking is very limited. You couldn’t inject any of no-script’s neutered scriptlets, for example. In this sense, Android has an advantage over iOS because it isn’t so restrictive.
- jzer0cool 7y agoAny plans for any of these features without installing extension? Possibly by enabling menu option.
- SanchoPanda 7y agoWill search shortcuts be fully operational before 1.0?
- newscracker 7y agoTangential comment for those using iOS: It sucks that this cannot be available on iOS because of Apple’s restrictions. But I’m happy with Firefox Focus, which is my daily driver browser on iOS (and what I’m using to write this too). It has a built in content blocker. It doesn’t upgrade HTTP requests to HTTPS, like Brave does. For ad and tracker blocking at the DNS level, I use NextDNS with some blocker lists enabled for my account (I recommend you check it out). It has made things better on other apps too.
- enriquto 7y ago> It sucks that this cannot be available on iOS because of Apple’s restrictions. Apple users have exactly what they want. It doesn't "suck": it's the very definition of walled garden. Your device is not yours, you are just allowed to play in there, under adult supervision. If you do not want walled gardens, just stop paying for them.
- jlokier 7y agoNo, not all Apple users have what they want. There is no "just stop" for people who need or want capabilities that only Apple devices have, but don't want the walled garden. It is not a free choice, not what those people want, and therefore sucks. The brutal fact is there are only two mobile OSes where essential apps are available (such as banking), and Android being the other one, is not suitable for all users and has its own walled garden issues.
- ComodoHacker 7y agoI like Firefox' design philosophy where you're bragging about how many third-party extensions a new version of your app supports. Another vendor would be bragging about how much of third-party functionality they have built in.
- franczesko 7y agoMobile browser development should be the actual focus of Mozilla team.
- nromiun 7y agoIt is much more polished compared to the regular Firefox for mobile. But it is still very slow (network, the UI is very smooth) compared to all other browsers. And I can't force myself to just a handful of extensions when other browsers support all of them. So more waiting I guess.
- akerro 7y agoI'm lost now, there is firefox, firefox klar, firefox preview, firefox focus... what's going on there?
- TsomArp 7y agothat is firefox preview.
- Quanttek 7y agoFirefox Klar is just the German name for Firefox Focus. Also, if you would just open the link - something HN readers often seem to struggle with - the first sentence of the would tell you that this is about Firefox Preview
- lucideer 7y agoThere are currently 3 Firefox browsers on Android 1. Firefox: end-of-life browser built on legacy Firefox engine 2. Firefox Preview: work in progress, soon to replace the old Firefox, rebuilt from scratch on new engine 3. Firefox Focus: a minimal/reduced/simplified browser first developed to pilot the new engine Klar is just the German name for Focus.
- dTal 7y agoThank you for this factual and definitive comment. It's essentially required reading for this thread.
- mappu 7y agoThere are more than these 3. For example Firefox Lite: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.mozilla.rocket&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.mozilla.ro...
- lucideer 7y agoThanks for this. I'd never heard of "Firefox Lite". It appears to be an "Emerging Market Experiment" run by Mozilla Taiwan[0] It also appears to be heavily based on or be a fork of Firefox Focus/Klar[1] [0] https://github.com/mozilla-tw/FirefoxLite https://github.com/mozilla-tw/FirefoxLite [1] https://github.com/mozilla-tw/FirefoxLite/pull/2/files https://github.com/mozilla-tw/FirefoxLite/pull/2/files
- antman 7y agoI think I have a PTSD and I get scared of Firefox announcements. I feel like it is a Russian Roulette of speed improvements or random removal of features. This looks very positive but I don't understand it, I have the extensions installed on my mobile since ages. So I look at the text and it says that it is based on recommended extensions. Recommended on what criteria I always wondered ? Business or security friendly? Or user friendly? How come uBlock is not recommended? That means that "recommended extensions" is not only a label for user assistance but also part of Firefox strategic decision making, oh my. Is it a ploy to finally embed them to the severely limited IPhone experience as preexisting features rather as extensions, a long con to bypass Apple restrictions through initial Android introduction? As I said I don't see what will change for me, I have already installed them for years. And they will stay installed until they become unavailable due to one strategic decision or another.
