3 ms·
> I guess that for each of them, there is some kind of unspeakable reason that trumps any sound rationale. I think the general unspeakable reason is pretty sim
by pdonis 7y ago
> I guess that for each of them, there is some kind of unspeakable reason that trumps any sound rationale.
I think the general unspeakable reason is pretty simple: once you give people power, some of them will misuse it. And since it takes more effort to correct a misuse of power than to commit the misuse in the first place, any institution that gives people power becomes more and more corrupt over time as misuses of power outweigh valid uses of power.
- ghaff 7y agoWhile I'm mostly in Camp Inclusion, I appreciate the issues that tend to come up as you loosen criteria for articles more and more--you probably inevitably get articles that are "notable" to a narrower and narrower set of people and a lot of verification depends on shakier and harder to access sources. That said, it's pretty clear that there are more than a few Wikipedia admins who seem to have embraced deletionism for topics that aren't near and dear to them personally and/or which poke at whatever their particular political hot buttons are.
- kragen 7y agoThe nice thing about Wikis in general is that it's usually easier to correct a misuse of the power to edit a page than it is to commit the misuse in the first place. That's why Wikis work at all.
- narag 7y agoThat works for the power to edit, not for the power to delete. So it makes sense, yes.
- ooobit2 7y agoNot just some people, nearly all will abuse it. But we've seen this more-so in people who are less familiar with these institutions. Baltimore, MD, for example, has had now two black, female mayors convicted of corruption and removed from office. We've seen the current mayor of Chicago attempt authoritarianism to enforce the stay-at-home order. Michigan's mayor has reached far beyond CDC and NHS recommendations, and now faces possible corruption charges over abuse of power. Maine's governor is also in the spotlight for circumventing checks and balances by the legislature on the executive office. People love AOC, and I too believe she means well, but even she has warped into an anarcho-syndicalist, going so far as to make absurd statements that "incremental change isn't working", when everyone knows governance is a complex, incremental series of processes, necessary to maintain a free republic and limit opportunities for tyranny. Omar has had a sexual affair with a senior member of her staff. Tlaib has been censured for collaborating with anti-semitic organizations on official business. Biden, himself, has now managed over a year of avoiding investigations into how his son secured a chair on a Ukrainian energy board and was on that board during negotiations between the Obama-Biden administration and Ukraine related to that company's finances. It's cute that people like John Oliver continue to say that the rise of fascism isn't obvious, that it happens slow, subtle. But abuses of power and position are everywhere right now, especially among anti-Trump activists in the media and Congress. You might agree that Trump is a racist, but taking that very position is complicit with the anarcho-syndicalism among a growing number of leftist politicians now. Keep an air of skepticism about you for your own safety. Just because 75% of us think a hate speech law is a reasonable circumvention of free speech guarantees doesn't mean we aren't also enabling scope creep. As we've seen thus far, "slippery slope" is a fallacy in everything but governance.