- jml7c5 7y agoThis is for Firefox Preview (preview as in "for testing"), a rewrite of Firefox for Android. It will eventually be renamed to Firefox for Android.
- antman 7y agoYes it is clear that it will replace Firefox for Android, and as I said my main hope is that it will do so without deprecating parts of current functionality (especially regarding extensions) as it happened with previous main updates.
- jml7c5 7y agoOh dear, they really shouldn't use a gif[1] to demonstrate performance. The low frame-rate makes it look like the UI is stuttering. [1]: https://microsoft.github.io/microsoft-ui-xaml/img/performance2-min.gif https://microsoft.github.io/microsoft-ui-xaml/img/performanc... (drawing a heart over a picture of a dog)
- Yizahi 7y agoSo many people complain about Firefox (current) being "slow", "clunky", have "bad performance" etc. I feel like I'm the only one who is completely fine with performance of this app? I've switched to FF on android fully 3 years ago, first on a phone with SD821, now with SD855. I realize that these are flagship SoCs, but I see people with high-end phones complain about it too. As a control - I also use old and modern iPads with stock Safari. I honestly don't get what the complaints are exactly, it opens as fast as any similar app, all UI controls are responsive (there are some animations, but they are intentional), scrolling is always smooth.
- dathinab 7y agoNo I feel the same I'm using Firefox mobile since years in middle class Android phones and have absolutely no complains about performance. Same for Firefox on Linux btw.
- sopromo 7y agoPerfomance has always been good for me but there are a few bugs that made me question if I should keep using it. On mobile, for example, I sometimes get blank pages when trying to visit a website and it will stop working until I restart the phone (internet is good because any other browser works). It is very rare to happen but it does.
- the_duke 7y agoI share your opinion. BUT, I am also using uBlock Origin with Javascript blocked by default. This makes a huge difference. Otherwise the current Firefox mobile is considerably slower for me than Chrome, especially on uncached sites. Haven't tried Preview yet.
- FirstLvR 7y agosame here, also chrome sandbox is specially useful for me, due work
- wazoox 7y agoYup. I use Firefox as standard browser on my phone, and even on an antiquated Samsung tablet (galaxy tab 3, Android 4.2, dual core and 1GB of RAM) with some extensions, and it's perfectly functional and usable.
- dependenttypes 7y agoNo uBlock Origin? It is much better compared to NoScript.
- greggman3 7y agoI read "for mobile" and was hopefully this would be for iOS as well but really it's "Firefox for Android" And now all the Apple fans can tell me why it's so great that only WebKit is allowed on iOS. I'd like to run those extensions an on iOS browser and others but to do that I'd have to actually be able to ship a different browser engine.
- kdtsh 7y agoI went back to Safari on iOS. I really quite like iOS - it’s not everyone’s cup of tea, but it is mine. I also quite like Firefox, and have used it since Firefox 3 (except for a few years when I bought into the Google project and used Chrome when it was shiny and new). I used the iOS Firefox app solidly for a little while - more than I year I think - but really, while WebKit is the only engine allowed on iOS, it’s just a skin on Safari with integration into your Firefox Account (which is a fantastic bit of work, but I don’t use it). Sorting tabs and bookmarks in iOS Safari is much nicer in my experience, so I eventually went back. I’ll keep using Firefox on desktop for as long as it exists, but I kind of just faced the music on Firefox for iOS.
- jorvi 7y agoI would be fine with Firefox for iOS not having access to extensions (after all, Mozilla can't help it Apple's app store policies won't allow that), but they could at least have some mercy on iOS users and just build in adblocking.. the web is borderline unusable without it.
- michaelbrooks 7y agoThis is the exact reason why I use Brave on IOS, it has built-in adblocking that works really well.
- lbeltrame 7y agoDoes anyone know if this version of Firefox for Mobile can use self-hosted sync servers (even if using Firefox accounts)? According to this GH issue[1] it is possible at least for the sync server part (not for the full account management), but I don't know if it made it into a stable release. [1] https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/fenix/issues/3762 https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/fenix/issues/3762
- thiht 7y agoThe HN title is misleading, this is specifically about Firefox Preview, not Firefox Mobile which has supported these extensions for a while now. It should be edited.
- ryuukk_ 7y agostop with the mozilla spam, fucking website full of bots